The Sheriff
Member
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2007
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- Arizona
Long story short, my parents live in a cookie cutter townhouse neighborhood in Manassas, VA, that was built between 1963-1965. I remodeled their 1,165 sq ft place over the last nine months (approximately $27K in improvements - including a new foam roof that was $5K of that $27K). Their house is an interior unit with homes on each side of them and in the middle of the subdivision (no traffic essentially). Typical lot sizes range from 1,440 sq ft to 1,527 sq ft for these homes. The only improvement NOT done to my parents house was the replacement of the upstairs bathtub and the replacement of the interior doors to the rooms and closets (I did paint them though). Everything else in the house was done with modern improvements.
There were two MODEL MATCH sales (no distress issues with them) within 30 days of the 7/19/2016 effective date ranging from $175K (COE: 7/1/2016) to $185K (COE: 6/30/2016). Neither sale was utilized (I verified with the agents that they closed prior to 7/19/2016 as well as cross referenced the tax records). These homes have mild to similar updating as my parents (and that is being generous saying they were similarly updated). But hey, I'll give lipstick on a pig credit as they did something to update those properties. The property that sold for $185K was more similarly updated based on the interior photos. The sale that closed for $175K was more lipstick on a pig - but let's roll with it anyways. These sales were also interior units in the middle of the neighborhood like my folks.
The VA appraiser utilized three MODEL MATCH sales - HOWEVER all three sales are dated compared to the two sales above. The most recent sale on the report was a model match with HEAVY traffic (see my analysis below).
His comp #1 closed for $169,900 on 5/11/2016. He adjusted the property down for $1,000 for a patio (good luck proving any type of paired sales for it). For what's it worth, my parents have a small covered patio as well (as does every model like their house in the neighborhood) - so I'm scratching my head on the adjustment. The adjusted value was $168,900.
His comp #2 closed for $186,000 on 5/24/2016... it's on the same street as my parent's house - six houses away actually - also an interior lot like my parent's house with no traffic influence. No adjustments were made to this sale in the appraisal. The adjusted value was $186,000.
His comp #3 closed for $162,000 with a COE date of 5/2016 per the report. In reality, it closed for $160,000 on 6/1/2016. Comp #3 faces a four lane road at the entrance of the subdivision that receives heavy traffic in the area (he made an $8K adjustment for traffic obsolescence based on a 5% adjustment). The adjusted value in the report was $170,000 for this sale (however it really should have been $168,000 if he had utilized the correct sales price). I won't go into a long diatribe about performing a paired sales analysis and the 5% traffic adjustment - but let's just say this appraiser has been licensed since 1991.
His opinion of value was $170,000.
You're probably thinking what's this guy complaining about?
My perspective... if you use the most recent MODEL MATCH sales and kick out the property with traffic influence, you're left to rely on sale #2 in the original report. You're now looking at a sales range of $175K to $186K with NO adjustments to any of the sales. Two of the model match sales closed for $185K and $186K and the low model match sale is $175K.
I submitted a reconsideration of value to the credit union three weeks ago on behalf of my parents with the two model match sales mentioned above as well as two other sales that were similar bed and bathroom counts, just 65 sq ft larger in size (they also sold for $180K+). The credit union submitted their appraisal reconsideration form to the appraiser on 8/3/2016. Three weeks later, the loan is being held up by the appraiser as he still hasn't done anything or gotten back to the credit union.
The loan process has dragged on for four months now and my parents (older and disabled) are at wits end with the credit union. I'm at wits end with the appraiser (with whom the credit union said hasn't gotten back to them).
It's a VA loan - for those that don't know, you can do 100% LTV on a VA loan. In my parents case, I'm having them utilize 100% of the appraisal amount for medical work that is necessary for my mother that she keeps putting off (but is becoming a major problem for her). So yes, even if the appraiser comes up $5K in his opinion of value to the extreme lower end of the value range of the best available AND most recent MODEL MATCH sales, it does make a difference.
So, do I continue to let the appraiser drag his feet? Should I make a phone call as a professional courtesy - one appraiser to another - without mentioning the sales? Or should I turn the appraisal in to the Virginia state board with my research and let them have at it? I'm certified in another state and I would NOT do it anonymously - I'm a big boy and think the facts are well enough that even my relationship to my parents can be taken out of the equation. A realtor shared with me all the sales in the neighborhood for the previous 90 days - and I did my homework from there by making the phone calls/cross referencing tax records/etc. The model match listings in the neighborhood are all $180K+ for anything with updating and not a foreclosure sale (in case someone is wondering where the listings are sitting).
