tpoettker
Freshman Member
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2010
- Professional Status
- Appraiser Trainee
- State
- Illinois
I have an order for a duplex not in a HOA with amenities such as pools, clubhouse, lawn maintenance, exterior maintenance, etc. It is one side of a duplex on it owned site. It has not been updated in 20+ years (actually has a 1960 appearance).
Duplexes within a 5 mile radius range from $40,000 to $162,000 with GLA range of 1100 sf to 1700 (subject is 1816 sf). Subject also has 2 bedrooms above ground and 1 bedroom (legal bedroom) and 1 full bath in the walk-out basement. Owners (executor of the estate) had an appraisal performed in August, 2015. The appraise estimated market value was $230,000. Property was purchased in 2007 for $250,000 and mine subsidence claim paid in 2010 for approximately $76,000.
I obtained a copy of the August appraisal because I was struggling to locate comps to support the contract price. The appraiser utilized comp that were 2 bedrooms above ground like subject but were 20 years newer and in a condo HOA that included pools clubhouse, tennis counts, lawn maintenance and exterior maintenance.
Imo, appraiser did not use appropriate comps. I am documenting how and why I used the comps I did and adjustments I made. In your opinion would I mention my review of the other appraisal and why I disagree?
Duplexes within a 5 mile radius range from $40,000 to $162,000 with GLA range of 1100 sf to 1700 (subject is 1816 sf). Subject also has 2 bedrooms above ground and 1 bedroom (legal bedroom) and 1 full bath in the walk-out basement. Owners (executor of the estate) had an appraisal performed in August, 2015. The appraise estimated market value was $230,000. Property was purchased in 2007 for $250,000 and mine subsidence claim paid in 2010 for approximately $76,000.
I obtained a copy of the August appraisal because I was struggling to locate comps to support the contract price. The appraiser utilized comp that were 2 bedrooms above ground like subject but were 20 years newer and in a condo HOA that included pools clubhouse, tennis counts, lawn maintenance and exterior maintenance.
Imo, appraiser did not use appropriate comps. I am documenting how and why I used the comps I did and adjustments I made. In your opinion would I mention my review of the other appraisal and why I disagree?