• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Subject Has No Bedrooms

Status
Not open for further replies.

DDF

Freshman Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2017
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Iowa
I have been an appraiser for over 15 yrs and have never come across a property with no legal bedrooms. After inspecting the property, I contacted the lender, explained the layout-Main base has large open living, dining, kitchen areas, .75 bathroom. Basement has no finish, owner placed a bed on blocks in NW corner, no walls, door, closet. There is an egress window on the north side. I asked them how to proceed, anticipating a cancellation. Not so! Reply was to proceed. Well, obviously there are no comparable sales and not sure how to proceed. I'm seriously considering declining the order. Anyone had this experience?
 
I have been an appraiser for over 15 yrs and have never come across a property with no legal bedrooms. After inspecting the property, I contacted the lender, explained the layout-Main base has large open living, dining, kitchen areas, .75 bathroom. Basement has no finish, owner placed a bed on blocks in NW corner, no walls, door, closet. There is an egress window on the north side. I asked them how to proceed, anticipating a cancellation. Not so! Reply was to proceed. Well, obviously there are no comparable sales and not sure how to proceed. I'm seriously considering declining the order. Anyone had this experience?
Treat it like a studio where it is just 1 large room and note the deficiency. You did not say if it was a SF or a Condo,etc.
 
are there windows and space to build a bedroom or bedrooms? A bedroom is just drywall, door and closet low-moderate cost to construct, question is does the size/layout accommodate it. ( even if appraised as is with no bedrooms, a buyer could anticipate construction of bedroom assuming floor plan allows for them )As Don said, what kind of property is it and how many sf.

As far as no comps, find similar sf comps and adjust for lack of bedrooms constructed in the subject, explain etc.
 
I have been an appraiser for over 15 yrs and have never come across a property with no legal bedrooms. After inspecting the property, I contacted the lender, explained the layout-Main base has large open living, dining, kitchen areas, .75 bathroom. Basement has no finish, owner placed a bed on blocks in NW corner, no walls, door, closet. There is an egress window on the north side. I asked them how to proceed, anticipating a cancellation. Not so! Reply was to proceed. Well, obviously there are no comparable sales and not sure how to proceed. I'm seriously considering declining the order. Anyone had this experience?
We call those studios
 
I had a 8x40 "house" that was a converted steel storage container (previously had a life as a "drive-thru" in Chicago (go figure)), with a living room that had a sofa bed, kitchen, bath, and laundry/storage room. Sailed thru without any stips. There is a new class of designed called Tiny Houses, which seem to be acceptable to the market.
 
I appraised one of those (in Iowa, coincidence) once. It was a custom home with features I didn't know existed at the time (15 years ago). Had in indoor pool in the middle of the house. It was built for "entertaining". The shower with room for six could be seen in the rest of the home. I would have loved to be a mouse in the corner to see what went on at his parties.
 
Would a Murphy bed make a living room in to a bedroom? :)
 
More info about the size of the house would be helpful ? Not a big issue on a 500-700 square foot bungalow or on a Artist studio or even a small condo but a big issue on a large home. I had one house where a single guy turned a 3,000 Square foot 4 bedroom single story Ranch into a 1-bedroom home. He literally removed the bedroom walls and then opened up the master bedroom creating a 800 square foot playboy type bedroom with a spa tub the size of a small pool. I completed the report but the lender would not fund the guys loan and it died. BUT if this would have been a small home I think it could have been done just with a bedroom adjustment - cost to cure and a comment about effect on future marketability. NO matter what I would call it a STUDIO and just do the best you can.
 
More info about the size of the house would be helpful ? Not a big issue on a 500-700 square foot bungalow or on a Artist studio or even a small condo but a big issue on a large home. I had one house where a single guy turned a 3,000 Square foot 4 bedroom single story Ranch into a 1-bedroom home. He literally removed the bedroom walls and then opened up the master bedroom creating a 800 square foot playboy type bedroom with a spa tub the size of a small pool. I completed the report but the lender would not fund the guys loan and it died. BUT if this would have been a small home I think it could have been done just with a bedroom adjustment - cost to cure and a comment about effect on future marketability. NO matter what I would call it a STUDIO and just do the best you can.

Sounds like you did a good job...whether a loan gets funded or not is beyond our control...the appraisal provides information to the client to make decisions. If their decision is not to fund, the appraisal served its purpose.

Some markets or types of construction lack of bedroom walls would be market accepted, others not, and would depend on floorplan cost to cure. If an appraiser is so thrown off by a complex element of an assignment turn it down.I actually enjoy weirdo assignments like this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top