• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Valuation Of Apartments Under Construction

Status
Not open for further replies.

netpresentvalue

Freshman Member
Joined
May 26, 2017
Professional Status
Certified General Appraiser
State
Alabama
Can anyone provide guidance with regard to approaches and methodology commonly used in the appraisal of, in this case, apartments that were under construction on a retrospective effective date? As well, can anyone point to articles, papers, texts or other writings on this valuation problem?

I understand there are possible issues concerning tangible/intangible property, opportunity costs, profits, etc. I am riding in the backseat on this assignment but desire to have a grasp of the relevant issues before our appraisal work begins.
 
Could you provide a little more insight on what the valuation problem is? IE are you looking for an as-is value on a retrospective date of a partially completed apartment project? What intangibles might be present in this case?
 
Could you provide a little more insight on what the valuation problem is? IE are you looking for an as-is value on a retrospective date of a partially completed apartment project? What intangibles might be present in this case?

Yes, as-is because the appraisal is to potentially challenge the yearly assessments for a few years leading up to the project's completion. I think the intangibles have to do with developer profits.
 
Developer profit (Entrepreneurial Profit), as Howard points out, results after completion.
Entrepreneurial Incentive may be part of the cost during construction.
Make sure you are talking about one and not the other.
 
Is there a reason why the as-is value wouldn't be based on the value as complete but not stabilized, less cost to complete and entrepreneurial incentive?
 
Thanks for the replies. I may have jumped the gun on posting this, as need to get a better grip on the appraisal problem. My apologies. I will follow-up in a week or so as I learn more about the problem to be solved.
 
My apologies.
No apologies necessary. I've found that the tone of posting can be misinterpreted and was actually wondering if I was missing something, rather than attempting to sound pompous.
 
I think the intangibles have to do with developer profits.
There is nothing intangible in this assignment. EI and EP are not intangibles. They are Factors of Production. The Cost Approach for your assignment is as follows:
  • Value As Is = Land + portion of Hard and Softs Cost completed
You're buying what is basically an asset in place, adjusting for physical depreciation and function/external obsolescence, if any, if not new.
​
This reconciles more or less with the sales comparison approach:
  • Value As Is = Value Stabilized minus portion hard/soft not completed, minus LL's rent/expense loss (*) for not being at stabilized occupancy, minus EI.
* If it is a owner-occupied or a not-for-rent property, the same concept applies. The asset is not capable of being productive until a future time. Time has an opportunity cost, so use present value discounting of the hypothetical As Stabilized in lieu of rent/expense loss.
​
EDIT: In some, usually weaker, markets, there may be external obsolescence for partially built structures. The market may penalize the property for distress and requires a rarer type of developer willing to step in to save it. They may expect greater than normal profit incentive.
 
Last edited:
<snip>...Developer profit would not exist until completion of the improvements
Yes, and it's actually still a proforma "cost" in this case, right? Or is that "incentive" that DeSaix referred to? I'm not seeing a difference in this case.

OP: you have to be careful because the reader (especially for litigation) will most likely look to the actual outcome for the retrospective-prospective value in this case (present value upon physical & economic stabilization), which is best estimated by an actual sale of the finished product, but otherwise income capitalization approach. If you would try to argue that the actual prospective value wasn't known and arrive at a different value conclusion, they'd simply answer that you're wrong and I believe that for the purposes of the court they'd be right (I wouldn't want to argue the other side, anyway). SO, if you know the stabilized market value (it sold or you have the actual finishing costs, lease-up expenses and first year operating history), maybe you should avoid a typical formal retrospective cost approach. Go with the market-evident value conclusion (things that actually happened) and deduct economic and physical stabilization costs.

Oh, and it probably goes without saying that the costs of any delays, construction re-do's etc. are extraordinary expenses and not part of "market" value (they would be damages).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top