• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Appraiser's Requiring Fixes Before He'll Do Appraisal?

Status
Not open for further replies.

poptart11

Freshman Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2017
Professional Status
Real Estate Agent or Broker
State
Utah
I am an agent that is working with a buyer on a new build. We have been holding off on the appraisal for about a week because the appraiser said that he would not come out until the home was complete. We finally got the C.O. and let the appraiser know. He told the selling agent he would come out today (Saturday) and then showed up Friday morning. He did not complete the appraisal as he says that the home is NOT complete and then sent over a list of things he wants done before he'll come back and do the appraisal. Mind you, we've got the C.O. A couple of things on his list....fix the grading in the backyard (it's construction grade and passed inspection), the foundation plaster needs to be done (we are being told by the builder this is not necessary and is not included), and that the AC cement pad has no drainage to avoid major settlement so it needs to be fixed. He also wants extensions on the gutters. He let us know that if he comes back to do the appraisal and these things are not done and the home is not indeed completed, he'll charge the buyers an additional $100.

I have done several transactions with new builds and have never been given a list of things we need to do before an appraisal will be done. The buyers are being told that the lender cannot talk to the appraiser about the list, only the buyers but they are afraid to say anything as they don't want it to affect the appraisal. Can an appraiser make these kinds of demands?? The home has already passed city inspection!

Thanks for any insight!!
 
Can he make the demands? Probably. Should he? Probably not. Some lenders are picky about final completion, some are not. It could be the appraiser has experience with an AMC/Lender that is picky about the house being very complete. CO's vary with building inspectors. I've had home owner's show me the CO and are living in the house, but there's one toilet not set because it broke and the doors not hung because they needed to be re-painted. So CO's don't mean much.

I don't sweat the small stuff, but I take lots of pictures. Its a reasonable assumption, along with most state 1-year warranties, that the piddly stuff will in deed be completed and won't jeopordize anybody's interest. YMMV.
 
Last edited:
In my market, you can get a Certificate of Occupancy on a new home with no floor coverings, so yeah, as Elliott said, the CO doesn't mean much.

Appraisers are required to point out drainage issues, so gutter extentions (or splash blocks), A/C pad drainage, and final grading are expected to be completed. If the foundation is ICF foam block, a protective coating to prevent degradation is common in my market. We can't see the subject from this forum, so these may or may not be issues. Also, my reinspection fee is $150. :)

On the surface, the appraiser requests do not appear to be unreasonable, and perhaps he is even trying to save the borrower a reinspection fee.

Good luck!
 
even trying to save the borrower a reinspection fee.
Sounds like the appraiser has been burned over trivial items before. And nothing more wasted in time for all than doing inspections. Went back three times once, tile in bathroom, floor covering in bathroom, no interior door trim, unhung closet doors, and no dishwasher. Each time the homeowner was shocked that all that was required. Finally, it got down to the AC registers and a couple of light fixtures and bank said close enough.
 
The Salt Lake City COO would seem rather thin in its coverage-
 

Attachments

  • upload_2017-6-17_9-57-42.png
    upload_2017-6-17_9-57-42.png
    107.6 KB · Views: 11
I agree with the others regarding the C of O - it can be helpful, but isn't the End All completed
It could be the appraiser has experience with an AMC/Lender that is picky about the house being very complete.
Agreed. Some clients (AMCs or direct lenders) are pickier than others as Terrel points out
Finally, it got down to the AC registers and a couple of light fixtures and bank said close enough.
I've run into this before and also the extreme opposite!
 
I would have made the report subject to those items being completed.
 
IMO, what the appraiser should have done is cleared the process with the lender first.
The lender is the client. The lender can send the appraiser out there multiple times if it wants to.

However, let's assume the appraiser is working in concert with what the lender would want, which is the ideal situation
. If that is the case, then I agree with the others: The appraiser is providing some important information to the stakeholders regarding what will impact the appraisal. I won't comment on the specifics that the appraiser is suggesting be finished, but knowing what items may and may not create potential appraisal delays is generally in the best interests of all parties concerned.

If there is disagreement with what the appraiser is asking to be completed and what is going to be completed, that is an issue between (a) the appraiser and the lender and (b) the borrower and the lender.

The appraiser cannot force anyone to do anything they don't want to do. The appraiser can (and this sounds like the case) inform the parties what items may cause delays with the appraisal process. Forewarned is forearmed.

Good luck!
 
I am an agent that is working with a buyer on a new build. We have been holding off on the appraisal for about a week because the appraiser said that he would not come out until the home was complete. We finally got the C.O. and let the appraiser know. He told the selling agent he would come out today (Saturday) and then showed up Friday morning. He did not complete the appraisal as he says that the home is NOT complete and then sent over a list of things he wants done before he'll come back and do the appraisal. Mind you, we've got the C.O. A couple of things on his list....fix the grading in the backyard (it's construction grade and passed inspection), the foundation plaster needs to be done (we are being told by the builder this is not necessary and is not included), and that the AC cement pad has no drainage to avoid major settlement so it needs to be fixed. He also wants extensions on the gutters. He let us know that if he comes back to do the appraisal and these things are not done and the home is not indeed completed, he'll charge the buyers an additional $100.

I have done several transactions with new builds and have never been given a list of things we need to do before an appraisal will be done. The buyers are being told that the lender cannot talk to the appraiser about the list, only the buyers but they are afraid to say anything as they don't want it to affect the appraisal. Can an appraiser make these kinds of demands?? The home has already passed city inspection!

Thanks for any insight!!

Go forth with the knowledge you glean here and educate your peers who complain about Appraisers and CO's in your state. :):):)
 
The normal course of events here would have been to complete the appraisal "subject to" completion of the list of items. Then the client would have sent me back to check for completion, each time paying me an additional $200 inspection fee until all are completed. Even though the OP is upset, it seems the end result will be pretty much the same, but likely saving the borrower $200+ in fees.

My "subject to" lists are infrequent, but when they are necessary I explain each item in simple to understand terms & include photos. Even so, it's quite often that whoever is completing the checklist omits at least one of the items, thereby requiring me to go back for 2 inspections. It's usually due to laziness on the seller's / agent's / owner's part, but I'm not complaining when I get paid an extra $400 for mostly short drive times.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top