• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Extreme Makover or Extreme Overimprovement?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Joyce Potts

Elite Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2005
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Florida
http://www.mercedes-extreme.com/gallery/

http://www.mercedes-extreme.com/

I was contacted today by an out-of-state lender wanting me to appraise a home that was the subject of the ABC TV series, Extreme Makeover.

No one loves a challenge better than myself, but I really think this is asking for trouble on multiple levels.

The main house comprises apx 5,500 sf of GLA and was built in 3 days by Mercedes Homes in conjunction with Ty Pennington and the gang at ABC TV and countless volunteers. In fact, one of my sons was worked on this project with the crew doing the hurricane shutters.

A portion of the structure houses a non-profit community organization. So zoning and caveating that one will be a barrel of fun.

Hold on, it gets better.

This newly built 5,500 sf home is primarily surrounded by an area having a much lower predominant value in the $150,000 - $200,000 range.

Did I mention the unsightly view of the rear of commercial buildings along SR 436 directly across the street to the SW? And lets not forget the traffic noise one block from a major roadway and active RR tracks within a few blocks.

There is no way any appraisal of this property would even come close to meeting any underwriting guidelines. But the irony is, per the tax rolls, Countrywide already holds a mortgage on it.

Any thoughts on this?
4_14_4.gif
4_14_4.gif
4_14_4.gif
 
You get a house for free and then you borrow money from it. Sounds like a future Bank Repo.
 
Tell em you'll be glad to accept your standard 5 figure fee to Review the Appraisal Report done by an L.A. Appraiser currently on Hiatus from L.A. LAW. :icon_idea: :new_smile-l:
 
I was wonderig if anyone had done one of these yet.
I dont think everyone gets a free house. I have noticed that on some shows they rais money to pay off the existing mortgage since they tore down the collatteral. Did they do that with these folks, if so it is pretty sad that they took a C/O refi
 
I was wonderig if anyone had done one of these yet.
I dont think everyone gets a free house. I have noticed that on some shows they rais money to pay off the existing mortgage since they tore down the collatteral. Did they do that with these folks, if so it is pretty sad that they took a C/O refi

I'm not sure. The tax records indicate there was a mortgage for apx $125,000, which I'm assuming was put on the property after they tore the original house down. How'd I'd love to get a copy of that appraisal.

After two e-mails and quoting them a reasonable fee that I'm sure the AMC thinks is outrageous and assuring them there was no way any appraisal could remotely be FNMA compliant, I'm awaiting their decision.
 
Last edited:
Among other things, I just can't get passed building a 5500 sf house in three days.

I have to wonder if the concrete slab foundation was dry when the walls started going up.
 
I would think there is significant editing on these programs to make it seem like the house was built in three days.
 
I love that show but i have always wondered how if they needed to sell or to refi the house would they. 5500 sq ft house in an area that is predominantly 900 to 1500 sq ft? lol Seems like its an EXTREME over improvement. Think about this, what type of buyer is coming into this area? I bet its the type of buyer that is looking for a 900-1500 sq ft house in this neighborhoods price range. Do you really think that a buyer thats looking for a 5500 sq ft house is going to look for that house in an area that is typically 900 to 1500 sq ft? Now i'm not saying that someone who follows the show and has an ungodly amount of money isn't gonna come down and buy the house (this isn't your typical buyer tho).


Something i've always wondered with this show as well, espically with these people that have these falling down houses that they never took care of in the first place. Do you really think they are gonna do the upkeep and maintanance on their new house to keep it nice? They should do a follow up like 12 months or 24 months after the orignal show and see if people are taking out money or have run the place into the ground lol.
 
Joyce,

You are so lucky! This is the type of assignment that legends are made of.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top