• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Modular Versus Stick-built

Status
Not open for further replies.
My experience yesterday with a modular home on my way to the subject. The modular home was being transported to its site and was stuck on a narrow 2-lane road with hairpin curves on an 8% uphill grade in the mountains. The only way into and out of the subdivision and 4-miles to go. They had to call in for an extra truck as the semi did not have the power. Many homeowners wanting to get home and stuck with nowhere to missing dinner for sure. I will have to go back next week. Lucky I was not in the subdivision trying to get out. It was going to be hours before they could open the road.IMG_0346.JPG
 
Do you own one? If not, why? Did any builder or government agency persuade you either way?

If you do own one, why did you chose it over a manufactured home, or stick built?

Are you seriously a senior member on an appraisal forum for over 15 years?

We are required to be astute observers of the market, but we are also market participants. Use a touch of that in your process.

Have a good morning.
 
[QUOTE="EddieB, post: 2872

Are you seriously a senior member on an appraisal forum for over 15 years?

We are required to be astute observers of the market, but we are also market participants. Use a touch of that in your process.

Have a good morning.[/QUOTE]

Oh my, who peed in your cornflakes on that good morning?

This OP was great and resulted in a very professional discussion involving astute observers of the market.

I don't even know what to think about the comment regarding the senior member of a forum for 15 years. Is that seriously your top appraisal credential? Is that even a thing that you should say out loud?

I am a bit late to the post because I don't spend much time on this forum because so much of it sounds like Eddie B. However, the good parts are great. Like the OP, serious discussion about relevant topics.

Because I am late to the post I scanned all the previous posts and as a result I may be repeating what has already been said.

I agree with the observation of the OP and have thought about this a bit. If I had the bank account I would build a subdivision of modular homes and I would do it differently than it is being done.

Granted, I am not a developer and I image that the current model is profitable and that is why it is done. However, I did complete the Urban Land Institutes Real Estate School so I know a bit about development. I wonder if Senior Member of appraiserforum Eddie B also completed that school.

The current problem with this development includes that many are land lease developments which further stigmatizes manufactured housing. The developments compromise lot size because it is possible, they minimize infrastructure and they select the most affordable style (ranch) which results in a development which clearly looks like a manufactured home development.

I would purchase a parcel, have typically wide streets and grid layout. I would incorporate ranch and two story styles on typical lot sizes and would convey fee simple property rights

That is my astute observation of the market. Which is what 15 year senior member of the appraiserforum Eddie B indicated I needed to have in order to be relevant.

It was probably my 25 years experience, a master's degree in real estate from a top real estate unversity and the best continuing education money could buy like the ULI real estate school which made me that. I just hope it meets the approval of 15 year senior member of the appraiserforum Eddie B. I must have missed when he showed up because I have been here for 20 years. I guess I was busy doing other things and obtaining other credentials.
 
Thanks for adding your 2 cents, Phil
 
I will admit it was not one of my finer posts. Obviously my point was missed by the OP and you Phil, so if you missed it with your outstanding pedigree then, man I really missed. And although my point was not a joke... well

Like they say, if you have to explain the punchline, it wasn't a very good joke.
 
I will admit it was not one of my finer posts. Obviously my point was missed by the OP and you Phil, so if you missed it with your outstanding pedigree then, man I really missed. And although my point was not a joke... well

Like they say, if you have to explain the punchline, it wasn't a very good joke.

I just want this to be a professional forum without the nonsense.
 
I’d say the bigger issue would be to get the profession back.
 
I bet you would put Mercedes Benz decals on your hyundai and call it custom.....any form of manufactured is NOT the same as a custom stick built....period. I adjust for quality unless it's an older house. Market participants do not treat the two the same. 99% of manufactured housing uses the cheapest materials possible and it shows.....

The discussion is about MODULAR and not MANUFACTURED.

There are some very good quality MODULAR homes..............MANUFACTURED home are commonly know as "trailers" around here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top