• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

STR's

Residential Appraisers Only - Who feels qualified to perform an STR analysis?

  • Yes

    Votes: 3 50.0%
  • No

    Votes: 3 50.0%

  • Total voters
    6
After reading these posts, I can now say that I'm overly qualified to do these. Yes Chief Appraiser at AMC, sign me up.

"Chief Appraiser" and "more competent" are 2 terms which are neither mutually inclusive nor mutually exclusive. Just like any other label we could pin on an appraiser. (also applies to other labels like "USPAP Instructor" and "ASB/AQB member, too)
 
From a mortage site :Although Airbnb rentals have become wildly popular, there isn’t a loan specifically for Airbnb use. However, plenty of financing options are available with rental property investors in mind.
Understand that when trying to secure financing for an Airbnb/short-term rental property, mortgages for investment properties work differently than a loan for your primary residence.

The biggest of these is that you’ll need a larger down payment to secure the financing, usually a minimum of 15%, and you’ll likely face higher interest rates as well.
The mortgage industry is catching up to the sharing economy, with some lenders letting Airbnb hosts use rental income to refinance home loans. Until this shift, banks and other lenders would hold mortgage refinance borrowers to more stringent requirements if part of their income came from renting out their homes.
Short-term rental income from brokers like Airbnb can be high in the summer and low in the winter, depending on where you live. Many lenders saw this as an increased risk.

Although loans may have been approved in smaller numbers in the past, lenders charged higher interest rates or disqualified customers from mortgage refinancing if they wanted to include rental income in their applications.
That thinking has changed. What was considered an unsteady side gig is now a sign of stability.
As the model has been proven and Airbnb has demonstrated staying power, lenders have followed suit and are relaxing rental income parameters.

It has taken years for regulatory boards such as Fannie Mae to determine that Airbnb rental income can help pay a mortgage. Fannie Mae changed the policy in 2018, and it is now widely considered a powerful tool for economic empowerment among

My comment: In a change from the past, the GSEs do allow lenders to use Airbnb /STR to qualify a borrower. However, that is the borrower's personal or business income thing and has no more bearing on the appraisal than if the borrower claimed income from mowing lawns. Appraisers often seem to get lender guidelines confused with appraiser guidelines.

Fannie and Freddie, while allowing lenders to qualify borrowers using STR, do not want the residential zoned properties valued in the appraisal using short-term or AirbnB rents.


The way Airbnb affects value is if the area becomes popular for STR use due to being near a beach, resort, college or hip urban area. Even if tht is the case we STILL do not value a residential property using STR rents - however, we can comment that the potential to collect STR rents is baked into area prices - and cite that MLS comments are it makes a perfect ARNB etc.
 
Last edited:

This is what this AMC wants certs and licensed appraisers to use.

Scroll down to see sample.
Givem your email to look at the form.

Tell me what you think of there form.
 
Last edited:
The biggest of these is that you’ll need a larger down payment to secure the financing, usually a minimum of 15%
One of my bank clients limit non-residential to 70% LTV... with the rare exception of borrowers with other assets that are well capitalized in their portfolio.
 
STR=FF&E and an intangible value

Properly completed valuations of the STR should include all the values stated independent of each other.
 

Attachments

  • Capture.JPG
    Capture.JPG
    25.2 KB · Views: 10

This is what this AMC wants certs and licensed appraisers to use.

Scroll down to see sample.
Givem your email to look at the form.

Tell me what you think of there form.
The forms better than what most have been using so kudos to them. It's a business decision to do or not do them but if your not doing them it's no skin off your nose. There are bigger hills to die on.
 
It seems to me that an STR analysis is really nothing more than a going concern appraisal. I personally feel very unqualified to perform an STR analysis. I've never valued FF&E, I've never audited P&L's, etc. There are lots of appraisers who think it's just estimating nightly rent and multiplying by 30, and there are a lot of users who are more than happy to allow residential appraisers to hang themselves in that manner.
You are correct. The appraisal of a property operating (or is projected to operate) as a short-term rental, is the valuation of the going concern, which is made up of different assets, real property, FF&E, financial assets and intangibles.

I teach an STR class through the Appraisal Institute. I'm not trying to advertise, but to let all on this thread that there is a class out there specifically for this.
 
You are correct. The appraisal of a property operating (or is projected to operate) as a short-term rental, is the valuation of the going concern, which is made up of different assets, real property, FF&E, financial assets and intangibles.

I teach an STR class through the Appraisal Institute. I'm not trying to advertise, but to let all on this thread that there is a class out there specifically for this.
It's good you offer a class so appraisers doing STRs should know what they're dealing with.
After knowing they may not want to do it or charge premium for such appraisals.
 
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top