• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

This is a new level of idiocy I have never seen before

The lender who closed the loan messed up, but the appraiser also needed to do her job which would have been to say no and indicate that the condition had not been satisfied.
I am thinking you as reviewer should tell the lender how to fix it. That's my opinion as the reviewer for the Lender. The appraiser and you have the same client.

I would reccomend lender ask for revised 1004D.
 
I am thinking you as reviewer should tell the lender how to fix it. That's my opinion as the reviewer for the Lender. The appraiser and you have the same client.

I would reccomend lender ask for revised 1004D.
I am not the lender's reviewer....I work for a mortgage insurer who insured the loan...this loan was underwritten and closed on a nondelegated basis by the lender and this was caught by our QA process. Believe me, we will be having a discussion about this with the lender, however, this is pretty far down the list of the most egregious things we find in the QA process. Fortunately, from my perspective, most of the more egregious issues we find are not appraisal/collateral-related.
 
The lender who closed the loan messed up, but the appraiser also needed to do her job which would have been to say no and indicate that the condition had not been satisfied.
Not too opposed to this, but the appraiser did provide a clear indication to the lender that something stunk. The yes or no was immaterial; the explanation was the meat.
 
It's just hard for me to fathom that there are still appraisers out there who are willing to do a final inspection on items noted in the 'requires inspection' space. That is liability that isn't theirs to take on. Can't fix stupid, though.
 
Water intrusion is one of those hinky things that could be caused by so many things, structural or superficial. Not the kind of thing to be speculated about by a not-certified contractor who would actually most likely know what he's looking at and the extent of the fix. Like the man said, why take on others' responsibilities that are not yours for saying its all Okey-dokey? Not intelligent.
 
Like the man said, why take on others' responsibilities that are not yours for saying its all Okey-dokey? Not intelligent.
Well.... the second appraiser whom didn't do the initial inspection noted that she asked for proof of repair "multiple times" and didn't receive it. The client didn't cancel the final inspection regardless. So, who's at fault here?

Kudos to the second Appraiser for thinking outside the box.... she covered herself and got herself a bag of groceries.
 
Not too opposed to this, but the appraiser did provide a clear indication to the lender that something stunk. The yes or no was immaterial; the explanation was the meat.
You seem not to understand how lenders work.....what undoubtedly happened is that the final came in with the "Yes" box checked and the since the "yes" box was checked, the processor, closer or underwriter who cleared the file did not bother to read anything else in the final inspection report. While that was an error on their part, that error is a direct result by the appraiser signing a misleading final inspection report that indicated that the conditions of the original appraisal had been satisfied. The lender screwing the pooch on this one does not absolve the appraiser's conduct on this one.
 
You seem not to understand how lenders work.....what undoubtedly happened is that the final came in with the "Yes" box checked and the since the "yes" box was checked, the processor, closer or underwriter who cleared the file did not bother to read anything else in the final inspection report. While that was an error on their part, that error is a direct result by the appraiser signing a misleading final inspection report that indicated that the conditions of the original appraisal had been satisfied. The lender screwing the pooch on this one does not absolve the appraiser's conduct on this one.
I fully understand how lenders work. You seem not to understand how appraisers work. There is a checkbox, with room for explanations. When an appraiser believes there is some aspect of the assignment that is worth the lender knowing, they (should) reveal that in the comments. That the reader can't read, or won't bother to read, is not on an appraiser. In this case, I am in the camp that believes no completion assignment should have been created. Even a stupid lender who can't read should be able to figure out whether or not an inspection had taken place if they received word that an inspection had taken place. In this case, what, exactly, is the appraiser saying yes or no about? The only question stemming from the original appraisal that remains to be answered is, "Did an inspection take place?" The appraiser clearly indicated they could not confirm what must have been an indication to the lender that an inspection had taken place. I also understand that lenders and underwriters will go to great lengths to transfer their risks to others, generally at no cost to the lender.
 
You seem not to understand how lenders work.....what undoubtedly happened is that the final came in with the "Yes" box checked and the since the "yes" box was checked, the processor, closer or underwriter who cleared the file did not bother to read anything else in the final inspection report. While that was an error on their part, that error is a direct result by the appraiser signing a misleading final inspection report that indicated that the conditions of the original appraisal had been satisfied. The lender screwing the pooch on this one does not absolve the appraiser's conduct on this one.
And the appraiser's conduct should not absolve the lender's conduct.

Which brings me to how imbalanced the appraisal industry is; If this ends up as a complaint the appraiser may suffer severe consequences including license sanctions, higher E&O, landing on do-not use lists, loss of income, etc. The lender's consequences are (at most) buying back a loan that they will just resell, which is effectively a big nothing burger.

IMO what happened is a direct result of a lender gaming the system, and an appraiser who was likely desperate for $$ or in fear of losing a client so they wrote what they thought would cover the condition. If secondary market lenders were mandated to follow a VA style appraisal assignment system stuff like this will all but disappear.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zoe
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top