ZZGAMAZZ
Elite Member
- Joined
- Jul 23, 2007
- Professional Status
- Certified Residential Appraiser
- State
- California
The subject is an 8000 sqft improvement on 2 acres atop a hill in unincorporated LA County in the Diamond Bar-Walnut-Hacienda Heights area.
I did not describe it in the first paragraph as a SFR because I'm not sure...
The original 1st floor has a 2nd floor mirrow image addition with permits. The 2nd floor addition has a bonus room that leads to a 3rd area of approximately 3000 sqft (also permitted) above the 5 car built-in garage that is attached to the 1st floor of the original unit. This 3rd area has a separate entrance, separate kitchen, and separate access to the garage below--but also integral to the 2nd floor of the "main unit" because of the bonus room.
When I discussed the property with the owner before inspsecting he continually reiterated that he and his family "uses the entire house all of the time" and in retrospect I think he was trying to convince me before-the-fact that the entire improvement is integral to the GLA rather than an ADU--or a separate SFR, or a duplex.
My gut feeling is that the proverbial market isn't going to tell me squat about this one, and my SOW includes lender guidelines extending the search radius 10 miles, but within 3 months.
This is as complex as its gets in my opinion; and the complexity probably allows me the creative liberty to call it as I see it either SFR or ADU. The owner provided County building permits for everything, and I'm thinking about visiting the County to discuss the property, but I'm not sure that anybody at the Counter will be prepared/able to pigeonhole the improvements into a definition compatible with appraisal verbiage.
Any thoughts? (and yes, I'm being well compensated, as always)
I did not describe it in the first paragraph as a SFR because I'm not sure...
The original 1st floor has a 2nd floor mirrow image addition with permits. The 2nd floor addition has a bonus room that leads to a 3rd area of approximately 3000 sqft (also permitted) above the 5 car built-in garage that is attached to the 1st floor of the original unit. This 3rd area has a separate entrance, separate kitchen, and separate access to the garage below--but also integral to the 2nd floor of the "main unit" because of the bonus room.
When I discussed the property with the owner before inspsecting he continually reiterated that he and his family "uses the entire house all of the time" and in retrospect I think he was trying to convince me before-the-fact that the entire improvement is integral to the GLA rather than an ADU--or a separate SFR, or a duplex.
My gut feeling is that the proverbial market isn't going to tell me squat about this one, and my SOW includes lender guidelines extending the search radius 10 miles, but within 3 months.
This is as complex as its gets in my opinion; and the complexity probably allows me the creative liberty to call it as I see it either SFR or ADU. The owner provided County building permits for everything, and I'm thinking about visiting the County to discuss the property, but I'm not sure that anybody at the Counter will be prepared/able to pigeonhole the improvements into a definition compatible with appraisal verbiage.
Any thoughts? (and yes, I'm being well compensated, as always)