• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Rocket Mortgage Sued

Yeah, you should work Shelby County and Memphis. I know what your talking about. Heterogeneous City where an appraiser can get in trouble quick if they are not familiar with the area.

Many rural areas in Tennessee are tough too if you are not familiar with the rural areas. Nashville and Knoxville are more homogeneous in nature. Easier to judge differences in different locations.
The trick to boosting your home value in the denser urban areas, especially diverse housing denver, is to toss a heated addition onto your property and record that with the assessors office.

Your home sizing jumps to an equivalent of the next segment higher, or several segments higher, and like magic, the avm utilities line you up equivalent with superior housing.

Or in the case of a human researcher whom cuts straight to agla narrow range search criteria within a mile rather than judging visually with stature, height, building materials, very local proximate location limits, you comp out with categorically dis similar homes.

Take a google maps street drive down MLK (martin luther king avenue) east of the Denver zoo (Colorado Blvd S). You'll see the premier customs on MLK, and then if you crawl four to five blocks N or S along the E or W side of the main MLK corridor, you'll see remarkable difference in housing quality. That's where this original topic story takes place, along MLK blvd if I remember correctly. Yet on paper some of them could technically comp out with each other. Then you get into the actual custom builders, where they operated, how home characters change over time, and well, basically one of your best research criteria is land sizes. The customs went on slightly larger lots, the regulars went on slightly smaller. Enter Denver's annoying pattern of allowing parcels to be split or combined depending on the need of the individual home builder at the time, a practice which carried on from pre turn of the last century to after the 1960's. Sometimes they offered land in such small increments, one needed more than two or three plots to put a regular sized home upon. The customs were on naturally larger plots. So that's only a general framework to start the research off anyways. In Denver, homes are worth what people say they are worth.

One has to rely in instinct and visual recognition, knowing the difference between customs, semi customs, tract homes, and occasionally the kit home or mixed quality conversion add on home as well. Being able to eye the difference of substantial home renovation vs average. Functional considerations. Furnishing. Custom landscaping. Parking! Walking score. You're not one of the cool people unless you live within three to five blocks of popular restaraunts, parks, or other fancy folk type destinations. You'll know when you're in the zone, the homeless and graphatti will make way for yuppies, joggers, people dressed in fancy business attire and an endless procession of dog walkers. If you're lucky you'll see one proudly put that bag into their hands and pick up a warm steamy, satisfied they're saving the planet and keeping the streets clean in their upscale areas. Think of it like a hand warmer is the best I can gather, otherwise the practice seems mysteriously like the dog is walking the human rather than vice versa. What do I know though, I live in the burbs. What they do in the big city will remain one big mystery to me.

Last month I had the fortune to end up in Denver again. Had my daughters and wife with me. It was an adventure in identifying the stereotypical activities and all the characters in the big city. 'Yes, we are officially in denver. There is the hooker or at least a highly inappropriately dressed lady, there is the auto wreck, the man getting arrested, bum on the corner, beggar, gangsters, punks, scary looking people, overly nice fashionistas and the occasional city professional buzzing too and fro, young love, and old love too. Every time, without fail. Colorado is reportedly the second most dangerous state in the union of late, mostly due to concentrated Denver crime, much of which is not officially reported. Yet what I found most fascinating were the tamed pigeons which came right up to me like my bff bird friends. Of course I thought of the pigeons are not real theory but dismissed that off hand as that simply could not be true. Yet, it got me thinking... Anything is possible in Denver, you never know. They were not normal pigeons.

That's why the little enclaves here and there matter so much. It's a different animal in terms of appraising than anywhere else. Denver's zoning code is among the most complex zoning codes in the country. If you're an appraiser in doubt for comparable valididty, or a concerned reviewer, look no further than the block by block zoning code differences. In some segments the zoning is congruent. In others it changes block by block. H&B is always in play, so are property investors whom know the residents are not as informed as they are. Twice the complexity and ten times the volume of incompetent coasting on easy street sales agents, with a few pro's in the mix here and there if you're lucky enough to get their attention for more than two seconds.

 

Attachments

  • birds are not real sticker.JPG
    birds are not real sticker.JPG
    60.3 KB · Views: 3
'Yes, we are officially in denver. There is the hooker or at least a highly inappropriately dressed lady, there is the auto wreck, the man getting arrested, bum on the corner, beggar, gangsters, punks, scary looking people, overly nice fashionistas and the occasional city professional buzzing too and fro, young love, and old love too. Every time, without fail. Colorado is reportedly the second most dangerous state in the union of late, mostly due to concentrated Denver crime
And to think, in 1980 I went to a Polynesian restaurant downtown with a women dressed to the nines and we walked a half block to our car at 9pm without any concern about safety.
 
And to think, in 1980 I went to a Polynesian restaurant downtown with a women dressed to the nines and we walked a half block to our car at 9pm without any concern about safety.
I've got a meme for that.
 

Attachments

  • america is dying, country gone, corruption.JPG
    america is dying, country gone, corruption.JPG
    34.8 KB · Views: 3
Rocket sues to dismiss the case

Rocket Mortgage is suing HUD, claiming the agency wrongly holds it (and Solidifi) accountable for an independent appraiser's alleged bias in a 2021 case involving a Black homeowner in Denver. Rocket also seeks dismissal of a DOJ lawsuit which alleges the company and others undervalued a property, leading to a denied refinance. The contention is that under federal law, lenders are supposed to remain detached from appraisals, yet HUD and DOJ suggest Rocket should have corrected the appraisal. Rocket argues it followed all laws and is challenging the legal contradiction in court.

https://www.housingwire.com/article...163&utm_content=337199163&utm_source=hs_email
 
Coincidence?

