Fnbpos
Sophomore Member
- Joined
- Oct 28, 2003
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- Florida
Back about 6 months ago I made comment on the fact that Fifth Third was going the way of the AMC with ServiceLink. 5/3 wanted to keep their existing appraisers; however ServiceLink was only willing to pay somewhere in the neighborhood of 60% of the regular 5/3 fees. Needless to say, I told them my office would not work for those fees as well as notifying 5/3. My guess is few if any of the 5/3 panel went along with this plan. Eventually, the 5/3 - ServiceLink deal fell apart.
Fast forward to last week....A letter reaches my desk; from 5/3. They are re-establishing the ServiceLink relationship HOWEVER, this time, the appraisers will be receiving the regular 5/3 fees. Sounds like good news to me. I called Servicelink and sure enough, its true.
So, how can this be. I can only speculate, but it would appear that one of two things happened:
1) 5/3 is charging their customers over $400 per appraisal to enable Servicelink to pay me the going rate 300-350...or
2) 5/3 is PAYING Servicelink for their services INSTEAD of having ServiceLink paid by ripping it off the backs of the appraiser.
I'm hoping its "2"
Is there any logical reason WHY the banks who use these AMC's SHOULD NOT BE PAYING FOR THAT SERVICE. They are after all receiving the "benefit"; whatever "benefit" that may be.
As it stands now, the AMC is being funded by ripping off the appraiser. I hope 5/3 has seen the light and that others will follow. 5/3 now has their preferred appraisers back on board. I would have no problem with the AMC concept if the lenders who were using an AMC were paying the AMC; not having the AMC make their money via a "pay cut" from the appraiser.
Could it be that its starting to sink in....if you pay $190 for an appraisal "you get what you pay for" ...
A potentially positive development ...possibly....maybe
I can dream, can't I ?
Fast forward to last week....A letter reaches my desk; from 5/3. They are re-establishing the ServiceLink relationship HOWEVER, this time, the appraisers will be receiving the regular 5/3 fees. Sounds like good news to me. I called Servicelink and sure enough, its true.
So, how can this be. I can only speculate, but it would appear that one of two things happened:
1) 5/3 is charging their customers over $400 per appraisal to enable Servicelink to pay me the going rate 300-350...or
2) 5/3 is PAYING Servicelink for their services INSTEAD of having ServiceLink paid by ripping it off the backs of the appraiser.
I'm hoping its "2"
Is there any logical reason WHY the banks who use these AMC's SHOULD NOT BE PAYING FOR THAT SERVICE. They are after all receiving the "benefit"; whatever "benefit" that may be.
As it stands now, the AMC is being funded by ripping off the appraiser. I hope 5/3 has seen the light and that others will follow. 5/3 now has their preferred appraisers back on board. I would have no problem with the AMC concept if the lenders who were using an AMC were paying the AMC; not having the AMC make their money via a "pay cut" from the appraiser.
Could it be that its starting to sink in....if you pay $190 for an appraisal "you get what you pay for" ...
A potentially positive development ...possibly....maybe
I can dream, can't I ?