D
Deleted member 142783
Guest
Completing an appraisal for mortgage transaction (conventional).
Subject is located in homogeneous tract/PUD development. The property has had several price reductions (below all the recent sales in an increasing to stable market).
Notes state - Notorious event know commited by "XXXX name". I ask the listing agent about this, she states the property is stigmatized due to a certain race (which makes up 1/2 the buyer pool) having superstition and will NOT consider purchase (can't use this data even though I believe it is reliant). When asked what the event was, she simply told me "google the name".
Previous occupant beat her 6 year old step daughter to death in the home a while back (pretty terrible).
How would you handle the stigmatization? I know of no properties in the area with similar issues. Also, I have asked my peer appraisers and other agents; none know of similar sales having such events occur. In my market, deaths in the home (natural or otherwise not horrific) do not impact price...
One appraiser said he would comp it out, then make an adjustment in the grid based on the sales vs Subject contract price to reflect "stigmatization"
Any suggestions on this one?
Subject is located in homogeneous tract/PUD development. The property has had several price reductions (below all the recent sales in an increasing to stable market).
Notes state - Notorious event know commited by "XXXX name". I ask the listing agent about this, she states the property is stigmatized due to a certain race (which makes up 1/2 the buyer pool) having superstition and will NOT consider purchase (can't use this data even though I believe it is reliant). When asked what the event was, she simply told me "google the name".
Previous occupant beat her 6 year old step daughter to death in the home a while back (pretty terrible).
How would you handle the stigmatization? I know of no properties in the area with similar issues. Also, I have asked my peer appraisers and other agents; none know of similar sales having such events occur. In my market, deaths in the home (natural or otherwise not horrific) do not impact price...
One appraiser said he would comp it out, then make an adjustment in the grid based on the sales vs Subject contract price to reflect "stigmatization"
Any suggestions on this one?