• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Urban Appraisal With Parking Two Blocks Distant

Status
Not open for further replies.

Greg Parker

Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2005
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Pennsylvania
Doing a refi appraisal on a home where the borrowers purchased the property slightly over two years prior. It was a cash deal for just a hair under $1 million. Part of the original purchase included the sale of a parking spot slightly over two blocks distant. The spot is deeded as it's own entity, and if I were to value it, would come in around $50-60k. With the slight uptick in values we have had in the city, the home itself is worth about 960k

I am not including it as part of my current assignment, as it was not part of the engagement letter or original order. (I have verified that the lender is only looking for value on the home).

Is there any scenario where this could actually be considered as part of a standard 1004 form appraisal? I've done properties where parking is a deeded entity unto itself and included as part of the real estate value -- typically, these are for condos or townhomes in the city where the lot is either contiguous or a part of the building itself, not two blocks away.
 
Just comment on the parking space as it is not part of deed and can be sold separately why it contributes no value /is not interluded as any factor in the value of the subject.
 
Just comment on the parking space as it is not part of deed and can be sold separately why it contributes no value /is not interluded as any factor in the value of the subject.

That's what I actually did already. I was only thinking after the fact on the borrowers perception of what they paid vs. what the house itself is actually worth. Irrelevant in the actual appraisal process, just curious if there was any scenario where it would actually fly if done on a 1004 form.
 
Last edited:
If prior purchase price was within last three years and you have to analyze it, explain it included the parking spaces in addition to the house.
 
Doing a refi appraisal on a home where the borrowers purchased the property slightly over two years prior. It was a cash deal for just a hair under $1 million. Part of the original purchase included the sale of a parking spot slightly over two blocks distant. The spot is deeded as it's own entity, and if I were to value it, would come in around $50-60k. With the slight uptick in values we have had in the city, the home itself is worth about 960k

I am not including it as part of my current assignment, as it was not part of the engagement letter or original order. (I have verified that the lender is only looking for value on the home).
I sometimes run into this in my market(s) with boat slips.
Sometimes they are part of the deed/sale (I personally don't like these situations!) and sometimes they are not - "sold separately" as with your deeded parking spot.
I agree, just disclose as much as you are aware at time of inspect/eff date, etc
If lender/client (as you say) just wants the house value, I wouldn't worry too much about the parking space ... unless the parking space is mentioned/considered as part of said parcel/legal description! (which is what I sometimes run into sometimes with said boat slips)
 
Greg....your question relates to off-site separately deeded parking, and whether or not the parking can be included on a 1004 Form.

The answer to that is whether or not the property and parking has a combined mortgage on both, with included legal descriptions for both sites. Both are 'real estate' .. I would argue. The parking is not personal property if it's on a hunk of dirt somewhere. But if in a 'parking garage' I might be inclined to decide differently.

If combined as real estate, then yes. If not, then no.

This situation is similar to a property being sold combined with the undeveloped, but developable, legal lot next door, mortgaged together....which can make the extra lot EXCESS by definition in appraisal textbooks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top