Davy
Sophomore Member
- Joined
- Oct 3, 2016
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- North Carolina
Am I missing something here? I was sent a check for an FHA appraisal from a financial company for an FHA appraisal I did for another institution. Ummm, what? Do we get paid as many times as the report goes from lender to lender? Am I missing something?
The financial institution that sent me the check called me yesterday and stated, "We have UPS'd you a check for the appraisal you did for Ms. "XXXXX" at "XXXXXX" Street." I said for them to send me an email requesting the report in question to give me time to research, because I could not remember the bank/client I was doing this for originally and maybe this is the same bank and they are confused or something. Well, I confirmed that this is a different bank altogether and that this financial company was basically asking me to assign/release them the appraisal. Their email contained a copy of a letter from the borrower stating that, "It was OK for me to do that, blah blah." I'm smart enough to know that I cannot legally reassign an appraisal and that such a request can only legally be handled as a new appraisal assignment with a new inspection, etc. But....
Here is where it gets interesting: the email request they sent me is cc'd to a number of people within their company. I thought I would take myself out of the loop and include the original lender's company name, the compliance officer who ordered the appraisal from me, etc., along with a clear statement that I cannot legally reassign this report and for them to contact the person and company I originally did the appraisal for....
...Well, one of the VPs cc'd in the email replied to the dude making the request that they had the FHA number reassigned to them and I didn't need to do anything on my part. Also, the original lender's compliance officer stated the same thing and said they'll give the other company the report and I don't have to act at all.
Today I received a substantial check for the FHA report. Full fee. Ummm, what? I though they were joking about sending me a check and using that as a pressure tactic to have me possibly do something illegal. So, the financial company that wants the appraisal reassigned to them gets it from the client, BUT pays me for it even though it was already paid for by the original bank. Is this an anomaly? I have not done FHA appraisals very long, so my stupid question is, "Am I missing something and does this have anything to do with the way that the FHA does things?" I plead ignorance on the subject and I am unsure that I can legally (or ethically) collect fees on the report (again) in question.
My gut tells me to tear up or return the check since the report was paid for already. My flesh wants to tell me that it's OK to cash the check since the other financial institution wants to pay for it (I'm all about making them happy, right?) lol BTW, there is no property address of the subject on the check or the check stub...
Opinions? I want to do the right thing here.
The financial institution that sent me the check called me yesterday and stated, "We have UPS'd you a check for the appraisal you did for Ms. "XXXXX" at "XXXXXX" Street." I said for them to send me an email requesting the report in question to give me time to research, because I could not remember the bank/client I was doing this for originally and maybe this is the same bank and they are confused or something. Well, I confirmed that this is a different bank altogether and that this financial company was basically asking me to assign/release them the appraisal. Their email contained a copy of a letter from the borrower stating that, "It was OK for me to do that, blah blah." I'm smart enough to know that I cannot legally reassign an appraisal and that such a request can only legally be handled as a new appraisal assignment with a new inspection, etc. But....
Here is where it gets interesting: the email request they sent me is cc'd to a number of people within their company. I thought I would take myself out of the loop and include the original lender's company name, the compliance officer who ordered the appraisal from me, etc., along with a clear statement that I cannot legally reassign this report and for them to contact the person and company I originally did the appraisal for....
...Well, one of the VPs cc'd in the email replied to the dude making the request that they had the FHA number reassigned to them and I didn't need to do anything on my part. Also, the original lender's compliance officer stated the same thing and said they'll give the other company the report and I don't have to act at all.
Today I received a substantial check for the FHA report. Full fee. Ummm, what? I though they were joking about sending me a check and using that as a pressure tactic to have me possibly do something illegal. So, the financial company that wants the appraisal reassigned to them gets it from the client, BUT pays me for it even though it was already paid for by the original bank. Is this an anomaly? I have not done FHA appraisals very long, so my stupid question is, "Am I missing something and does this have anything to do with the way that the FHA does things?" I plead ignorance on the subject and I am unsure that I can legally (or ethically) collect fees on the report (again) in question.
My gut tells me to tear up or return the check since the report was paid for already. My flesh wants to tell me that it's OK to cash the check since the other financial institution wants to pay for it (I'm all about making them happy, right?) lol BTW, there is no property address of the subject on the check or the check stub...
Opinions? I want to do the right thing here.