• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Is This Grounds For A New Appraisal? County Demands Granny To Return To 1200 Sq Ft

Status
Not open for further replies.

JoeBlowRealestate

Freshman Member
Joined
May 11, 2016
Professional Status
General Public
State
California
When the appraiser arrived to appraise several buildings, primary, granny adu and work shop(illegal garage conversion) he ignored ignored all my concerns and the rules of our County. He gave the illegal buildings higher prices than the legal building, well today guess who called? The County's Code Compliance and Code enforcement said they want the granny-house or secondary ADU brought back up to code and compliance. The builders did not pay the correct costs associated with the dwelling, they overbuilt greatly and the appraiser gave them full value.

If the County wants the house returned to code, how is this going to impact the value of the appraisal because he did not mention the granny house's extra illegal square feet even after we told him the County was cracking down due to a Grand Jury case where the County was accused of allow too many things to slide. Would you say having the County begin action against a house is material? They said "the owner of the granny house can not just put up some "As is No Warranty" because the seller can get sued. What do I do now, who do I call to get the appraisal corrected since the City has been on a roll lately making people remove illegal projects? He's the appraiser who said the illegal garage-to-apartment conversion can be valued using the "contribution model" or used for Air BNB even though the City and County said "Nobody can inhabit this building and if we find anyone living there we will take you to court plus charge you legal fees". Did we hire someone who did not understand the local code enforcement rules because even someone like me would not pay full price for a building a government agency wants half of it taken out. Who can I contact to correct the original appraisal numbers and challenge his valuation assumptions that illegal conversions and unpermitted additional square feet exceeding the size of the Primary or Main house is not a good thing if the City and County are going to sue the honors to reduce the size of the house?



Is there a agency that regulates appraisers because he has not been helpful and ignored all my concerns. Now with the City wanting the extra space removed how can he justify his valuations? If the people who are putting me and my father with dementia through misery were not so bad I would not talk to the City and ignore their calls. Who can help sort to see if the original appraisal had any merit since the County is going to go after both illegal structures. I apologize for asking this but I am tired of being bullied and having my dad with dementia get bullied after he enabled them to live for such low rent for decades because the breadwinner decided to take off life until he was 45 years old. Thank you and please remember the family members you might be helping could easily turn on you like they did to my parents, no natural affection.
 
Last edited:
When you say appraiser...are you referring to an independent fee appraiser or an assessor?
How long have these improvements existed? If new(er), did the builder submit plans to the county? Did the builder build something different than what was on the plans?

Little hard to follow your post...while you have obviously been dealing with this issue up close and frustrated, this is the first we've heard any of it. Provide some basics. What exists, how long has it existed, DIY or contractor improvements, who valued what when, what exactly is the county saying, etc. I know there is an emotional element to all this but we really can't opine about how you feel in any way that would be truly helpful. There will likely be helpful suggestions when there is more factual information we can digest.

These situations can get confusing. Timelines and outlines of facts can identify gaps in your data and greatly aid your own understanding of a situation...perhaps answer a few of your own questions along the way.
 
Last edited:
Excellent question, Artemis!

I have been involved in litigation (in California... I was hired as an expert consultant) in a situation that involved an accessory unit that was built in excess of the 1,200sf maximum size limit.
It was a mess for my client.
 
Which County?

Example:


It’s a LEGAL Issue.
Don’t forget that in addition to the steps that it takes to get the permits (if they can be gotten) to legalize your illegal structure(s), you’ve still got to deal with your city or county if you have received an Order/Notice to Comply. So first and foremost remember – it’s a legal issue you’re dealing with, and if not addressed in a timely manner, the effects can be disastrous:
  • Fines and penalties of over $1,000
  • Criminal charges brought
  • JAIL time
That’s right – the prospect of jail may loom in your future. It WILL loom is you don’t properly and timely respond to the city demands. This is no joke, folks.

