• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Homogeneous banned from the appraisal lexicon

Status
Not open for further replies.
Homogenous is the one that pisses me off the most. I get it. They're talking about human characteristics (homogeneous neighborhood = all white, all black, etc) but I'm talking about properties and not people. :shrug:

I'll figure out a new word and life will go on.
one interpretation is Appraiser Speak describing homes and the other use is for describing occupants/residents by the ones thinking we use that as some form of adjustment.

Kind of like the Difference in Speech between Liberal Arts College professors/students and Hard Science Colleges like MIT Professors and Students
 
one interpretation is Appraiser Speak describing homes and the other use is for describing occupants/residents by the ones thinking we use that as some form of adjustment.

Kind of like the Difference in Speech between Liberal Arts College professors/students and Hard Science Colleges like MIT Professors and Students
It's obvious when I use the word that I'm not using it in a bad way, but I'm going to stop just because it'll be a zero tolerance thing with the checkbox reviewers we deal with.

Here's an example where I use the word.

The adjusted prices range from $1,206,300 to $1,471,600. Adjustments are based on techniques that include paired sale and sensitivity analysis. A larger adjusted sale price range and larger adjustments are unvaoidable due to the high quality, custom market where homes are less homogeneous. Comps 1 and 4 are given the most weight because of their small gross adjustments and overall similarities. $1,400,000 is most supported by the sale approach.
 
"Hey ChatGPT, I'm running for congress, but my only goal is to use my power to enrich myself and the special interests that have bankrolled my campaign. Can you please provide a list of the most divisive social topics which I can use to divert the voters attention?"

1676492085376.png
"Wow, AI is amazing!"
 
"Hey ChatGPT, I'm running for congress, but my only goal is to use my power to enrich myself and the special interests that have bankrolled my campaign. Can you please provide a list of the most divisive social topics which I can use to divert the voters attention?"

View attachment 72586
"Wow, AI is amazing!"
Abortion. Game over. Make sure you call them babies.
 
It's obvious when I use the word that I'm not using it in a bad way, but I'm going to stop just because it'll be a zero tolerance thing with the checkbox reviewers we deal with.

Here's an example where I use the word.
less homogeneous = more heterogeneous = more diverse
 
They're going to set their filters to look for the word regardless of the context of its usage. Then they're going to stip you for an explanation. Then you're going to drop everything you're doing to spend 1/2 hour of uncompensated time to respond to the stip on the fire drill basis. Even if you win the dispute it's still going to cost you.
 
Didn't read through all the comments, but I received an email recently from a client (MaxVantage - I like them, smaller AMC, however got bought out from Dart)
Anyway this is part of the email I received:
"Several of our bank clients have communicated to us that they need us to update our review process regarding a few issues that are triggering audits and/or compliance reviews on their end. We’d like to outline them here and point out steps we all need to take to avoid these issues..."

"...In response to recent regulatory attention to the matter, lenders are focused on any perception of bias and/or discrimination in the lending process. We want to make sure we are doing everything we can to avoid any perception in our combined work. We are forwarding a list of words that have been identified as having potential fair lending/bias issues. Please read the list at the bottom of the memo and follow the recommendations within"

"...We suggest that you have controls in place to check for these keywords in every report, or that you implement controls ASAP. If you have any questions or concerns related to this, do not hesitate to contact us"
This is the list:

African , african American, age, alaska native, american Indian, Asian, baby, bad credit, binary, bisexual, black

Blind, buddhist, bullets, catholic, Caucasian, childbearing, children, Chinese, Christian, church, citizen

Colored, crime, crime-ridden, crippled, DACA, deaf, desirable, desirable area, desirable environment

desirable location, desirable market, desirable neighborhood, disabled, discrimination, diverse

ethnic, ethnically, ethnicity, European, exclusive, female, food stamps, foreign, foreigner, fraud

gang, gay, gender, gentrification, ghetto, good neighborhood, good location, graffiti, high crime, hindu

Hispanic, hoarder, hoarding, homeless, homosexual, immigrant, Indian, integrated, islam, Islamic

Jewish, latino, lesbian, lgbtq, low income, marital status, married, maternity leave, Mexican, middle eastern

Mosque, muslim, national origin, nationality, native, native American, native Hawaiian, negro, no pride of ownership

non-binary, old, one parent, pacific islander, paternity leave, poor neighborhood, pregnant, pride , pride of ownership

projects, public assistance, public housing, queer, race, racial, religion, retired, senior, ,sex, singles

slum, social security, Spanish, spouse, students, synagogue, temple, transgender, transient

undesirable, undesirable area, undesirable environment, undesirable location, undesirable market

undesirable neighborhood, unmarried, white, woman, women, young​
That's a good start for client/lender in dealing with bias.
All those words, I never used in my appraisal reports except for church. Later I changed to Place of Worship if next door to subject or across street.
I think it's relevant having traffic issues on certain days.
Those words I don't use in my reports but I use them in AF because y'all know I'm not racist.
 
They're going to set their filters to look for the word regardless of the context of its usage. Then they're going to stip you for an explanation. Then you're going to drop everything you're doing to spend 1/2 hour of uncompensated time to respond to the stip on the fire drill basis. Even if you win the dispute it's still going to cost you.
Dammit stop making so much sense.
 
So there's this real thing called the Principle of Conformity, which states that: "maximan value is realized when a reasonable degree of architectural homogeneity exists and land uses are compatible." As I see it, use of the term 'homogenous' merely suggests that the principle of conformity is at play in a particular neighborhood. And if these two constructs are - shall we say, homogenous - would it not be just as applicable to state that 'the principle of conformity is being practiced in this neighborhood'? Assuming it is even relevant to the analysis.

Until about 1977, when the Dept. of Justice settled its case against several appraiser organizations under the Fair Housing Act, the definition of the Principle of Conformity in The Appraisal of Real Estate (6th Edition) was quite different: "The principle of conformity holds that maximum value is realized when a reasonable degree of sociological and economic homogeneity is present. . ."

That's part of the reason why the word "homogeneity" is viewed as a loaded or code word in relation to alleged appraisal discrimination. So, in this environment with more focus on appraisal content, unless appraisers want to press the "sue me" button for lenders or themselves, why not just avoid using the word?
 

Attachments

  • 1676493749975.png
    1676493749975.png
    33 KB · Views: 0
Until about 1977, when the Dept. of Justice settled its case against several appraiser organizations under the Fair Housing Act, the definition of the Principle of Conformity in The Appraisal of Real Estate (6th Edition) was quite different: "The principle of conformity holds that maximum value is realized when a reasonable degree of sociological and economic homogeneity is present. . ."

That's part of the reason why the word "homogeneity" is viewed as a loaded or code word in relation to alleged appraisal discrimination. So, in this environment with more focus on appraisal content, unless appraisers want to press the "sue me" button for lenders or themselves, why not just avoid using the word?
If you'd read my post, you'd have understood that I recommended not using the word homogeneous as well. Unless you're advocating for doing away with the principle of conformity?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top