Is this house too "Loggy?"

[Bryan Reynolds]

I would not remove them. They asked you for your opinion.

I always say be careful when you ask for my opinion because that's exactly what I will give you.

Bryan

 

[The Warrior Monk]

Comps 1 and 5 are the only log houses which have sold in the last 5 years and they are reasonably recent (last July and June, respectively)

Comp 7, 8, and 9 are historical sales which support my conclusion that value is not affected and exposure time is only moderately affected (actual estimates are in the report.)

They want to custom pick my comparables. I like my report the way it is. Do I bend to client desires? (again.. not the client but their AMC who rides shotgun on the stagecoach.)

I would not remove them. They asked you for your opinion.

I agree.

I love the requests to replace your own opinion with someone's else opinion, especially when that opinion is not supported by market data.

 

[kim grant]

Greg,

I don't know if this house it too "loggy" but I do think you have it handled nicely. Obviously I have not had to deal with log homes but I have dealt with many geo-domes in my career, same principle and I handled in a similar way......point being, I got paid at the end and I did my cya in the process.

Pleasanton is only 15 min. from me............email me through the forum and let's have lunch!!!


--Kim