• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Agent Requested A Different Appraiser

Status
Not open for further replies.

0351

Freshman Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2015
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Louisiana
I received an order for a 1004 purchase this week. My office is approx. 45 min from the subject property. I have been doing appraisals in this particular market since I was a trainee over 10 years ago. When I called the agent to set up the inspection she questioned me on my competence in the area(likely due to my area code from phone). Said she wanted to talk to her seller before moving forward. I briefly explained my experience in the area but didn't push the issue as I had no time to deal with her. She called back to inform me that they were requesting another, more local, appraiser. As an FYI there are few appraisers in this particular market and the subject was in a cookie cutter subdivision that an appraiser from Canada could complete. I'm not butt hurt over losing the order. My question is does she have the right to cancel the order when in reality the buyer is paying for the report and she is not an intended user......... and would she be responsible for fees associated with delaying the loan process?
 
I received an order for a 1004 purchase this week. My office is approx. 45 min from the subject property. I have been doing appraisals in this particular market since I was a trainee over 10 years ago. When I called the agent to set up the inspection she questioned me on my competence in the area(likely due to my area code from phone). Said she wanted to talk to her seller before moving forward. I briefly explained my experience in the area but didn't push the issue as I had no time to deal with her. She called back to inform me that they were requesting another, more local, appraiser. As an FYI there are few appraisers in this particular market and the subject was in a cookie cutter subdivision that an appraiser from Canada could complete. I'm not butt hurt over losing the order. My question is does she have the right to cancel the order when in reality the buyer is paying for the report and she is not an intended user......... and would she be responsible for fees associated with delaying the loan process?

She has no right to cancel the appraisal request. I would call the lender and tell them this is in violation of Dodd-Frank and that you will report this if necessary, and will report her to the local Realtor Association as well as the state licensing board. Don't take their crap.
 
No she does not have the right, AND the lender/client is at fault if they allow RE agent to decide who the appraiser is (such as by denying access )

Next time, decline to answer any RE agent questions about your competence or where you are located. They have no right to qualify you for an assignment, they are not our client, I wish appraisers would stop being such wimps ( and brush up on regulations ). Next time it happens, respond to the RE agent that you were qualified by the client and there are regulations around client engagement and thus it is not appropriate for you to have this conversation with her. If she says other appraisers answer, say those appraisers are violating regulations as she is if she is denying access to a lender selected appraiser. Or simply respond that the client does not wish you to discuss the issue with RE agents.
 
thank you for the replies
 
Do as Don suggested. If that doesn't work, there's always option B

 
  • Like
Reactions: PMM
Be happy it got started off bad and would have only gotten worse. The agent did not order the appraisal but they did probably tell their client to contact their lender and request a local appraiser. The agent has a duty toward their client and there is nothing that can be done to her . The lender can order the appraiser from a more local appraiser and they can say their client was concerned about an outside appraiser not knowing the area ( geographic competence ) issue It does not sound like the agent was trying to get you to hit a number or push a value. * Old Doodle & Frank have way bigger fish to fry :)
 
I haven't an issue like this for quite some time. Back when I did, I would shoot an email to the agent's managing broker, to give him/her first right to correct the situation in-house before escalating. If that doesn't work, I like res's option B. :)

Good luck!
 
When you speak to the lender/AMC I think its important for you to establish that the real estate agent is attempting to select their preferred appraiser to establish that particular violation of the appraiser selection process.
 
I've had it happen once or twice. Even if you call the AMC, they most likely won't care. They are in it to make money, they don't care about anything else. It would be nice if the lender told the agent to go to hell, they will send whoever they want, but that isn't likely.

Others gave good advice. The agent can't have any say in the appraiser. Good luck.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top