• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Revision Request

Status
Not open for further replies.
"If you can hit this value you can have the assignment"
Actually I never had but perhaps one or two such pre-HVCC occurrences. But I have had a lot more pressure since 2008 to rush reports which invites errors. Why was 14 day turn a rounds so much worse than 3 - 5 day when at the same time we were supposed to put out bigger better reports for less money?

ROVs are simply a way to punish the appraiser by wasting their time. The client is well aware of the improbable scenario where the appraisal changes.
 
Oh boo hoo.

Nobody said questions could not be asked.

Right there is the opportunity to open a discussion on some nice company letterhead.

No conflict of interest, no attempts at influence.

Simply answer questions separately.

But most professionals I know, charge in 15 minute increments, so don't expect free answers. Because technical issues are find-able online.

.

.
 
However, there's a distinction to be made between a borrower simply trying to get what they want on the unethical basis vs one who actually disagrees with the appraiser's opinion because they're incompetent in appraising and because they actually do think price/sf is a meaningful unit of comparison or they aren't familiar with how the attributes of their comps relate to the subject.

One is an unethical rationale and the other is an incompetent rationale, and there's not much overlap between the two.
The appraisal report furnished is to aid in making a lending decision, it is not invitation to an Introductory to Appraisal Class.

Oh boo hoo.

Nobody said questions could not be asked.

Right there is the opportunity to open a discussion on some nice company letterhead.

No conflict of interest, no attempts at influence.

Simply answer questions separately.

But most professionals I know, charge in 15 minute increments, so don't expect free answers. Because technical issues are find-able online.
Moreover, you know as well as I that not every appraiser performs at the same rate, meaning some actually are worse than others - and a borrower has no way of knowing who is who.
Of course borrowers' have no way of and they didn't engage the appraiser. They engaged a lender, who engaged an AMC (most likely) who engaged an appraiser. So how are the borrowers' basic lack of appraisal understanding the appraiser's problem?
 
Ok, then, perhaps you can explain it. If asking one to address sales is always pressure, then why does the DF AIR provision specifically allow it? ... RG just does. not want to have to reply to the kind of inquiries that DF specifically allows, so he just yells “PRESSURE”. Maybe he is just a big Billy Joel fan. I dunno.
Not once have I said that, and you know it. If they analysed them and found them to be better indicators of value than the comps that the appraiser used, then it is not pressure and would be appropriate sales to send over, as the DF provision intended. Then I'll gladly use them and redo my appraisal, as I certified that the best sales were used.

Now, what I have been saying all along, posted ad nausea, is when they send over a bunch of inappropriate sales that aren't good comps, rather chosen because their sale price hits the bulls-eye, then I would yell "PRESSURE" and report the lender for value pressure...which is exactly what it is!

I don't appreciate you twisting my words like that. Maybe you should cue up Billy Joel's song, "Honesty"
 
Last edited:
It's almost as if appraisers have completely forgotten what external pressure looks like.

I find hilarious the attempts to equate any data-included ROV - prompted by any party operating under any motivations - with the type of external pressure that occurred on a daily basis for many appraisers prior to the HVCC.

"If you can hit this value you can have the assignment"
"If you don't hit this value I won't pay you"
"You ruined this deal so not only will i not pay you for it, I'm also not going to pay you for the other 10 appraisals I owe you for"
I agree but I thinks it’s deeper than that. I’m convinced some appraisers will never be happy. If it’s not ROV requests, it’s fees, stips, not enough cookie cutter work, or not enough work or to much work. Residential appraisers complaining about whatever cause célèbre is the flavor of the week will never end.
 
Last edited:
Telling borrowers they have no right to even question an appraisal requires a level of arrogance and ego than not even a USPAP Instructor would normally possess. I disavow that level of arrogance, and IMO you should, too. Building credibility starts with establishing *reasonable* expectations, not laying claim to being infallible.

The borrowers are not the named client. That is how the big banks want it, oh expect when the value is low. I see.
 
The borrowers are not the named client. That is how the big banks want it, oh expect when the value is low. I see.
Appraisers don't want borrowers involved either, unless of course a PIW is involved then all of a sudden the poor borrower isn't being protected by an appraiser armed with a Fannie 1004.
 
Appraisers don't want borrowers involved either, unless of course a PIW is involved then all of a sudden the poor borrower isn't being protected by an appraiser armed with a Fannie 1004.
Yes, this thread illustrates pretty well that appraisers don't want borrowers involved. And it is fine to want such a thing, but the wording in DF brings the borrower (and several other parties who are not intended users) into the picture, regardless of what we might want. :)

I fully understand the business implications of that. Time is, after all, money. So, appraisers should work out with their clients, in advance, how this will be handled from a business (fee) perspective. Adding one-sided language to a report, language that the client did not agree to, is not, IMO, the way to handle the business side of this. Rather, any such arrangement should be communicated, and agreed to, prior to carrying out the assignment. That is why we address it in our standard agreements with appraisers. That way there should be no confusion as to what is expected with regard to an ROV request.
 
Yes, this thread illustrates pretty well that appraisers don't want borrowers involved. And it is fine to want such a thing, but the wording in DF brings the borrower (and several other parties who are not intended users) into the picture, regardless of what we might want. :)

I fully understand the business implications of that. Time is, after all, money. So, appraisers should work out with their clients, in advance, how this will be handled from a business (fee) perspective. Adding one-sided language to a report, language that the client did not agree to, is not, IMO, the way to handle the business side of this. Rather, any such arrangement should be communicated, and agreed to, prior to carrying out the assignment. That is why we address it in our standard agreements with appraisers. That way there should be no confusion as to what is expected with regard to an ROV request.

Danny,

Dodd Frank is Public law 111-203

Please cite the section by reference numbers of what you claim the Dodd Frank says.

Thanks.

.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top