• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Assessor Data And Fannie Mae Collateral Underwriter

Status
Not open for further replies.
It always pays to get the title report. Appraisal 101 is identify the subject property. Sorry to hear you wasted your time completing the appraisal as a two unit residential income property, apparently based on the building permits.
You are making an assumption there that the title report is right. Last time I asked for a title report it said the property was a manufactured home. They were wrong. The property is a site built AZ room.
 
Au contraire! No assumption that the title report is necessarily correct. Just one piece of the puzzle. Would you agree that Appraisal 101 is to identify the subject property?
 
The preliminary title report says single-family, so now the bank wants me to value it as a single family with guesthouse, not two units. Thanks assessor! .

In such a case, I really would not care what the title report or the tax card says. :) The property is what it is. Going back to my earlier example, the fact that the tax card would say its commercial would have no effect on my appraisal.
 
The value difference is for multiple family is significant 25%+, there is no way I am going to misrepresent it. Two smaller houses on one lot, separate meters, and separate USPS addresses. If they want to cheat the owner on their loan to value ratio, then they can find some other skippy to do it. And they are just worried about my fee... Title report is wrong and I will send them the permits and clear it up, but they need to order the appraisal.
 
As appraisers we rely on data from the assessor's office. Our appraisals are reviewed against the GLA that the assessor provides. Frequently, I call the assessor's office to amend data that is incorrect because I worry about Fannie Mae CU. However, they will consistently put illegal GLA on the record to collect for taxes. They will admit to this over the phone. I thought that it needs to be "legally permissible" to be valued. Fannie Mae said it was fraudulent to put incorrect information in the public record. Many lawsuits result from putting the wrong GLA in the record, yet since they do not require them to be licensed there does not seem to be any accountability. It puts appraisers in a liability situation because even a false claim can destroy the credibility of the appraiser. Appraisers need this information from Fannie Mae from CU so that we can better serve the public and restore faith in our profession. Recently, a lot with two homes was rated as a single-family residence. When I asked the assessor why, she said well most of them are single-family properties in this market and refused to change it. Their excuse is that it is an "internal rating" system. They also put manufactured homes as single-family homes. Fannie Mae said this was fraudulent. The owners are going to get hassled every time they refinance who own these properties. It's not fair to the homeowner, appraisers, and is pure negligence on the part of the assessor's office. We are all being held to a certain standard and the authorities are not doing their do diligence. We need access to Collateral Underwriter to produce credible results.

Hi Amy, I use to appraise in Cook County, Illinois. Ask any Illinois appraiser about reporting's of GLA's in Cook County. For the past 20 years of my 24 years experience, I have been addressing differences in GLA's on the sketch page. All you have to do is explain what the assessor's or county records is reporting and what the results for your exterior perimeter measurements . Once this is done, forget about it and move on within the report. You cannot change GLA's of the comp's even if you suspect the reported GLA is incorrect. However if you put a statement such as: "The county's reported GLA is assumed to be correct and therefore utilized", you should be good to go. You might also request the assessor's drawing's to confirm there reported GLA's.
 
The value difference is for multiple family is significant 25%+, there is no way I am going to misrepresent it. Two smaller houses on one lot, separate meters, and separate USPS addresses. If they want to cheat the owner on their loan to value ratio, then they can find some other skippy to do it. And they are just worried about my fee... Title report is wrong and I will send them the permits and clear it up, but they need to order the appraisal.

I'm confused. Is your beef with the assessor or a lender client? The thread title seems to imply assessor.

The property is what it is and it doesn't matter what is on the assessor card or what CU spits out. And Fannie Mae supports that position.
 
I'm sure most appraisers have been asked when doing an appraisal, "Will the assessor get a copy of your report." Owners just don't know. I always tell them that the value and information is held as confidential. I'm not the records police and am not compelled to coordinate my records with a assessor and realtors. A person can gets into trouble for poking their nose where it doesn't belong.
 
Most of the time, the assessors records are correct. When not, it triggers maybe the addition was not done with permits. I cross check the records with other sources and I determine which data is most reported accurate.
We're appraisers so it's our duty to find the most accurate information. I check with building records because sometime assessors did not report the new addition or maybe too recent to be reported.
If assessors records are wrong, it's not our duty to contact and change it. Why would you do that? You're opening a can of worms of liability with the homeowner.
I never had a problem with the lender when gross area is different. If you go back in time, you can see what happen to the property for the discrepancy.
This issue validates the need for appraisers because we are like detectives and can accurately determine values better than computers.
 
I'm confused. Is your beef with the assessor or a lender client? The thread title seems to imply assessor.

The property is what it is and it doesn't matter what is on the assessor card or what CU spits out. And Fannie Mae supports that position.
Exactly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top