BankThink
FHA: 60 Years of Mission Failure
In "
Recent Attacks on FHA Are Wrongheaded" (Dec. 19), John Griffith of the Center for American Progress blindly repeats the FHA’s idealized and sanitized version of its history.
This hagiography ignores 60 years of wrongheaded policies perpetuating mission failure—the selling the American dream of homeownership, but delivering despair.
In 1992 former HUD attorney and senior analyst Irving Welfeld summed up the Federal Housing Administration’s history when he wrote in his book
HUD Scandals: "Mention the Department of Housing and Urban Development and the word
scandal comes to mind." He is in good company. Outlined below are a few examples of reporters, authors, and commentators across the political spectrum who have pointed out how the FHA’s poorly designed underwriting policies have resulted in financing failure for working-class families and a plague of foreclosures for working-class communities.
In 1954, as documented by Welfeld, FHA was targeted by the FBI for involvement in fraudulent home improvement schemes.
In 1962 the FHA’s mounting foreclosures were noted by
Time magazine when it observed "Homeowners of a new and unattractive breed are plaguing the Federal Housing Administration these days. Known as ‘
the walkaways,'they are people who find themselves unable to meet their mortgage payments—and to solve the problem simply move out their belongings at night, drop their house key in the mailbox and disappear. … Because it underwrites low-cost housing for high-risk groups, the FHA’s problems are particularly acute."
It is time for the FHA and its supporters to put the interest of working-class families ahead of real estate agents and other interest groups who want to expand its abusive lending practices.
www.americanbanker.com