• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

AI Agents and Appraiser Oversupply

Yes, but almost entirely wrong...
Very funny lol

I suppose my clients over two decades feel otherwise and assign me complex assignments over properties over 10 million on teh regular because of that -
 
The GSEs will just offshore it to China

China has a population of 1.4 billion people. When robots and AI take their on jobs what is going to happen?

I typically do not agree with them on much...but worth the listen.

 
Last edited:
I still contend that the hybrid deal is bass ackwards....

" The appraiser" is the one who should be inspecting the subject, driving by the comparables, and delineating the neighborhood.

Then send it into the GSE, AI, robot in the sky to draw up the report. After all, writing up the report is the most time consuming. (I don't do rural stuff so maybe you rural guys/gals would disagree with this).

After the AI robot is finished completing the report with the comparables that the appraiser chose, in the neighborhood boundaries the appraiser chose, comparables from alternative, competitive neighborhoods due to the lack of more recent and similar sales in the immediate neighborhood.... that the appraiser chose, it would be sent back to the appraiser to review, sign, and send in.
 
*On-site observation by appraisers is going away. Floorplans and digital walkthroughs will be created by homeowners via smartphone. The majority of homes will not require any third-party observation AI might flag some properties for individual observation if it detects potential defects, but those will be completed by home inspectors, not appraisers.

*AI agents will be used in the remaining tasks including comp selection, data analysis, adjustment extraction, data input, and narrative writing. Each step can be done in a matter of minutes.

*Appraisers provide an oversight/review function. How many reports can the average reviewer complete in a day? Maybe 1 per hour?

*The process will get so efficient and cheap that GSE waivers might not even be necessary. Why waive any valuation when 24-hour turnaround and $150 cost becomes the norm?

*The profession will consolidate around a dozen or so national firms specializing in GSE work. Assume we need a capacity for 500,000 appraisals per month. That's ~17,000 per day, or ~2,100 per hour. With each assignment taking an hour, that's 2,100 appraisers needed. We might need closer to 5,000, assuming some inefficiencies. That works out to 100 appraisers per state for GSE work.

*I would say this could be less than 5 years away. All of this was probably unimaginable 5 years ago, so who knows what other advances will happen over the next 5 years.

You could say this about so many things. Lets wait and see what happens. Many people have jobs because the Govt says they have to exist. i.e, Pharmacists, family practice Physicians, Optometrists, Loan Officers/Brokers, Insurance Agents, Benefit Managers, Medical Coders/Billers, Car dealerships and salesmen, many Lawyers, etc. can all be done better/cheaper via computers, machines, AI.

Some middle men like Realtors etc. are certainly going to get pushed aside. Most provide no value. Some idiot appraisers fall into that category as well.

Facts are also that appraisals on cookie cutters in subdivisions don't really need full appraisals (often never did) especially if there is some interior hybrid deal, but that is nothing new. Everyone doing work for GSE's has been on the chopping block for quite a while.

Why is there no self services MLS website that people can make offers on houses with the click of a button, like FB Marketplace and Legal Zoom combo? Does Zillow already do this? Its gonna happen...MMWs!
 
I still contend that the hybrid deal is bass ackwards....

" The appraiser" is the one who should be inspecting the subject, driving by the comparables, and delineating the neighborhood.

Then send it into the GSE, AI, robot in the sky to draw up the report. After all, writing up the report is the most time consuming. (I don't do rural stuff so maybe you rural guys/gals would disagree with this).

After the AI robot is finished completing the report with the comparables that the appraiser chose, in the neighborhood boundaries the appraiser chose, comparables from alternative, competitive neighborhoods due to the lack of more recent and similar sales in the immediate neighborhood.... that the appraiser chose, it would be sent back to the appraiser to review, sign, and send in.

No one should be 'driving by the comparables' anymore. This is a retarded exercise that adds almost no value in 99% of cookie cutter deals. Lots of inefficiencies causing us to cut our own noses off and pushing our clients to Hybrids. You think they are driving comps on Hybrids? And no one give a ****. Whats the damn number!?!?!!?!?

We gotta get rid of these old dogs running things now. Their inability to think outside the box and be honest about what we do and how easy it has gotten, is going to be the ruination of our industry.

If a Hybrid Appraisal can cut all these corners, why in H*ll would we me making an updated 1004 that is requiring all the same old tired crap that NO ONE reading, nor cares about? You know how many processors ordering appraisals have no IDEA we drive comparable sales for photos. In my area, we spend all day taking pictures of gates...and charging dearly for the inconvenience.

One page, that's all we need. And yes, there are going to be fewer of us but we need to be advocating the importance of Certified Appraisers STILL looking at the property in person...everything else does not matter.
 
Last edited:
There is a lot of value in driving neighborhoods. Over time, if appraisers don't get out regularly they won't know these markets as well except via overhead maps. Unfortunately, I don't think users will care or pay for it.
 
Our lending overlords have apparently figured out that the function of commuting to/from the subject, physically inspecting and driving comps isn't worth the same pay/hr that the analytics and report writing is worth.

Uber drivers get paid to drive, but the pay that goes along with driving doesn't amount to $50/hr.
 
I still contend that the hybrid deal is bass ackwards....

" The appraiser" is the one who should be inspecting the subject, driving by the comparables, and delineating the neighborhood.

Then send it into the GSE, AI, robot in the sky to draw up the report. After all, writing up the report is the most time consuming. (I don't do rural stuff so maybe you rural guys/gals would disagree with this).

After the AI robot is finished completing the report with the comparables that the appraiser chose, in the neighborhood boundaries the appraiser chose, comparables from alternative, competitive neighborhoods due to the lack of more recent and similar sales in the immediate neighborhood.... that the appraiser chose, it would be sent back to the appraiser to review, sign, and send in.
The number 1 issue with these automated appraisals that I have seen is they select the comparables for you.

Test out aloft. Appraisers can be in denial if they want, but AI photos does a better job than appraisers do....appraisers are stuck on C3.
 
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top