• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

FHA Septic & Well Appraiser Lawsuit

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sounds like the seller and seller's agent were deficient in their disclosures at a minimum and doesn't sound like your agent did you any favors either. Is this your first house?
 
because banks and appraisers have a team of attorneys on their payroll
Banks maybe. Appraisers very seldom have more than one attorney and it would usually be their E & O attorney. Appraisers typically don't have deep pockets.
 
Sounds like the seller and seller's agent were deficient in their disclosures at a minimum and doesn't sound like your agent did you any favors either. Is this your first house?
The seller listed it correctly as septic and well, there was a seller's disclosure as well as a septic pump receipt provided to the appraiser since my agent and I asked for the tanks to be pumped in the sales contract. Yes first home.
 
Banks maybe. Appraisers very seldom have more than one attorney and it would usually be their E & O attorney. Appraisers typically don't have deep pockets.
I'm not sure how an E & O will defend the fact that the appraiser went against what it was listed as.
 
The seller listed it correctly as septic and well, there was a seller's disclosure as well as a septic pump receipt provided to the appraiser since my agent and I asked for the tanks to be pumped in the sales contract. Yes first home.
Was the septic system inspected by somebody competent prior to escrow being opened with a report for you to peruse or did you rely on something else like agent's conversations, or make the first-time buyer boo-boo of ignoring a normal course of due diligence? It sounds like the appraiser maybe was a trainee and/or professional incompetent who didn't have a clue nor a mentor, either case being irrelevant as far as you are concerned. I see you partially recovering after a prolonged pause in the Texas judicial system.
 
Was the septic system inspected by somebody competent prior to escrow being opened with a report for you to peruse or did you rely on something else like agent's conversations, or make the first-time buyer boo-boo of ignoring a normal course of due diligence? It sounds like the appraiser maybe was a trainee and/or professional incompetent who didn't have a clue nor a mentor, either case being irrelevant as far as you are concerned. I see you partially recovering after a prolonged pause in the Texas judicial system.
I did have a septic professional test it. The issue is there is not sufficient room for repair or replacement, without capping and digging a new well, and tunneling to reroute the plumbing, and my "working" inspection does not measure FHA minimum distance requirements. That was a requirement of the appraiser and lender only. see FHA well waiver which would have required sufficient room for repair or replacement.
 
But you were in the house a year before you overflowed the septic.

 
But you were in the house a year before you overflowed the septic.

It was 5 months. FHA minimum property requirements are determined prior to closing not sure what your timeline has to do with.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top