Jim Vincent
Freshman Member
- Joined
- Jan 6, 2005
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- Connecticut
Hello,
An estate property is being sold via a conventional mortgage. It has some issues with damaged kitchen and baths and "discoloration" on parts of the ceiling and is rated at C5. The original engagement letter does not mention any points like making a hypothetical condition that any such repairs had been made for purposes of the report.
The client requests the report be "subject to repairs to bring the property to C4 condition" with a list of such items made. A few months later, such repairs are made and a 1004D Cert of completion made to that effect. Now the client wants to have the condition rating in the original report changed "to a condition rating of C4 subject to repairs necessary"
How does this sound to you? Despite the completion of repairs, it would seem to be a new assignment as the condition at the original effective date is what it is, and any change in rating would affect things like conditional adjustments to the comps and ultimately the opinion of value.
An estate property is being sold via a conventional mortgage. It has some issues with damaged kitchen and baths and "discoloration" on parts of the ceiling and is rated at C5. The original engagement letter does not mention any points like making a hypothetical condition that any such repairs had been made for purposes of the report.
The client requests the report be "subject to repairs to bring the property to C4 condition" with a list of such items made. A few months later, such repairs are made and a 1004D Cert of completion made to that effect. Now the client wants to have the condition rating in the original report changed "to a condition rating of C4 subject to repairs necessary"
How does this sound to you? Despite the completion of repairs, it would seem to be a new assignment as the condition at the original effective date is what it is, and any change in rating would affect things like conditional adjustments to the comps and ultimately the opinion of value.