• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

C Condition, Fannie Mae Clarified

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tom D

Elite Member
Gold Supporting Member
Joined
May 22, 2015
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Pennsylvania
i had my 1st CU stip. i have a 1.5 year old house that CU said i should rate as c1, or c2. now maybe i was napping when they wrote that advisement originally, but i will not argue. i renamed it a c2. assuming that to be the new meaning of c2 i humble requesting some appraiser group clarification. assuming that the actual age of a house is also it's effective age, then at what year-s would a c1 become a c2, a c2 become a c3. and how old an effective age to become a c4. seems like going back to new, good, gd/av, avg but i'm not sure what the CU group thought is now.
the refi craze is happening year after year, it seems like, with the same house. your help is appreciated.
 
A new house with no DNA is C-1. Once a car is driven off the lot, it becomes a C-2 to the market IMO. If you super maintained it, I'd think you could maintain a C2 for 2, maybe 2.5 years, but then it becomes a C3, if its like most newer homes. Some HO bring enough dirt with them that a house could easily become a C-3 in two months. I remember doing a final inspection on a new custom construction, and there was a toddler dragging a half full diaper behind her....not C1 in my opinion. Lottery winner.
 
Last edited:
I agree. A C1 has no DNA in it. Upon the first f@rt, it becomes a C2. With the exception of super high-end inventory, I'll call it a C2 for up to three years maybe four on a very rare occasion. FannieMae's obsession with C-ratings is bordering on the absurd. Who the fk cares what I call it. It all depends on how it compares with the competition and how I account for that as an appraiser.

Looking for the bottom of the gene pool? Step inside a FannieMae office.
 
A new house with no DNA is C-1. Once a car is driven off the lot, it becomes a C-2 to the market IMO. If you super maintained it, I'd think you could maintain a C2 for 2, maybe 2.5 years, but then it becomes a C3, if its like most newer homes
:clapping: well said and agreed

Tom D, I think you could call it c2 or c3 ... again, it's your opinion as the guy on the ground. Gotta love the CU, huh?!
 
A house one year and six months old is NOT a C 3 , unless it was left open tor weather /or had people abuse its condition down.

All you have to do is read the condition ratings, and follow them. The verbiage on the UAD definitions describes the differences between condition. There is no official cut off point when C 3 becomes C 3, but I agree with TxTea, normally around 3 years or so...again see what C 2 is on the UAD definitions, is like new.
 
C-2 then move on BUT not a C-3 . Read the definition Fannie provides!
 
:clapping: well said and agreed

Tom D, I think you could call it c2 or c3 ... again, it's your opinion as the guy on the ground. Gotta love the CU, huh?!

i did call it a c3, CU made me change it. i then said c2, but apparently by the spewed clarification it could still be a c1 because of no perceived depreciation.

i always, because of my old urban area, considered a new rehabd dwelling, not moved in house, to be the c2 definition. i have always done that, but this time i accepted the "new clarification" but am now having flashbacks to pre certification condition meanings confusion.
 
it could still be a c1 because of no perceived depreciation.

It CAN NOT be a c1 if it has been lived in/occupied at all,, even for a week ! That is Fannie, not up to you or me, they have specific qualifications for the C ratings in the definitions and C 1 is never been occupied..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top