Here’s what you need to be concerned with from a legal perspective:

Building Codes & Permits

http://www.illegallaconversions.com/garages_guest_houses.html

http://www.bsc.ca.gov/SearchResults.aspx?q=garage+conversion+to+dwelling+unit
 
Last edited:
While i suppose it is possible to put someone in jail (didn't they do that to slumlords?), the likelihood is probably very low. I'm not saying to ignore that potential but I am trying to add some perspective to it.

What I've seen (in California) is that the jurisdiction will red tag the building and order that it cannot be used for occupancy or use.
They will order the owner to bring the unit into compliance.
If the owner fails to do that, they can begin to assess fines. Typically, the fine is added as a lien on the property. The impact of the lien makes it nearly impossible to finance (conventionally). The fine, in theory, can continue to grow until the the problem is fixed, the jurisdiction fixes the problem and bills the owner, or the jurisdiction initiates a taking-process of the property.

Please let us know if the appraiser you reference is part of the assessor's office or the appraisal was for some other purpose.

And, good luck!
 
Go to the state of California's website for regulating and enforcement of appraisers http://www.orea.ca.gov

Read about how to file a compliant http://www.orea.ca.gov/html/EnforcementFAQs.html#q3
In the appraisal, did appraiser discuss compliance of the ADU and conversion, zoning ordinances, enforcement and marketability?



Dear Artemis he is a independent appraiser we paid over $2,000 to perform on a nightmare property because of his reputation of being fair. The problem is he refused to believe us about the ADU being required to be 1200 sq. ft. He knew there was bad blood in the family and figured we had sour grapes. In addition, the County's records were in error and showed a higher square footage than is legal. The original permit application and the completed approved permit both said 1200 sq ft. Somehow in the paperwork, it went up on their end. So our appraiser may have looked at that despite our offering him the plans to inspect himself. He did measure out a much higher (1580+) square footage on his report. He doesn't seem to get that the ADU is not without restrictions. He addressed nothing in regard to the illegal overage. Perhaps as he's a neighbor selling his own home, he may have wanted a higher value placed on our property so that he'd have a comparable comp?

In any case, he was completely disinterested in our requests that he examine both the permit and plans we had in hand when he was evaluating our house. We showed the appraiser another room they designated "storage" of approximately 500 sq. ft. In the plans (which we have), it was engineered to have a doorway opening into the master suite, making a large top floor. However, they closed off this doorway and had it plastered over so as to be invisible to the appraiser. He fell for it, even though the "storage room" was decorated in the same style as the master bedroom in colors, flooring, and trim. We pointed this out to him but he said it was storage, although it was clearly conditioned space with heating per the rest of the house. It's not just that they cheated, they knew what they were doing.

The County stated that all of this must be addressed even the "hidden room" must all be brought back to 1200 sq ft because the granny cheated. Are you able to be a professional consultant who can debunk the original appraisal now this new information has been discovered? I believe their is a tremendous value for me to hire someone who specializes in correcting bad errors. What would you do in my situation, would you allow the owner of this ticking time bomb to get the value the appraiser said even though the County is now starting to clock for them to remove their 2,000+ square feet down to 1200 sq ft. The owner has been threatening to take dad to court because they think he can't think and is in a state of discombobulation he will not be able to testify because of his dementia.

The Appraiser was self-employed who has been working the industry for almost forty years and knows the ropes. It is not working for the bank, a man I thought had great integrity until he ignored all the illegal unpermitted work. He failed to address my concerns of the owners failure to tell the City their valuation of the Granny does not come near what he is paying. I have letters showing their house is suppose to be worth $600,000 total but they pay $1400 a year in property taxes. My house got the parent-to-child house exclusion after five years of waiting, I paid my dad fair market value and asked that our property get registered so everything was legal. There was no pressure from a bank, from FHA, Freddie or Fannie to do the appraisal a certain way. The appraisal is bogus if the County is going to force them to rip out half their square feet, just my guess as I wait for the professionals here to set me up with paid appraising specialist who know how to cancel out appraisals with gross errors.
 
