• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

UAD 3.6 discussion

Had a chat with an AMC's underwriter/37yrs appraiser today re: a difficult one where value came in below what owner paid for the newly constructed house 6 months ago. :shrug: Declining prices in his desert location, oh well.

...But the conversation turned to the 3.6, and she said her AMC had been anticipating increasing fees for 6-12 months already, and decided to wait to see how the roll-out of the 3.6 would go, and what fees the appraisers were demanding. So... for goodness sakes, people, charge what you're worth right now while the AMCs understand there will be some changes! She didn't say specifically, but it sounded like $200/appraisal bump would not raise an eyebrow at their company.

She said she is dreading the 3.6, didn't like it at all, was hoping implementation would be delayed or abandoned, so I asked her if she had taken any classes on it, and she had. She said she was unimpressed, software was anti-intuitive, and it was a real mess. She's not looking forward to doing appraisals NOR reviewing appraisals. As we were discussing some of the recent b*t-sh*t-cr@zy appraisal assignments of late, she said MOST appraisals now are the oddballs, challenging mixed use, huge or tiny or with additional LQs someplace. She speculates that many ppl in the "normal" houses who refinanced or bought during super-low interest rates are reluctant to sell or refi, which means there is a lot of inventory suspended right now until rates come down or people feel more confident with the economy. She shared that she has a 2.25% mortgage rate! Wowsers!! I said I thought that rate was only available for about 15 minutes on 1 day. She says she is therefore not moving, not selling, and definitely not buying now as prices and rates are uncomfortably high.
 
She's not looking forward to doing appraisals NOR reviewing appraisals.
Curious that the reviewer wasn't looking forward to "reviewing" the 3.6. I mean, with it being dynamic and the commentary being organized, prioritizing clarity with its structured format.... isn't it taylor made for ease of reviewing? No more hunting through the addendum, less revisions, and ultimately faster reviews, no?
 
As I expected, no one likes the 3.6.
Just because Fannie can tell appraisers what to do and accept they will accept it, Lenders too will have to deal with the 3.6 monstrosity. With so many pages to review and to read, it will take longer for reviewing. And many just not me will have mistakes for awhile to have no mistakes in the new form. (For many years when I started out, I had lots of revisions (hard to imagine) but now I rarely have revision requests).
Time is money and 3.6 will be lender worst nightmare. Not just appraisers.
 
Curious that the reviewer wasn't looking forward to "reviewing" the 3.6. I mean, with it being dynamic and the commentary being organized, prioritizing clarity with its structured format.... isn't it taylor made for ease of reviewing? No more hunting through the addendum, less revisions, and ultimately faster reviews, no?
She didn't elaborate on why she wasn't eager to review the 3.6 appraisals. Perhaps because it is a new product that lacks the familiarity of the forms we have been accustomed to. I assume she doesn't have 'the feel' of it yet, so probably a learning curve on the reviewers' ends too. She also mentioned that she's heard mutterings that 1/2 the active appraisers will shun the work, and either retire or move into different work, and she was concerned about that being a complication for getting loans done.

Sounds pretty realistic to me.
 
As I expected, no one likes the 3.6.
Just because Fannie can tell appraisers what to do and accept they will accept it, Lenders too will have to deal with the 3.6 monstrosity. With so many pages to review and to read, it will take longer for reviewing. And many just not me will have mistakes for awhile to have no mistakes in the new form. (For many years when I started out, I had lots of revisions (hard to imagine) but now I rarely have revision requests).
Time is money and 3.6 will be lender worst nightmare. Not just appraisers.
It will hurt turn times. Lenders may buck the system. The big players have the power to buck it. Money too. They have the lobbyist..
 
One of my direct lenders said they wanted to start trying the 3.6 in aug. Well, here we are in august, 3.6 dead silence.
 
Last edited:
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top