BlakeAlden
Sophomore Member
- Joined
- Jan 1, 2006
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- New York
Someone came into my office with a report in hand to ask my opinion if the appraiser did a good job on a commercial property. I told them, sorry but I can't help you because I only do residential appraisals and not commercial appraisals. I looked at the report to see if a reliable commercial appraiser had done it and it turns out that it was done by a certified residential appraiser and it was even done on a single family URAR report. The report is of a commercial warehouse type building and its purpose was for fair market value for the owner to possibly sell it.
I told them that this appraiser has a very bad reputation in general and that it should have been done on a commercial form or a narrative report by a commercial licensed appraiser. After they spoke to the appraiser, he said that since this was not done for a federaly related mortgage loan, that any appraiser could do it and on any form. I told them that this is not correct and I was looking to see if anyone can direct me to any reference material stating the pros or cons of his argument to see if the property owner wants to turn the report into the state or if she can get the refund that she is requesting.
Thanks in advance.
I told them that this appraiser has a very bad reputation in general and that it should have been done on a commercial form or a narrative report by a commercial licensed appraiser. After they spoke to the appraiser, he said that since this was not done for a federaly related mortgage loan, that any appraiser could do it and on any form. I told them that this is not correct and I was looking to see if anyone can direct me to any reference material stating the pros or cons of his argument to see if the property owner wants to turn the report into the state or if she can get the refund that she is requesting.
Thanks in advance.