• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

What Qualifies As 2 - 4 Family Small Income Property?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Racehorse 10

Freshman Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2017
Professional Status
Certified General Appraiser
State
Kentucky
I have a property that I just did a 1004 on that had a main residence and another small 1-bedroom home, which I treated as an accessory unit and adjusted for it. I actually found one comp that was similar. Now, the client wants me to do a 1025 small income report. An appraiser friend I called looking for rental info said that this property didn't qualify as a small income property as both units were not under the same roof. I don't do very many of these, and of course the client wants it today. I am brand new to this forum, any advise would be greatly appreciated. :)
 
Is the property owned by someone who does not occupy the property and both units are rented?
 
This is a H&BU problem (I'm assuming the zoning, if there is zoning, allows for 1 or 2 units).

If the likely buyer is an owner-occupant, than it is a SFR + accessory unit. If the likely buyer is an investor, than it is an income property.
You had a similar comparable: Who purchased it (owner-user or investor)?

The lender may want income as part of the underwriting analysis. If so, and the H&BU is SFR + ADU, then I'd simply do an income approach along with the SCA.
 
An appraiser friend I called looking for rental info said that this property didn't qualify as a small income property as both units were not under the same roof. I don't do very many of these, and of course the client wants it today. I am brand new to this forum, any advise would be greatly appreciated. :)
Your appraiser friend does not know what he or she is talking about. Whether or not the individual units are under the same roof has nothing to do with determining whether a property is a residential small income property

Where do people come up with stuff like this?
 
Last edited:
This is a H&BU problem (I'm assuming the zoning, if there is zoning, allows for 1 or 2 units).
This is the first thing I look at when I deal with similar properties/situations - zoning! I have many SFR + ADU and 2+ unit properties within my immediate city, let alone markets I deal with. Zoning is always one of the quickest ways to decipher which way to go. What does your zoning allow?

Other questions I look at with similar type properties: how many meters? Are the 2 "units" similar in size or is one much larger/one much smaller? As Denis mentioned (and I agree) who is the typical buyer (owner or investor)?
 
We have many 2 unit properties, located in R-4 or multi-family zoned areas, where there is a strong owner-occupant appeal with the second unit rented. There is no H&B use issue with these, they are typically appraised on the 1025 as residential income properties. Btw, for VA, the vet must be an owner-occupant for a two unit residential income property to qualify for a VA loan.
 
An issue not discussed yet is what were the instructions in the assignment order form/engagement letter?

If you were engaged to do a SFR appraisal, and subsequently discovered the ADU was present, then you did the assignment correctly***. The client cannot now come back and just say 'change the form' without proper compensation to you for the extra time and hoop jumping required on the 1025 form.

If however, you disregarded the original instructions to do a multi-family 'form' appraisal, then the change is on you.

***However, if the client didn't originally indicate that there were TWO complete, separate living units on the property, and you subsequently discovered that fact at the time of inspection, prudent and professional conduct would be to contact the client immediately after inspection and ask how the situation should be handled in terms of the 'form' used. Then, if they wanted you to do a MF assignment, then the fee (and probably the DD) should have been re-negotiated at that time ..... before proceeding.
 
How many discussion about issues like this have there been? A bunch. :popcorn:

Around here it is usually clear by the use code. Detached or attached does not matter.
 
Thank you for your responses, they have been very helpful. Hi Lee in LA, I'm glad you know so much about this forum and topic since I am new and don't know much about either. Is there a way to access these discussions? Please educate me how to do that and I will look it up and any other question I might have so as to avoid thickening your waistline and head with unnecessary posts in the Help Thread.

This is rural Kentucky, and according to the county planning and zoning, the R-1C district allows no more than 5.1 dwelling units per gross acre; the subject deed describes 1.17 acres (albeit a loose description as bounded by other properties from 1941), therefore, the subject containing 2 dwellings is compliant with zoning, as it is single family residential, but doesn't deny other residences, based on lot size. However, the neighborhood has only single family residences constructed that are only about 20 years old and are on a third of an acre or less. The subject is 60 years old, at least, and appears to have been a part of the original acreage now containing the "new" subdivision.

The main house and the additional unit have separate addresses, however, they are both under the same map number per the PVA and there doesn't appear to be separate deeds. The deed referenced is from 1941, this is an estate, and while apparently legal in KY, lacks a metes and bounds description. The other home is separately metered for gas, water and electric. It is also vacant, as is the subject. I have obtained and attached several aerial maps of the subject(s) in the 1004 I already did for the client from the county zoning map website which clearly shows two separate tracts. Again, no other documentation of these separate tracts are readily available upon questioning and research of the clerks in the deed room and PVA. It appears to be an oversight from decades ago.'Urgent

The client has asked me for a new report, not to change the other one. I believe the buyer is going to be living there in the main house and is not an investor, it isn't a VA report. The similar comp I found for the 1004 wasn't a rental, it was an accessory unit and also in an adjacent county. I haven't been able to find any similar rental comps--I do have a fair idea of what the accessory unit would rent for separately as a stand alone property. Also, the accessory (looks like it was built around 1900 - 1920 or so) has only a kitchen, main room with a fireplace, and a full bath. The client says Fannie requested the 1025 after reviewing the 1004, and after conversation with them today about these, the order has been put on hold.

Again, thank you for your helpful responses, and I appreciate the kind help from those that welcome newbies to the "Urgent Help" thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top