• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Proposed AQB Changes To Experience Criteria

Status
Not open for further replies.

Argentum

Sophomore Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2006
Professional Status
Licensed Appraiser
State
Texas
TAKE ACTION NOW!

It is my understanding that the proposed AQB changes the experience criteria to include a change for only 6 months of experience to qualify for a license and 12 months for a certification.

The new qualifications are based upon recommendations from the IAC which is comprised mostly of lenders and management companies that are claiming there is a shortage of Appraisers.

There is no shortage of Appraisers in most areas only a shortage of Appraisers willing to work for less than a reasonable fee. Once these requirements are revised we can expect an abundance of Appraisers willing to work for less than reasonable fees and less reliable reporting.

The experience criteria is the most important of all qualification requirements, you cannot learn the art or science of Appraising without adequate practical application in the field.

Why are Appraisal Organizations not joining the IAC to oppose these changes that originate from the AMC Companies and Lenders that are looking for less experienced Appraisers to handle their less than reasonably compensated orders.

Recently an AMC owner and member of the IAC was overly enthusiastic when telling me how hard he was working to reduce Appraisal Fees and Appraiser Qualifications for Licensing and Certification.

We need more Appraiser Advocates to join the IAC and oppose these changes.

Here is a list of the IAC members that are proposing these changes to the AQB.

ACI
Allstate Appraisal, L.P.
AVMetrics
Axis Appraisal Management Solutions
Bank of America
Butler Burgher Group Real Estate Services
CBRE
Clarocity Corporation
Cushman & Wakefield
Corelogic | FNC, Inc.
Colliers International Valuation & Advisory Services
CU Appraisal Services, LLC
Forsythe Appraisals, LLC
Genworth Mortgage Insurance Corporation
JPMorgan Chase
JLL, Valuation & Advisory
Lowery Property Advisors
Miller Samuel Inc
Morgan Stanley Mortgage Capital, Inc.
Mortgage Information Services, Inc.
National Association of Jewelry Appraisers
OnCourse Learning – CompuTaught
PCV Murcor
PNC Bank
Property Sciences Group, Inc.
Pro-Teck Services
Prudential Financial
Rels Valuation
ServiceLink
Solidifi, Inc.
Stewart Valuation
The William Fall Group
Title Source, Inc.
Universal American Mortgage Company
Weichert Workforce Mobility
Wells Fargo Bank
 
Last edited:
It is just supply and demand. Who needs police or military or hospitals or public education?

Please don’t choke on that supply and demand, or at least not to death. Lol
 
Last edited:
SHORTAGE DUE TO LOW FEE'S "NO" After reviewing hundreds of appraisals I started to buy into the fee "V" quality issue so I began to review the appraisal and see how much the appraiser was paid. I also had personal contact with many of these guys and one clear pattern was the longer the appraiser had been in the business the more arrogant and lazy he became. We had some younger appraisers with less experience but who took pride in their work and it was obvious they had also taken advanced appraisal courses and wanted to learn new things.

In summary: I agree with AQB- Lets get new appraisers and re-energize the industry.
 
From what i have been told, the IAC exists so the rule writers can get input from the users of the appraisals. They must not have email like the commoners.
 
From what i have been told, the IAC exists so the rule writers can get input from the users of the appraisals. They must not have email like the commoners.
Every time there is proposed change to the rules, these proposed changes are exposed to the public and input is requested....anyone can send in their input on any of the proposed changes.
 
WF, Chase, BOA, and Corelogic. No wonder the public doesn't trust us.
 
Well they certainly do seem to try like hell to manage the number of appraisers. I think they do this to manage cost, no other reason. this certainly is not market based activity. I don't know of any other profession where they manage numbers of people needed by an industry by raising and lower standards. There are lots and lots of Lawyers out in the countryside. Many struggle to find a job. So they often set up their own shop or work for FOX Network. One thing that doesn't change and that's the requirements for being a lawyer, doctor, Commercial Pilot, Realtor's, Plumber, electrician etc So why appraisers? Seemingly ONLY APPRAISERS

The Government and specific other Industry does the same thing. Most don't meddle with each other. If a Lender is involved then it gets worse. In the Healthcare profession they have similar problems when it comes to CNA's 1 & 2. They do the same kind of nonsense. If I took the time to explain that profession you would shake your head.

OK so when I was flying for the military I also qualified myself for the FAA Commercial Pilot License. I still have the commercial pilots license, but its not active. I would have to do some things to get it active again. None of them would be going all the way back to Flight School and starting from day one on academics.

BUT, if I don't take my CE each and every year and pay the license fee for the NC Appraiser License then one day later after June 30, I would have to start all over to get my license back.

Is it just me or do others here think that's the dumbest requirement on the Planet Earth.
 
Last edited:
SHORTAGE DUE TO LOW FEE'S "NO" After reviewing hundreds of appraisals I started to buy into the fee "V" quality issue so I began to review the appraisal and see how much the appraiser was paid. I also had personal contact with many of these guys and one clear pattern was the longer the appraiser had been in the business the more arrogant and lazy he became. We had some younger appraisers with less experience but who took pride in their work and it was obvious they had also taken advanced appraisal courses and wanted to learn new things.

In summary: I agree with AQB- Lets get new appraisers and re-energize the industry.

WRONG - AMC Companies refuse to pay reasonable fees. They want less experienced Appraisers to justify their existence, spell checking reports looking for bracketing, etc... Someone they can push around. Crazy after all these years in the business to have someone with less than a year or two in the business asking questions of no relevance whatsoever to the report. After 25 years you better believe my attitude is anything but arrogant. What these AMC Companies fail to realize is that real world experience is what matters most. You've got a transaction in many cases involving sales in excess of $500,000 and these lenders want to save $50 for their Borrowers... Really???

You need an Appraiser with real world experience that can back up his numbers with experience. Someone that knows what they are doing and can go up against any Realtor with facts and the data necessary to prove their results.

Would you really want to jeopardize a deal with the least expensive Appraiser willing to work for less than the next guy?

After all these years in the business I never forget just how important each and every assignment is. Should a deal fall apart because a property comes in for less than the contract price it is not for a lack of experience, or consideration of every possible factor.

AMC Companies thrive on inexperienced appraisers willing to work for less money. They perpetuate the lie about a shortage of Appraisers.

There is no shortage of Appraisers. There is only a shortage of Appraisers willing to work for less than a living wage!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top