• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Revision Request

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok...it IS about the fee...or was in my case. Had some leftover whining to exhume I guess. I didn't have much to contribute to this thread in the first place so I'm done too.
Res IMO that verbiage IS problematic.
 
Well, that may not be what you intend, but it is the message that I (and apparently others) got from what you posted
I don't know how you can say this with any sincerity. When I talk about reporting lenders or value pressure, it has always been inline with sales that are inappropriate sales only given because of their higher price... In other words they are superior in some fashion, hence their higher sales price. This is typical when they send over sales that the agent gave them and they don't even look at them to see if they're just trying to get a higher value. I have always said that if they are better indicators of value that would have changed the outcome of that report, then those should have been in the original report, which the lender has already paid for. I can't double charge them for something I already charged them for. That's like turning in a report unsigned, then when they send it back, the appraiser charges them to sign it. You don't charge for your own errors. Changing a flawed report is not value pressure.
In fact we've discussed in this thread how I don't charge for comps that that I should have used and would have difference in the outcome of the report. So there is no way that you could say what you did. I have been very clear that it is the sales chosen only for their sale price to Target contract are inappropriate and violates DF as a Pressure for value... Of which you agreed it was, btw. If they are good comparables, is not pressure.
 
Here's a pro-tip; if you don't provide a lender or their reviewer with the answer to a question their borrower is asking they have no means of responding to that question for you.
I have no problem answering a question, but an ROV is an assignment that sucks up a lot of time. It's not just about looking at the MLS.... this is something that is thrown in front of you and if you don't verify that sale inspect it, grid it to make to make sure that it is or isn't appropriate, you'll find yourself in front of a judge on the losing side.
 
I don't know how you can say this with any sincerity. When I talk about reporting lenders or value pressure, it has always been inline with sales that are inappropriate sales only given because of their higher price... In other words they are superior in some fashion, hence their higher sales price. This is typical when they send over sales that the agent gave them and they don't even look at them to see if they're just trying to get a higher value. I have always said that if they are better indicators of value that would have changed the outcome of that report, then those should have been in the original report, which the lender has already paid for. I can't double charge them for something I already charged them for. That's like turning in a report unsigned, then when they send it back, the appraiser charges them to sign it. You don't charge for your own errors. Changing a flawed report is not value pressure.
In fact we've discussed in this thread how I don't charge for comps that that I should have used and would have difference in the outcome of the report. So there is no way that you could say what you did. I have been very clear that it is the sales chosen only for their sale price to Target contract are inappropriate and violates DF as a Pressure for value... Of which you agreed it was, btw. If they are good comparables, is not pressure.
OK. But my point is that even if the sales are all superior, requesting one to address those sales, without any pressure to use such sales, is just that - a request to address. And a request to address, absent pressure to change, is not a violation. As I said, it is the pressure, not the nature of the sales provided that is the key.

As for the cited fee arrangement, it inspires unethical behavior, because it provides economic motivation for the appraiser to conclude the alternate sales are invalid. It is a fee based on the results of your analysis. Fundamentally, it provides the same economic incentive as a fee based on the value - it inspires/temps one to be less than ethical in the analysis. Whether one is actually unethical (and I certainly do not mean to imply that you are) in the analysis is irrelevant to what is allowed by the ETHICS RULE. One could probably defend the fee arrangement, but I would not want to be in the position of doing that. It certainly is a contingent fee arrangement - the argument would be over whether it is a prohibited contingency.
 
But my point is that even if the sales are all superior, requesting one to address those sales, without any pressure to use such sales
If they're Superior, why are they sending them? It's about their price point.

Why don't you send those comps to the appraiser when you order the appraisal and ask them to consider using them?

?
 
As for the cited fee arrangement, it inspires unethical behavior, because it provides economic motivation for the appraiser to conclude the alternate sales are invalid.
No it does not. Just the opposite. Paying them nothing for work results in a generic..."Nope, not comparable"
I asked for a reasonable fee for the hours that I'm going to put in to that ROV, and not correcting my faulty report means I'll go down in court.
 
I have no problem answering a question, but an ROV is an assignment that sucks up a lot of time. It's not just about looking at the MLS.... this is something that is thrown in front of you and if you don't verify that sale inspect it, grid it to make to make sure that it is or isn't appropriate, you'll find yourself in front of a judge on the losing side.

