• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Data Sharing - Costar, Et Al

Status
Not open for further replies.

PL1957

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2004
Professional Status
Certified General Appraiser
State
Illinois
Commentary on data sharing from a slightly different perspective ...

https://www.bisnow.com/national/new...are-still-skeptical-about-sharing-data-80198?

"Although commercial real estate has been famously sluggish in its technology adoption, the industry's reluctance may stem from having been burned in the past.

Such was the case when industry professionals turned to data providers like CoStar to share information, Reonomy founder and CEO Rich Sarkis said during a panel at Wednesday’s MIPIM PropTech NYC Summit in Midtown.

“Once upon a time, they started giving their data to some of the data providers like CoStar and others and then that data was taken, repackaged and sold back to the brokerage firms … it [was] no longer [their] data,” Sarkis said. “I think there’s this psychological block now that’s saying, 'conceptually, we understand that sharing our data is more valuable and we are willing to give to get, but then how do you ensure we’re able to use our data and that it's still ours?’”
 
“[Professionals] should not be collecting data, cleansing it and housing it; machines are infinitely better at doing that,” Sarkis said. "Let humans at the brokerage firms and other companies through the CRE ecosystem look at the data sets and spot the trends."

If machines could ever do a half-decent job of verifying real estate data most of us would be out of a job. Perhaps it will get to that point someday, but there's still a ways to go. Is a machine going to talk to the broker who tells you that the seller's husband just died and the wife just wanted to get rid of the property and took the first offer that came along? Or that there was $300,000 in deferred maintenance and the buyer beat up the seller to drop the price by $400,000? Or that the broker had to show up a half-hour early before showing the property to clear out all the homeless that were sleeping around the building because it was in a bad neighborhood near the drop-off site for the county jail?

I was recently working on a difficult property, a large vacant Class A office building in a small city. I was looking nationally for data and found several promising leads through Real Capital Analytics. The first one it turned out the building was only 55,000 square feet, not 110,000 so the price per square foot doubled and it was not a good comp for my 110,000 square foot building. The next one turned out to be twice as large as RCA indicated, over 300,000 square feet and so the purchase price per square foot was half what they indicated. A third one was purchased and immediately demolished to make a parking lot - no mention of that in the comp. I've heard tales of CoStar having all of their dozens of data fields filled out for properties in larger markets and that would be great if it were all accurate. At the end of the day though, garbage in - garbage out. Without a knowledgeable human being to scrub and filter that data - especially for heterogeneous data like commercial real estate, it's always going to be suspect.
 
That is why companies like Compstak are breaking through. If you give them data then they give it back for free. The people that pay are the ones that need information, but don't have any to give.
 
My feeling is that CoStar is so dominant that it is getting in its own way. The data is more shallow today than I found it over the last few years (since the recession through 2016 maybe?). I've been a customer/user since the 1980s. I thought it might be that this year they reduced their "TTP-budget" ("Talk to People" budget) too much and/or lost their better researchers, but I am personally sensing a reluctance from brokers to share detailed financials and transaction details, supporting the article.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top