Last edited:
An "appraiser" for the county cannot be sued. Fee appraisers do not normally value property per se for the assessor.

So please clarify. Are you saying you just bought a place and an independent appraiser valued it but then someone from the county came out and said, "Ah Ha! Cha-Ching". Perhaps you should sue the party that sold you this knowing it did not comply with the law. And what did the appraiser say? If they valued it, then the valuation by the county is not privy to that information unless you gave it to them. So regardless what the appraiser felt it was "worth", the county is operating upon another set of facts created by their own assessment, not your appraisers. So. What did the appraiser say it is worth? And what did the county say it is worth?

It seems to me that the county action is independent of the appraiser's action and if the appraiser valued it "as is" and assumed that it would continue under the same situation, then market evidence may well support that valuation. The fact you got "caught" does not mean the appraiser caused you to get caught. You did buy it knowing the property did not comply with zoning didn't you?
 
Excellent question, Artemis!

I have been involved in litigation (in California... I was hired as an expert consultant) in a situation that involved an accessory unit that was built in excess of the 1,200sf maximum size limit.
It was a mess for my client.


Dear Denis, do you provide consulting services to debunk appraisals like the one I mentioned too? My goal is to get someone who understands that illegal square feet is not a beneficial asset if the City and County is planning on making the owner rip all that square feet out. My goal is to find someone who can write up reports to help show if we must appear before a judge (garage to apartment) illegal additions, illegal dwellings and upermitted square feet should not be valued at the same rate of a legal primary dwelling. The County was sued by the Grand Jury and now been on a tear making owners of illegal dwellings very nervous. How can I find a Appraiser Consulting to represent me?
 
An "appraiser" for the county cannot be sued. Fee appraisers do not normally value property per se for the assessor.

So please clarify. Are you saying you just bought a place and an independent appraiser valued it but then someone from the county came out and said, "Ah Ha! Cha-Ching". Perhaps you should sue the party that sold you this knowing it did not comply with the law. And what did the appraiser say? If they valued it, then the valuation by the county is not privy to that information unless you gave it to them. So regardless what the appraiser felt it was "worth", the county is operating upon another set of facts created by their own assessment, not your appraisers. So. What did the appraiser say it is worth? And what did the county say it is worth?

It seems to me that the county action is independent of the appraiser's action and if the appraiser valued it "as is" and assumed that it would continue under the same situation, then market evidence may well support that valuation. The fact you got "caught" does not mean the appraiser caused you to get caught. You did buy it knowing the property did not comply with zoning didn't you?

-----------------
I'm sorry I wasn't clearer. I've owned a property with two other owners for almost 20 years. One of the owners removed an old mobile home and rebuilt a new ADU that exceeded 1200 sq. ft. (the County limit). In preparation for a sale, we hired an appraiser to evaluate each of the three homes so as to know how to value it for sale. We knew one of the other owners overbuilt the ADU but didn't know how much until we saw the plans. It is nearly 2,100 sq ft with all conditioned areas (even though some were labeled storage) included. It is not in compliance with code.

Thus, a call from the Building Department had them requesting more information and letting us know that the ADU will need to be brought to code, even if that means destroying part of the ADU. They are not flexible in this. Thus, we are concerned with the appraiser we hired that did not take any of this into account even though we showed him plans, permit apps, and permit.

We are not sure who told the County that the ADU was not in compliance. Numerous neighbors have complained they wish they could build an ADU as grand as this one (it really is quite an attractive building). We have never been inside. We're concerned as being part owner means this could bite us too, even though we had no knowledge of irregularities until after the fact.

Thus we are hoping to get another appraiser to debunk the one done that credited them with the square footage, gave it a high price, all while exceeding the size of the primary dwelling (where we live).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top