Disagree completely from beginning to end. If you laid out your search criteria in your report and related your comp selection to those criteria then it doesn't take 10 seconds to refer back to that explanation and add that these sales aren't as comparable to the subject *on the factual basis* as those sales. Question answered, problem solved, and someone would have to articulate a reason to disagree with your explanation.

And that's if the lender or their reviewer doesn't use that information to vet those other sales themselves, which is way tougher to do when there is no explanation in the report.

It's not even time consuming. You write the boilerplated paragraph one time, and thereafter just edit the particulars to suit your assignment.

IMO, any form revisions Fannie does should include a separate section for the subject's market segment that includes a field that addresses your search parameters. The main reason most appraisers don't answer that question up front is because the form doesn't ask it, whereas that's exactly what it takes to resolve a challenge to your comp selection.

The OTHER thing a lot of appraisers do to shoot themselves in the foot is to only look for direct comps instead of looking at the expanded datasets that would provide more context to the most similar sales they do choose to put into the report. It's real easy to say you already looked at that less comparable sale when you actually did previously look at it as a means of analyzing what the more comparable sales mean to you.

Your comps are the pinnacle of a much larger mountain of data - some being a little closer to that pinnacle than others. IMO they should be depicted as such. Too many appraisers portray their appraisal as hingeing *solely* on those 3-6 sales even when that isn't the case.
 
Last edited:
In areas where many people sell outside of an MLS system, if someone knows of other sales in the neighborhood that the appraiser may not be aware of, those sales can be given to the appraiser PRIOR to the appraiser completing their work.

so you want people to do your job for you? i must have missed the day in appraisal class when they taught everyone to only look for sales on the MLS.
 
Disagree completely from beginning to end.
You can disagree all you want George, but we all know that properties aren't always what the MLS portrays. It's one thing to have your initial comp search based upon MLS... It's reasonable to assume that some of the properties may not be a good reflection of MLS. But a ROV is very particular on a couple particular properties to reconsider. And you take a look at MLS and give them a "nah, not comparable" boilerplate. Now, the buyer or owner sues you and the judge sees that you had RE Market professions and market participants deliver comps on your lap and declare them to be better, as the agent may have been inside or knows the conditions of sale, and had you done that diligence to take a closer look you to find out it was a good comp & would have changed the outcome of your report... But all you did was spend a couple minutes sitting on your azz to send out a boilerplate...Well, good luck with that. I'm going to spend as much diligence those sales as I did on those comps on my report.
 
Last edited:
Disagree completely from beginning to end. If you laid out your search criteria in your report and related your comp selection to those criteria then it doesn't take 10 seconds to refer back to that explanation and add that these sales aren't as comparable to the subject *on the factual basis* as those sales. Question answered, problem solved, and someone would have to articulate a reason to disagree with your explanation.

And that's if the lender or their reviewer doesn't use that information to vet those other sales themselves, which is way tougher to do when there is no explanation in the report.

It's not even time consuming. You write the boilerplated paragraph one time, and thereafter just edit the particulars to suit your assignment.

IMO, any form revisions Fannie does should include a separate section for the subject's market segment that includes a field that addresses your search parameters. The main reason most appraisers don't answer that question up front is because the form doesn't ask it, whereas that's exactly what it takes to resolve a challenge to your comp selection.

The OTHER thing a lot of appraisers do to shoot themselves in the foot is to only look for direct comps instead of looking at the expanded datasets that would provide more context to the most similar sales they do choose to put into the report. It's real easy to say you already looked at that less comparable sale when you actually did previously look at it as a means of analyzing what the more comparable sales mean to you.

Your comps are the pinnacle of a much larger mountain of data - some being a little closer to that pinnacle than others. IMO they should be depicted as such. Too many appraisers portray their appraisal as hingeing *solely* on those 3-6 sales even when that isn't the case.

He is wanting it on the front end GH. I understand that for more than one reason. That is how tidewater with VA works. It’s on the front end which virtually eliminates ROV’s. I am coming in 10% higher than contract price on one right now. It’s tens of thousands. There will not be an ROV. I assure you.

Res is hitting it from a what qualifies these people based on the regulations? He has outlined the regulations.

He wants proof in writing what qualifies the people and why and for what? He wants it all spelled out in the ROV to comply with regulations.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top