• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Enclosed Porch/den/office/sitting Room?

Status
Not open for further replies.

JCONNOR3

Sophomore Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2007
Professional Status
Certified General Appraiser
State
Florida
Here in Florida it is quite common to enclose the the area shown by the county as a porch. It is known as a Florida Room. In the past the room was probably less than complete finish consistent with the balance of the house. Say plastic windows and floor coverings.

However as of the past few years we are seeing finishing out of this area with knee wall, therma pane windows, same floor covering as the balance of the house and venting of central a/c. The giveaway is the sliding glass doors left in place. Other than that the room looks and feels like a continuation of the main housing area.

The question is how do you treat it? Is it an enclosed porch or is it part of the overall floor plans? Interested in your thoughts.
 
I often base whether to include it as GLA if it has a permit or not. Even without a permit, I might include it in GLA if the space is well finished to rest of house and no sliding glass doors in place. But when it has sliding glass doors in place and no permit, I treat it as an enclosed FL RM /porch ( and it gets valued as a separate line item, usually there are other comps with similar enclosed Fl rms)

Usually with sliding doors in place there is a step down- so it is not "really" on a par with rest of house as in a storm/heavy rain it is not well protected from water seepage- how do I know I did it without permit in my own house step down and if I had to do it over, would have paid to have it done right with a permit they will raise the floor too)
 
Last edited:
The giveaway is the sliding glass doors left in place. Other than that the room looks and feels like a continuation of the main housing area.

The question is how do you treat it? Is it an enclosed porch or is it part of the overall floor plans? Interested in your thoughts.
I run into this often here in my market (Tampa/St Pete) and I agree with RK
Does it have the same utility of the rest of the GLA, cooled/heated, finished? If so, it is GLA. However, the market will tell you if buyers recognize it as GLA.
I often have borrower's and/or agents saying "it's heated/cooled" but I throw in the caveat "...but is it finished similar/same as the rest of the dwelling?" Even with sliding glass doors,there are times I will count it in the overall GLA because it is truly similar to the rest of the house, as you mention. Most neighborhoods here in my area accept this as GLA. The problem is when that area is NOT finished similar to the rest of the house ... and agents count that in the overall square footage on MLS. That is why (at least IMO) it is even more important that we actually verify the Sq Ft used on MLS. Sometimes that "enclosed porch" area can be significant (300-600sf)
 
I have relatives in the St Pete, Venice, and Pt Charlotte areas. All have these rooms/areas but the glass doors have been removed.

My only concern is that they all have a step down into the area even though they are finished either the same as or very similar to the main house; I'd consider it GLA on their homes.

I have to wonder how many of the residents, especially the older ones, have broken hips/ankles/arms because of that step up/down. I fully expect to someday hear that my mom has fallen and broken something because of this room. I wonder if there's any market resistance from the older crowd due to the step down feature/hazard?
 
I have relatives in the St Pete, Venice, and Pt Charlotte area. All have these rooms/areas but the glass doors have been removed.

My only concern is that they all have a step down into the area even though they are finished either the same as or very similar to the main house; I'd consider it GLA on their homes.

I have to wonder how many of the residents, especially the older ones, have broken hips/ankles/arms because of that step up/down. I fully expect to someday hear that my mom has fallen and broken something because of this room. I wonder if there's any market resistance from the older crowd due to the step down feature/hazard?

Here is how I look at it. A step down room rarely has a permit. Because a permit means the room is up to code, including raising the floor above a floodable area, even if it is just 8 inches. It cost more to build to code, (including roof ) and the house is then assessed at higher taxes due to larger living area on record, which is why people expand rooms without a permit. In an older home, I dont' apply that standard, because so much construction in an older home is funky and even if it had a permit, the building codes were different than now. Homewoner insurance may not cover these areas if not in permit ?

I don't think old folks are the problem re tripping though it could be a concern. The point is that even if the market recognized non permitted step down with glass slider enclosed space as living area, we as appraisers know it is not to code because of the step down. So we can value it as the market does as a separate line item, but not include it in the permitted/county recorded GLA. There are always exceptions to anything on a case by case basis
 
Last edited:
while it doesn't happen as often here as it most like it does in florida we have the same thing. finished similar and heated/cooled are what i look for. the step down, not so much. been in more than my fair share of houses that have one step differences between rooms and/or sections of the house, mostly older (70s) construction - sunken living rooms, kitchens one or two steps higher than the dining room and let's not forget split levels with 3-5 steps per level.
 
It's not the step down per se, as you note in areas where houses with step down portions split level or sunken living rooms of original build.

In FL, the step down to a porch level means usually hardly any clearance above ground level (whereas main house is raised by foundation ), also these step down porch areas often have a flat roof not the same as pitched roof on rest of house. The AC system can be "bootlegged " from origina venting, and homeowner insurance may not cover rebuild of these areas if non permitted.

It is a tough call when inside, the area is finished nicely and it's on MLS as living area. I find the value can end up the same if it is appraised as a separate value line item vs included in SF....the hard part can be finding similar comps because MLS treats it as one living area and the listings vs public records SF and verifying differences is needed.

Now matter how we value these areas, someone can argue it should have been done "the other way"....
 
the step down, not so much. been in more than my fair share of houses that have one step differences between rooms and/or sections of the house, mostly older (70s) construction - sunken living rooms,

Sunken living rooms were a horrible idea, one that fortunately had a fairly short life span in this area. Many of the sunken living rooms in this area have been converted to the same level as the rest of the house. A few hundred $ in floor joists, plywood and some new carpet turns these rooms back to normal.

If I was older (actually I don't want one now), I wouldn't want a sunken room or lower level porch. Mom is in her 80's and between her rat-like dog underfoot and this Florida-room thing, she's destined to take a fall. I've seen it too often; trip over a gum wrapper, fall, break a hip, go into the hospital, never recover.
 
Last edited:
Interested in your thoughts
If different construction (regardless the "near" identical finish) and framing, it is not gross living area. It is off grade.
the market will tell you
The market may tell you that it is received just like GLA, but it still isn't GLA. I would segregate the two areas, and adjust accordingly even if the identical factor (say $50/SF) Otherwise you can distort the value inadvertently.

Example, appraised a house in a cookie cutter subdivision that had several sales of similar homes. This house, however, was identical to the rest except they had enclosed the garage and finished it out with only a minimal difference in finish to the rest of the house, and, of course, somewhat newer appearance... (15 vs. 4 or so yr. age) In the process, they lost the garage unlike every other home in the subdivision. Had I used the indicated SF adjustment, I would have adjusted over 25% to the GLA. I went outside the subdivision and found some conversions where they didn't build a new garage. The difference in price was very muted, and the offsetting loss of the garage otherwise somewhat a guessing game. I preferred to extract the loss of garage value first, then try to judge the impact of the off grade space. It's not a lot of fun and difficult to determine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top