• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Notorious Event

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 142783
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Deleted member 142783

Guest
Completing an appraisal for mortgage transaction (conventional).

Subject is located in homogeneous tract/PUD development. The property has had several price reductions (below all the recent sales in an increasing to stable market).

Notes state - Notorious event know commited by "XXXX name". I ask the listing agent about this, she states the property is stigmatized due to a certain race (which makes up 1/2 the buyer pool) having superstition and will NOT consider purchase (can't use this data even though I believe it is reliant). When asked what the event was, she simply told me "google the name".


Previous occupant beat her 6 year old step daughter to death in the home a while back (pretty terrible).


How would you handle the stigmatization? I know of no properties in the area with similar issues. Also, I have asked my peer appraisers and other agents; none know of similar sales having such events occur. In my market, deaths in the home (natural or otherwise not horrific) do not impact price...

One appraiser said he would comp it out, then make an adjustment in the grid based on the sales vs Subject contract price to reflect "stigmatization"


Any suggestions on this one?
 
Completing an appraisal for mortgage transaction (conventional).

Subject is located in homogeneous tract/PUD development. The property has had several price reductions (below all the recent sales in an increasing to stable market).

Notes state - Notorious event know commited by "XXXX name". I ask the listing agent about this, she states the property is stigmatized due to a certain race (which makes up 1/2 the buyer pool) having superstition and will NOT consider purchase (can't use this data even though I believe it is reliant). When asked what the event was, she simply told me "google the name".


Previous occupant beat her 6 year old step daughter to death in the home a while back (pretty terrible).


How would you handle the stigmatization? I know of no properties in the area with similar issues. Also, I have asked my peer appraisers and other agents; none know of similar sales having such events occur. In my market, deaths in the home (natural or otherwise not horrific) do not impact price...

One appraiser said he would comp it out, then make an adjustment in the grid based on the sales vs Subject contract price to reflect "stigmatization"


Any suggestions on this one?

Similar events happen fairly often. I once appraised a property where the wife blew her brains out with a shotgun, in the bath tub of the master bath. Several homes here locally have had people die in fires. All such events are short term and have short term effects. I would not state the exact nature of the event but disclose that a death f a previous family member has caused a short term market reaction based on the declining dollar amount of offers received on the property, but do not affect the condition, quality or other considerations of the subject. The market value is based on current market conditions of comparable sales unaffected by the event that occured within the subject property.
 
One appraiser said he would comp it out, then make an adjustment in the grid based on the sales vs Subject contract price to reflect "stigmatization"

While the difference in the contract price vs. the non-stigmatized market value may, indeed, be the loss in value due to a stigma, that isn't the way to analyze the stigma (according to the above process, the stigma impairment is predetermined based on the difference in the contract price vs. non-stigmatized market value).

The way to do this is to find other, stigmatized homes and compare their sale prices to non-stigmatized sales in their area. You can also call the agents involved in the transaction and survey them if there was a discount. Use that information to conclude an adjustment for your subject.

I just finished a property in San Francisco: the owner was critically injured during a crime at the property and later died in the hospital. This was disclosed in the MLS. Based on my analysis, there was no stigma attached to the grizzly event. This SF market is in great demand, so the buyer pool didn't care about the prior event.

This one will take some work if it is to be done correctly. I'd say this is definitely worth going back and asking for a higher fee (if this information wasn't known to you when you accepted the assignment to begin with).

Good luck!
 
Market conditions can include stigma. In his book, Real Estate Damages: An Analysis of Detrimental Conditions (R. Bell, AI), Bell describes the stigma creating Market Resistance. Here is an excerpt that refers to crime scenes:

Market Resistance refers to the risks and uncertainties, if any, associated with negative reactions by the market towards a property that has a history of being damaged....
[he then talks about environmental and other issues]
....In other situations, there may have been no assessment stage or repair stage, but only a pure market resistance that is attributable to a negative event that occurred on the property, such as a crime scene. In all these situations, market resistance reflects any risks associated with the historical problems of the property. In the example of a car, this would be like any resistance by buyers toward a car that was damaged in an accident and later repaired. Depending on the situation, the market may require a discount as an inventive to purchase the car, give its history.​

Market resistance is a market reaction. If buyers and sellers, fully informed of the history of the property, are not buying it because of its history, that is a stigma that reflects a market reaction to that history.
What's the value of the property, as-is? The value of the property, as-is, may include market resistance to the events that occurred.

As horrible as the crime is that you cite, it is likely the stigma attached to it is temporary.
 
Similar events happen fairly often. I once appraised a property where the wife blew her brains out with a shotgun, in the bath tub of the master bath. Several homes here locally have had people die in fires. All such events are short term and have short term effects.

That would depend on the market. It can be short term and almost non-existent in more populated high transition areas, to a seemingly never ending stigma attached to properties in rural areas. I would search far and wide to find similar stigmatized properties keeping the neighborhood demographics similar and go from there.
 
Completing an appraisal for mortgage transaction (conventional).

Subject is located in homogeneous tract/PUD development. The property has had several price reductions (below all the recent sales in an increasing to stable market).

Notes state - Notorious event know commited by "XXXX name". I ask the listing agent about this, she states the property is stigmatized due to a certain race (which makes up 1/2 the buyer pool) having superstition and will NOT consider purchase (can't use this data even though I believe it is reliant). When asked what the event was, she simply told me "google the name".


Previous occupant beat her 6 year old step daughter to death in the home a while back (pretty terrible).


How would you handle the stigmatization? I know of no properties in the area with similar issues. Also, I have asked my peer appraisers and other agents; none know of similar sales having such events occur. In my market, deaths in the home (natural or otherwise not horrific) do not impact price...

One appraiser said he would comp it out, then make an adjustment in the grid based on the sales vs Subject contract price to reflect "stigmatization"Do

Any suggestions on this one?
Do your research. There is definitely literature available out there that analyzes the effects of stigma on value. There are also undoubtedly other homes in just about every market that you can find in which murders or deaths occurred which were then subsequently sold. This is one of those situations where you need to get the elbow grease out and do some extra, hard work. You should also be sure to charge for that extra, hard work.
 
Realtor only required to disclose if it was the previous transfer. We had a suicide on the next door home and the home went into foreclosure. No disclosure of the suicide on the resale was required. We are afraid to tell the current owner. My wife would have refused to move in if it was her.
 
Realtor only required to disclose if it was the previous transfer. We had a suicide on the next door home and the home went into foreclosure. No disclosure of the suicide on the resale was required. We are afraid to tell the current owner. My wife would have refused to move in if it was her.
The disclosure requirement varies greatly from state to state. In some states (i.e., PA), no disclosure at all is required, in other states (i.e., CA) disclosure is required.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top