• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Proposed Microbrewery And Tap Room

Status
Not open for further replies.

Michael S

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2009
Professional Status
Certified General Appraiser
State
New Mexico
I’ve been engaged to appraise an old industrial building that is planned for conversion into a microbrewery and tap room (aka bar). These have become very popular in Albuquerque over the last few years with what seems like a new brewery or tap room opening up every month. My assignment is to value the property as is, and as complete following the renovations to convert a couple of old connected warehouses into a brewery and bar.

The as is value is pretty straightforward as I’ve got several sales of similar industrial buildings in the area. The problem I’m running into is the as complete value. Most of the new breweries are either leased or they were also purchased for renovation by owner/users. None to my knowledge have sold once they’ve been converted into a brewery or tap room. I’ve appraised a couple of other breweries in the last year or two and I used mostly restaurant sales as those breweries had kitchens and were primarily a bar and event space whereas this one is mostly brewery with just a single large room for the tap room (no kitchen). I do have decent rent comps for breweries and tap rooms but cap rates are pretty much nonexistent as once again, none of these have sold.

So, any thoughts or advice on what to look at for sale comps as complete?
 
I don't think a sales comparison approach "as complete" is necessary in this situation, although I could see some clients disagreeing.

I would simply do a sales comparison approach "as is", and make an adjustment "as complete" based on reasonable conversion costs. In general, I am of the opinion that most restaurant related costs should be excluded as FF&E. But, this could be market specific. For a secondary approach, do an income approach based on reasonably similar leases to arrive at your stabilized value, and deduct out lease-up costs as well as the construction costs you used in the sales comparison approach.

This might be a situation where your methodology could use some interviews with owner/users and/or brokers.
 
I have an appraisal of a +/- 15,000 SF property being converted to a microbrewery on my desk, and would be interested to know how you end up handling this.
 
i feel sorry for those who are new investors to microbrew and brewpubs. the fad has passed and is on the way out. i have had a piece of one for quite some time (started out as just a brewery) and the industry is just too saturated. the peak was a couple years ago and unfortunately it is on the down slope now. some of the better known breweries are still doing well but the vast majority of the start-ups are going to fail. the cost of equipment and permits alone is staggering.
 
some of the better known breweries are still doing well but the vast majority of the start-ups are going to fail. the cost of equipment and permits alone is staggering.
Apparently they are cutting into the national brewery take however.
http://www.businessinsider.com/america-has-hit-peak-craft-beer-2015-12

You are seeing the next craze headed to peak and that is good old fashion Apple Jack under a variety of names, but the next trend..? I'll pass. Read it yourself :)
http://www.inquisitr.com/1759828/icelandic-brewery-debuts-beer-made-with-endangered-whale-testicles/
 
i feel sorry for those who are new investors to microbrew and brewpubs. the fad has passed and is on the way out. i have had a piece of one for quite some time (started out as just a brewery) and the industry is just too saturated. the peak was a couple years ago and unfortunately it is on the down slope now. some of the better known breweries are still doing well but the vast majority of the start-ups are going to fail. the cost of equipment and permits alone is staggering.

So far only one very small one has closed down here in Albuquerque. Many others are still expanding, mostly the larger ones. I've seen the financials on a few (mostly larger ones) and they seem to have pretty healthy margins. One I was looking at had just brought in a new investor that valued the business (including the real estate I was appraising) at several million dollars. If you can sell a whole keg of beer at retail prices in a tap room it will bring in a chunk of change. The same keg of beer that is bottle or canned and sold to a distributor brings in far less of course but there's a much larger market. So far I think there's seven local breweries that are canning/bottling beer for sale in stores and about 30 or so more smaller ones that survive on tap rooms and kegs at bars/restaurants. They've sort of become the new neighborhood bar. A full service liquor license on New Mexico runs around $300,000 or more these days as there is a limited supply. A brewery license which includes the ability to run a couple of tap rooms can still be obtained through the normal permitting process and might cost a few thousand dollars total.

Everyone I've talked to has said the cost and time required to get equipment is a big hurdle as everyone and their brother wants to start a brewery and there's only so many equipment manufacturers out there and most have back logs of many months.
 
Last edited:
Brew Pubs were the hot fad 20 years ago in the northwest. I recall making the statement that in the future, no one will have to walk more than 100 feet to find the next brew pub. There seems to be the second wave of new upscale chic pubs, eating the lunch of the first generation. If I were searching for a cap rate, I'd want it to reflect a strong depreciation component.
 
Brew Pubs were the hot fad 20 years ago in the northwest. I recall making the statement that in the future, no one will have to walk more than 100 feet to find the next brew pub. There seems to be the second wave of new upscale chic pubs, eating the lunch of the first generation. If I were searching for a cap rate, I'd want it to reflect a strong depreciation component.

I grew up in the Portland area and when I went to college in Washington I always appreciated the good selection of microbrews that were available. Of course that didn't stop my roommates and I from buying case after case of the cheap stuff. Still, it was nice to be able to order a keg of microbrew from some of the Seattle breweries that didn't bottle or can their beer.

Albuquerque is definitely experiencing a boom in microbreweries and tap rooms in the last 5 year or so. Prior to that there was maybe 5-7 microbreweries in the state with only a few of these bottling beer and selling it through normal retail channels. Now there are at least 30, all of which operate a tap room on site, many with one or more separate tap rooms in more prominent retail locations. They recently changed the law to allow up to three offsite tap rooms (up from two previously) and many of those are locating in more typical retail locations with the breweries generally in more industrial areas due to zoning restrictions and liquor license restrictions (500 feet from schools or residential, commercial or light industrial zoning, adequate parking, etc.)
 
i feel sorry for those who are new investors to microbrew and brewpubs. the fad has passed and is on the way out. i have had a piece of one for quite some time (started out as just a brewery) and the industry is just too saturated. the peak was a couple years ago and unfortunately it is on the down slope now. some of the better known breweries are still doing well but the vast majority of the start-ups are going to fail. the cost of equipment and permits alone is staggering.

In Seattle the brewery market has exploded as well. There is plenty of more growth potential because the people are going to the breweries to drink beers in a sunlit area at picnic tables sometimes with kids in tow..... and they are doing this instead of going to the traditional dark bar/tavern. There appears to be a shift in how people want to consume their liquor.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top