• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Requesting Prior Appraisal Reports For Reference

Status
Not open for further replies.

Wayne Henry

Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2003
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Maryland
Requesting prior appraisal reports for reference.

Looking for input from my peers regarding reviewing previous appraisal reports and using them as a secondary data source in your appraisal report. If the homeowner or agent has a previous appraisal completed by another appraiser, would you use it as a secondary data source to make sure you have accurate data when comparing your improvement findings with the prior appraisal? Is there any confidentiality or USPAP violation if this is done?

Reviewing a prior appraisal with a homeowner and pointing out the differences that you find could prevent a confused phone call later when the difference is noticed.

Is this a conversation you would have with a homeowner? if not why?

I could understand the argument with viewing a very recent prior appraisal report, especially if the client requests it as a jumbo loan but what about viewing a report over a year from the effective date.

I value your opinions and would appreciate serious answers regarding how you would treat this in your business practice. I am on the fence at this point and looking for guidance from my peers.

I appreciate your time and all that respond to help.
 
Can o worms that have no relevance for anything other than controversy. Stand by and on your appraisal and opinion. That is what you are engaged to do. If you are engaged to review another appraisers work do so. I do no know of a USPAP application of comparison of your appraisal and another appraisers opinion...
 
Requesting prior appraisal reports for reference.

Looking for input from my peers regarding reviewing previous appraisal reports and using them as a secondary data source in your appraisal report. If the homeowner or agent has a previous appraisal completed by another appraiser, would you use it as a secondary data source to make sure you have accurate data when comparing your improvement findings with the prior appraisal? Is there any confidentiality or USPAP violation if this is done?

Reviewing a prior appraisal with a homeowner and pointing out the differences that you find could prevent a confused phone call later when the difference is noticed.

Is this a conversation you would have with a homeowner? if not why?

I could understand the argument with viewing a very recent prior appraisal report, especially if the client requests it as a jumbo loan but what about viewing a report over a year from the effective date.

I value your opinions and would appreciate serious answers regarding how you would treat this in your business practice. I am on the fence at this point and looking for guidance from my peers.

I appreciate your time and all that respond to help.
 
At this point I'd rather not look at a prior appraisal, for many different reasons...unless it was such an oddball property that a prior report could provide information I cant' get elswehere. Otherwise, I'll do my own measurements or find floorplans, data etc...I can stand behind what I did and found, not what someone else did or found. And I do't want to be taking on a quasi review assignment, or having to justify why I didn't do it the same way or come to same /similar value or other conclusions.
 
If they offered to email it to me, I would decline.

If the homeowner stuck it in my face during the inspection, half open, referencing the sketch, I would do a 10 second scan of it.

Sounds like you don't have it in your hands. I would not use another appraisal (unless it was mine) so I would have to pass.
 
Reading again the first post, its especially a can of worms if you the appraiser request the prior appraisal (vs the owner or RE agent offering it). They can use the fact that you asked for the prior appraisal against you..they can.say you are lazy, didn't want to do your own work, and so on. Unless people get what they want (typically a sky high value or SC price met), they will use any reason at hand to complain or discredit an appraiser. Not everyone of course, but enough that makes it just not worth it...imo .
 
It can be useful. It does not violate bank or USPAP rules. I wouldn't cite it in my report but read it closely.

I agree, I combed the USPAP book and reviewed various AMC order forms, and there were no references to asking for or using previous appraisals as a secondary data source. I believe the more information, the better. Not sure what the argument against it is but I am all ears.
 
After reading the posts you are not sure what the argument is? How can that be?I think we all made our points very clearly. Go ahead and do it since that is what you want to do. It may not be against USPAP, but can create potential problems for you with the parties or client, influence to a prior value, parties accusing you of being lazy or not doing your own work, possible bad information you relied on etc.
 
Reading again the first post, its especially a can of worms if you the appraiser request the prior appraisal (vs the owner or RE agent offering it). They can use the fact that you asked for the prior appraisal against you..they can.say you are lazy, didn't want to do your own work, and so on. Unless people get what they want (typically a sky high value or SC price met), they will use any reason at hand to complain or discredit an appraiser. Not everyone of course, but enough that makes it just not worth it...imo .

I see your point, but it would take 2 seconds for any reviewer worth their salary to look at the reports and see that it is not the same. New sales, different values, the different format used are just a couple of items that can be pointed out if one looked at both reports. If you're using the report to verify property improvement data with a homeowner that has the original copy it could be helpful to make sure everyone is on the same page.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top