• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Has This Happened To You?

Status
Not open for further replies.

NachoPerito

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2012
Professional Status
Certified General Appraiser
State
Washington
I got engaged to do an appraisal for a foreclosure (client is the bank holding the note).

Before inspecting the property I get a bidding opportunity from the bank that is financing the new pending sale for that very same property...
 
You might have a problem with the 2nd Lender when you tell them you have appraised the subject property recently.
 
Once or twice had something similar happen. Usually it's been a borrower shopping around and two different lenders order appraisals for the same property. In one case the second lender engaged us a few days after the first appraisal was completed and asked for a rush job - we may have got a bit greedy on the fee in that particular case but they were willing to pay it.
 
I got engaged to do an appraisal for a foreclosure (client is the bank holding the note).

Before inspecting the property I get a bidding opportunity from the bank that is financing the new pending sale for that very same property...

I would disclose to the second client that you're currently appraising the property for another client and check with the first client if they're ok with you appraising it for another client. Some of our lender clients have a policy where they require permission if you're engaged to appraise the same property for a different client within a year. They've pretty much always granted permission but in a case like this I can see where they might deny it.
 
how greedy can you get just decline to do the purchase appraisal, you've already agreed with first client to do their REO appraisal. you can ask but I highly doubt the bank would want you to be both appraiser for purchaser and their internal use appraiser for their purpose.
 
Thanks for the replies.

The important thing to do is not alienate one of my clients over one assignment.

I am inclined to turn down the purchase appraisal, but it is possible that the 2nd scenario results in a cancellation of the first appraisal. If that happens by monday then I would go ahead and bid on the 2nd appraisal.

I wouldn't call it greed because in situations like this I give discounts to people and it works out for them quite a bit to get an appraisal for a lot cheaper than normal.

In this case though.... is it unethical to appraise two properties at the same time if both clients give the ok to do it?
 
I don't personally think it is unethical provided both clients give okay, but if it were me I still would not do it, because if there is a problem later with the property/file/borrower, the charge could
be made there was a conflict of interest in doing two appraisals or that one assignment influenced results of the other. Even if untrue, the charge could be made. It's a situation that why go there...surely there are other assignments with similar fees that will come along soon?

Normally a purchase assignment does not cancel the REO assignment, if anything it green lights it....the bank owner wants to make sure the buyer is not under paying for property (in which case they would deny the offer or re negotiate , or they could have other internal reasons for the appraisal)
 
In this case though.... is it unethical to appraise two properties at the same time if both clients give the ok to do it?

If you have to ask you probably already know the answer. Its a can of worms. Do the REO one and don't bid on the purchase.
 
Often (usually) on lender order of REO where there is a purchase contract the lender client does not want the appraiser aware of the sales contract price...they want to see if a buyer is trying to get the property under market value, for example.
 
If you have good relationships with both clients, it shouldn't be a problem. They both called you for your expertise, right? I'd make sure I got both clients to sign off.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top