Discoloration in Attic, Subject to Question

[RockBass]

Afternoon all,

Poked my head in the attic and saw this.




That discoloration on the roof doesn't exactly fill me with confidence and I reported as much to the lender, making the property "subject to" getting it dealt with.

The listing agent is trying to tell me that it's a result of a puncture in the hood venting, which has led to a greasy discoloration from the hood venting into the attic. But in my mind, my bigger concern would be a mold issue. I'm also noticing that there are no dark areas on the beams or on the insulation, only the roof itself which would seem strange if it was a hood vent issue.

According to the HUD handbook "If there is evidence of a deficient condition (such as a water-stained ceiling, insufficient ventilation, or smell of mold), the Appraiser must report this condition, and render the appraisal subject to inspection and repairs if necessary". I've asked multiple times if an inspection has been performed on the property and the question isn't really getting answered. Naturally, the lender and the listing agent are asking me how to "fix" it. At this point I'm basically repeating that they need to get an inspection and repairs if necessary per the HUD handbook.

I just wanted to make sure that I'm not missing anything and figured I'd ask for anyone else's two cents.

Thanks!

 

[Dublin ohio]

You are on the correct track. Call it out and let the chips fall where they may. Not within your expertise as an appraiser to tell them how to fix it. It is too suspicious. Something smells. If it is not mold as they claim. A simple inspection would determine that. Not sure what it would cost. But can't see it being that great of an expense just for a test,

 

[Terrel L. Shields]

Does it have good ventilation because it looks to me like it may have been sweating.

 

[Tom4value]

My guess is that it is mold due to poor ventilation. However, don’t guess. Just report and recommend an inspection.

 

[Tim The Enchanter]

Subject to a new roof!

 

[RockBass]

Follow up, because I'd hate to leave anyone hanging:

I finally got an answer that an inspection had been performed and they provided me with a copy of it. Not what I asked for, but okay. So I read through it and the inspectors basically stated that "there was no moisture visible in the attic space."

Okay, cool. So then about an hour later I get a call: "The inspection says that the attic is free of moisture. Is that satisfactory?" To which I responded that wasn't my decision to make. That's the underwriter's call and they can proceed from there based off of the inspection and my recommendations.

I swear, my last 48 hours have basically been one long caveat about how I'm not an expert. Is that damaging to my self-esteem? I wouldn't know. I'm not an expert.

 

[Tim The Enchanter]

Follow up, because I'd hate to leave anyone hanging:

Thanks for that.

I think I'd attach the report to my 1004D or whatever, and rely on that.

Pretty sure you're smart enough, you're good enough, and doggoneit, people like you.

 

[glenn walker]

Most common cause is the Exhaust fans terminating into the attic and not to the exterior. The Realtor is probably telling the truth no bid deal and may have already been fixed . Om some cold weather areas if serious it will turn black or get very dark.