• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Appraiser Marked Private Septic And Well As Public

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are wrong. The seller had a well and septic that did not meet MPR. Had the appraiser not made the mistake I would not be fixing anything as the loan would not have funded.
What is your end goal here? Would you like them to unwind the deal, and everyone goes their separate ways? Even with the cost of fixing the problem the property might be worth more today than when you purchased it. If you make too much of a stink the county might come in and demand you fix immediately since it is not recorded and unacceptable.
Did a professional tell you they were to close, or did you measure? There might be extenuating circumstances that you're not aware of. You should get some bids of a real cost to cure, it might not be worth all the time you've invested here.
 
You are wrong. The seller had a well and septic that did not meet MPR. Had the appraiser not made the mistake I would not be fixing anything as the loan would not have funded.

FHA well and septic inspection requirements

Well Requirements
For an FHA appraiser to pass your well, it must be at least 50 feet from your septic tank and at least 100 feet from the septic tank's drain field. In addition, the well cannot be within 10 feet of your property line. The appraiser can also test for chlorination in the water.
That may be true but in the end it is a lending error. The appraisal you are referring to was completed to protect FHA/HUD from loan defaults not to protect the buyer. Some buyers/sellers hire appraisers directly as a safeguard when making one of the biggest purchases in their lifetime. If that were the case the appraiser might have some liability.
 
What is your end goal here? Would you like them to unwind the deal, and everyone goes their separate ways? Even with the cost of fixing the problem the property might be worth more today than when you purchased it. If you make too much of a stink the county might come in and demand you fix immediately since it is not recorded and unacceptable.
Did a professional tell you they were to close, or did you measure? There might be extenuating circumstances that you're not aware of. You should get some bids of a real cost to cure, it might not be worth all the time you've invested here.
Since it was fraudulently funded. It is on the lender to deal with their clients and bring the property up to MPR. The bids are at least 60k.
 
That may be true but in the end it is a lending error. The appraisal you are referring to was completed to protect FHA/HUD from loan defaults not to protect the buyer. Some buyers/sellers hire appraisers directly as a safeguard when making one of the biggest purchases in their lifetime. If that were the case the appraiser might have some liability.
"FHA-approved lenders are obliged to apply our underwriting standards, not only to protect our insurance fund, but to make certain families can sustain their mortgages," said Acting FHA Commissioner Bob Ryan. "Due diligence is at the root of mortgage lending protecting lenders, the FHA, and certainly homeowners from the prospect of foreclosure."
For those lenders with special authority to insure mortgage loans on FHA's behalf, HUD seeks to force indemnification for 'serious and material' violations of FHA origination requirements such that the mortgage never should have been endorsed by the mortgagee in the first place just as FHA would not have insured the mortgage on its own.
Specifically, these lenders may be required to indemnify HUD if they failed to: (1) verify and analyze the creditworthiness, income, and/or employment of the borrower; (2) verify the source of assets brought by the borrower for payment of the required down payment and/or closing costs; (3) address property deficiencies identified in the appraisal affecting the health and safety of the occupants or the structural integrity of the property;
or (4) ensure that the property appraisal satisfies FHA appraisal requirements. HUD may seek indemnification irrespective of whether the violation caused the mortgage default.

When the Onsite Sewage Disposal System is not sufficient and an off-site system is not available, the Mortgagee must reject the Property unless the Onsite Sewage Disposal System is repaired or replaced and complies with local health department standards.
 
Last edited:
"FHA-approved lenders are obliged to apply our underwriting standards, not only to protect our insurance fund, but to make certain families can sustain their mortgages," said Acting FHA Commissioner Bob Ryan. "Due diligence is at the root of mortgage lending protecting lenders, the FHA, and certainly homeowners from the prospect of foreclosure."
For those lenders with special authority to insure mortgage loans on FHA's behalf, HUD seeks to force indemnification for 'serious and material' violations of FHA origination requirements such that the mortgage never should have been endorsed by the mortgagee in the first place just as FHA would not have insured the mortgage on its own.
Specifically, these lenders may be required to indemnify HUD if they failed to: (1) verify and analyze the creditworthiness, income, and/or employment of the borrower; (2) verify the source of assets brought by the borrower for payment of the required down payment and/or closing costs; (3) address property deficiencies identified in the appraisal affecting the health and safety of the occupants or the structural integrity of the property;
or (4) ensure that the property appraisal satisfies FHA appraisal requirements. HUD may seek indemnification irrespective of whether the violation caused the mortgage default.

When the Onsite Sewage Disposal System is not sufficient and an off-site system is not available, the Mortgagee must reject the Property unless the Onsite Sewage Disposal System is repaired or replaced and complies with local health department standards.
FHA-approved lenders are obliged
 
You really need to speak to an attorney. I doubt he will direct you to go after the appraiser. He will probably tell you to go after the money, which is the lender.
 
If the AMC states that, then most likely the appraisal was corrected. That corrected copy is not the one you were provided. For any given assignment there can be multiple appraisal reports due to changes requested by the client (usually the lender).

Q46. AIR requires the lender to provide the borrower a copy of any appraisal report concerning the borrower’s subject property promptly upon completion. In this instance, what is meant by “completion?”​

The word “completion” is meant to reflect when the lender has reviewed and accepted the appraisal to include any changes or corrections required.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top