 
Update: The Colorado board has revoked the license of the appraiser named in the lawsuit (see below post from a FB forum). My question to the CO board, why not sting the AMC too? And FWIW his "business model" as referenced by the CO board reads like a coaching system.

"This was sent out by the Colorado Department of Regulatory Agencies, Division of Real Estate:
“Wednesday, January 8, 2025
DENVER, COLORADO-On January 6, 2025, the Director of the Division of Real Estate, Marcia Waters, executed a Stipulation and Final Agency Order for public censure, fines, and revocation of the license for Maksym Mykhailyna, License CR.200002225. The licensee operated as a certified residential appraiser with a principal office address of 1000 Speer Blvd Apt 1409, Denver, CO 80204-4079. In addition, the licensee operated a controlling appraiser license, License CA.200002917, with the same address.
The Colorado Board of Real Estate Appraisers (“BOREA”) directed the Division of Real Estate (the “Division”), part of the Department of Regulatory Agencies (“DORA”), to conduct an investigation in response to a complaint received by the Division. After the investigation, the Division found substantial evidence of license law violations.
In part, the investigation revealed that the licensee ran an appraisal firm that improperly retained the services of unlicensed individuals located outside of the United States to complete appraisal assignments and then affixed the signatures of credentialled appraisers to the reports, often without their knowledge. This business model was not only misleading to the clients, but also to his credentialled appraisers on staff.
In a second complaint investigation, Mykhailyna, conducted substantially similar violations of license law, notably, by failing to supervise both licensed and unlicensed assistants and by submitting, and aiding and abetting the submission of appraisals that contained signatures from appraisers who did not author the appraisals.
Mykhailyna was ordered to immediately surrender the above referenced licenses and was assessed a total fine of ninety-seven thousand five hundred dollars ($97,500.00) which includes a fine and additional fee. BOREA agrees that the surrender of his licenses shall be treated as revocations under Colorado law. When asked about this matter, Director Waters indicated that “the Division of Real Estate treats all investigations with the utmost care and holds all licensees to account for violations of license law.” Director Waters also identified that federal regulatory agencies are aware of the allegations and violations uncovered by this investigation, specifically referencing a recent Press Release by the United States Department of Justice. Said Press Release can be found on the United States Department of Justice website at: [https://www.justice.gov/.../justice-department-sues...](https://www.justice.gov/.../justice-department-sues...) ”
 
Update: The Colorado board has revoked the license of the appraiser named in the lawsuit (see below post from a FB forum). My question to the CO board, why not sting the AMC too? And FWIW his "business model" as referenced by the CO board reads like a coaching system.

"This was sent out by the Colorado Department of Regulatory Agencies, Division of Real Estate:
“Wednesday, January 8, 2025
DENVER, COLORADO-On January 6, 2025, the Director of the Division of Real Estate, Marcia Waters, executed a Stipulation and Final Agency Order for public censure, fines, and revocation of the license for Maksym Mykhailyna, License CR.200002225. The licensee operated as a certified residential appraiser with a principal office address of 1000 Speer Blvd Apt 1409, Denver, CO 80204-4079. In addition, the licensee operated a controlling appraiser license, License CA.200002917, with the same address.
The Colorado Board of Real Estate Appraisers (“BOREA”) directed the Division of Real Estate (the “Division”), part of the Department of Regulatory Agencies (“DORA”), to conduct an investigation in response to a complaint received by the Division. After the investigation, the Division found substantial evidence of license law violations.
In part, the investigation revealed that the licensee ran an appraisal firm that improperly retained the services of unlicensed individuals located outside of the United States to complete appraisal assignments and then affixed the signatures of credentialled appraisers to the reports, often without their knowledge. This business model was not only misleading to the clients, but also to his credentialled appraisers on staff.
In a second complaint investigation, Mykhailyna, conducted substantially similar violations of license law, notably, by failing to supervise both licensed and unlicensed assistants and by submitting, and aiding and abetting the submission of appraisals that contained signatures from appraisers who did not author the appraisals.
Mykhailyna was ordered to immediately surrender the above referenced licenses and was assessed a total fine of ninety-seven thousand five hundred dollars ($97,500.00) which includes a fine and additional fee. BOREA agrees that the surrender of his licenses shall be treated as revocations under Colorado law. When asked about this matter, Director Waters indicated that “the Division of Real Estate treats all investigations with the utmost care and holds all licensees to account for violations of license law.” Director Waters also identified that federal regulatory agencies are aware of the allegations and violations uncovered by this investigation, specifically referencing a recent Press Release by the United States Department of Justice. Said Press Release can be found on the United States Department of Justice website at: [https://www.justice.gov/.../justice-department-sues...](https://www.justice.gov/.../justice-department-sues...) ”
The AMC hired the appraiser and it was the appraiser who decided to violate the law. Not a huge AMC fan, but they hired the appraiser and also most likely had the requirement of comply with USPAP in all of their engagement letters. The appraiser is the one who decided to mislead, etc. How were they to know that signature was affixed without the appraiser's knowledge?
 
This appraiser is in deep, his license has been revoked and the criminal charges may foolow. Another skippy bites the dust.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RCA
In part, the investigation revealed that the licensee ran an appraisal firm that improperly retained the services of unlicensed individuals located outside of the United States to complete appraisal assignments
Curious, has anyone ever considered whether PAREA opens the door to licensing people outside the US?

In the Rocket case this appraiser is being sued for appraisal bias on a report he signed. What the state is alleging here is something entirely different. I wonder had he not been licensed in CO, would BOREA and DORA have had jurisdiction over him, or would they just be making a criminal referral and going after the signing appraiser instead? I ask because an appraiser in CO alleged something similar (see below), but in that case, the company owners were venture capitalists. The liability typically falls on the signing appraiser in these situations, and the company just finds another dupe to sign off.

 
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top