I am not new to this rodeo. FNMA has hired a few geeks that are just trying to out-smart appraisers, and they think they can add more regulations. They are trying to take away appraiser judgments through regulations. The problem is that we NEED appraiser judgments. We know if the market supports ANSI, or if the comps in our area require rounding to the 1/2 foot. That is how my market is. Now we are required to use ANSI for our subject, when we know that the comps are not up to ANSI standards.
You may say that it doesn't matter, but that just proves that ANSI is not the solution to a made up problem that does not exist.
ANSI requires us to double-dip on stairways, which provides a slightly misleading report. The more accurate way to measure is to only double dip if there is a closet under part of the stairway. ANSI makes it easier for us to measure stairs, but it is not accurate. Spiral stairways are not required to be included in GLA.
The only way this ANSI crap is going to work, is if all MLS and tax data is revised using ANSI. Right now, NONE of our comps are using ANSI standards, so our reports are going to either make adjustments that are not supported, or add a comment that we have a limited idea of the size of the comp, but assume it is similar to what tax or MLS tells us, BECAUSE we do not know the ANSI size of the comps.
I don't have livable attics in my area, but those of you that do are going to have trouble. Is the comp including an attic that has a 6'10' ceiling over 50% of the attic? Good luck figuring that out. Guess we need to do an interior inspection and measasurements of all of our comps.