“1.) Appraiser to state he also reviewed the final hud I settlement stmt from the builders file for each sale" - Client sent this request after submission of our URAR 1004 Form Report. - Subject and 2 comps are new construction. 3 other comps are resales. - Is our response appropriate? "Please confirm the intent of this request. To us this is a new 'never-seen-before' requirement. If our understanding is correct, the client requires that the appraiser reviews the FINAL Closing Statement (HUD1) for each comparable sale. (Presumably AFTER the closing & signed by the buyer(s) and seller(s)). While we are sometimes provided with a "PRELIMINARY" HUD1 - we are not authorized to DEMAND access to, what the principals might consider, to be a confidential document. Does this new requirement mean that we cannot use 'comps' if the SIGNED, FINAL HUD1 is unavailable, for whatever reason?