Your thoughts on the situation?
There were two MODEL MATCH sales (no distress issues with them) within 30 days of the 7/19/2016 effective date ranging from $175K (COE: 7/1/2016) to $185K (COE: 6/30/2016). Neither sale was utilized (I verified with the agents that they closed prior to 7/19/2016 as well as cross referenced the tax records). These homes have mild to similar updating as my parents (and that is being generous saying they were similarly updated). But hey, I'll give lipstick on a pig credit as they did something to update those properties. The property that sold for $185K was more similarly updated based on the interior photos. The sale that closed for $175K was more lipstick on a pig - but let's roll with it anyways. These sales were also interior units in the middle of the neighborhood like my folks.
The VA appraiser utilized three MODEL MATCH sales - HOWEVER all three sales are dated compared to the two sales above. The most recent sale on the report was a model match with HEAVY traffic (see my analysis below).
His comp #1 closed for $169,900 on 5/11/2016. He adjusted the property down for $1,000 for a patio (good luck proving any type of paired sales for it). For what's it worth, my parents have a small covered patio as well (as does every model like their house in the neighborhood) - so I'm scratching my head on the adjustment. The adjusted value was $168,900.
His comp #2 closed for $186,000 on 5/24/2016... it's on the same street as my parent's house - six houses away actually - also an interior lot like my parent's house with no traffic influence. No adjustments were made to this sale in the appraisal. The adjusted value was $186,000.
His comp #3 closed for $162,000 with a COE date of 5/2016 per the report. In reality, it closed for $160,000 on 6/1/2016. Comp #3 faces a four lane road at the entrance of the subdivision that receives heavy traffic in the area (he made an $8K adjustment for traffic obsolescence based on a 5% adjustment). The adjusted value in the report was $170,000 for this sale (however it really should have been $168,000 if he had utilized the correct sales price). I won't go into a long diatribe about performing a paired sales analysis and the 5% traffic adjustment - but let's just say this appraiser has been licensed since 1991.
His opinion of value was $170,000.
You're probably thinking what's this guy complaining about?
My perspective... if you use the most recent MODEL MATCH sales and kick out the property with traffic influence, you're left to rely on sale #2 in the original report. You're now looking at a sales range of $175K to $186K with NO adjustments to any of the sales. Two of the model match sales closed for $185K and $186K and the low model match sale is $175K.
I submitted a reconsideration of value to the credit union three weeks ago on behalf of my parents with the two model match sales mentioned above as well as two other sales that were similar bed and bathroom counts, just 65 sq ft larger in size (they also sold for $180K+). The credit union submitted their appraisal reconsideration form to the appraiser on 8/3/2016. Three weeks later, the loan is being held up by the appraiser as he still hasn't done anything or gotten back to the credit union.
The loan process has dragged on for four months now and my parents (older and disabled) are at wits end with the credit union. I'm at wits end with the appraiser (with whom the credit union said hasn't gotten back to them).
It's a VA loan - for those that don't know, you can do 100% LTV on a VA loan. In my parents case, I'm having them utilize 100% of the appraisal amount for medical work that is necessary for my mother that she keeps putting off (but is becoming a major problem for her). So yes, even if the appraiser comes up $5K in his opinion of value to the extreme lower end of the value range of the best available AND most recent MODEL MATCH sales, it does make a difference.
So, do I continue to let the appraiser drag his feet? Should I make a phone call as a professional courtesy - one appraiser to another - without mentioning the sales? Or should I turn the appraisal in to the Virginia state board with my research and let them have at it? I'm certified in another state and I would NOT do it anonymously - I'm a big boy and think the facts are well enough that even my relationship to my parents can be taken out of the equation. A realtor shared with me all the sales in the neighborhood for the previous 90 days - and I did my homework from there by making the phone calls/cross referencing tax records/etc. The model match listings in the neighborhood are all $180K+ for anything with updating and not a foreclosure sale (in case someone is wondering where the listings are sitting).
Your thoughts on the situation?