• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Final inspection

Status
Not open for further replies.

Albert2

Sophomore Member
Joined
Jan 18, 2021
Professional Status
Certified Residential Appraiser
State
Tennessee
I am completing a final inspection on a conventional loan. The listing indicated that the HVAC had to be installed but would not be installed until closing as it has been stolen several times. I completed the appraisal subject to the HVAC being installed and operating. The agent called yesterday and said that the condenser would be on site tomorrow… during our discussion he said that he needed for me to come out at a certain time because they were going to take it away after I took pictures. I told him it has to be installed and working and that I have to check it for operation. He told me that he had other appraisers that just accepted it the way he is asking. What is wrong with people? I am not asking for advice, I am just wondering if anybody else has ever had this situation. I am finding that appraisers get penalized by this industry for doing the right thing.
 
They can build a cage around the unit so that it cannot be stolen. Must be a sorry neighborhood to have to secure same and if someone is going to live there... well, why would it not be stolen when they go to work?
 
The agent said they already did that, and someone came and broke the cage, and it was stolen.
 
Wow.
I had a similar situation (broker admitting that they were going to change it after I left). My response to the realtor was, "you will be fine with my telling the lender that and put your name to it, right?"

If I had a dime every time I was told, "other appraisers are ok with that".......My response is always, "great! Then you will have no problem finding another appraiser to sign off on it."
 
Yes, when you hold them accountable they sing a different tune.
 
Theft of HVAC units is VERY common in the Austin, TX are where I live and work, I have had PLENTY of lenders agree to let me go back to the property AFTER it has closed and sometimes the new owners are already occupying the property, ask the client/lender who you are completing the appraisal for if that's an option.
 
I think the agent’s beef is that the mortgage company requires a final inspection three days before closing, at least that’s what the agent said. I am not in this business to make real estate agents happy.
 
rI think the agent’s beef is that the mortgage company requires a final inspection three days before closing, at least that’s what the agent said. I am not in this business to make real estate agents happy.
Worrying about the closing being delayed- understandable
Asking the appraiser to deceive their own client-unacceptable
 
Let the lender escrow a couple thousand bucks. Send you out after closing and release the escrow. Easy peasy. But at the rate they are stealing them. You better be standing there when the installer gets done.
 
If they are selling the loan onto one of the GSE's, tell your client to avail themselves of a 1004D alternative. From the selling guide –

Form 1004D and Completion Alternatives​

Form 1004D

The Appraisal Update and/or Completion Report (Form 1004D) is used to update an appraisal or provide confirmation that the requirements or conditions in an appraisal report have been met (such as completion of construction or repairs).

The appraiser can complete the Completion Report section of Form 1004D based on an on-site visual inspection of the property. The appraiser may also complete the form based on alternative methods, such as virtual inspections, digital photos, site videos, or other technological solutions. All completion documentation must include one or more visually verifiable exhibits. A link to the digital exhibits from within the form is acceptable but must be accessible by Fannie Mae for the life of the loan. These exhibits must be unaltered and able to be authenticated using metadata and the geocode for the subject property.

See B4-1.2-04, Appraisal Age and Use Requirements, for certifications completed by substitute appraisers.

Attestation Letters

Fannie Mae also permits other completion alternative methods - attestation letters - to verify completion of construction, alteration, or repairs in lieu of Form 1004D.

Borrower/builder attestation letter: For new or proposed construction, a letter is permitted to confirm the property was completed and constructed in conformity with the plans and specifications, amendments, and change orders. The borrower/builder attestation letter must include (at a minimum) the following items:

  • borrower name,
  • property address or legal description if the address is not available,
  • certification language that the property was constructed in conformity with the plans and specifications including any amendments or changes,
  • signatures and dates by the borrower(s) and builder, and
  • exterior and interior photos of the property (see B4-1.2-01, Appraisal Report Forms and Exhibits).
If a letter signed by both parties is not obtainable, then a Form 1004D completed by the appraiser is required.

Borrower attestation letter: A letter is permitted to confirm completion of certain alterations or repairs for existing construction. The letter must include (at a minimum) the following:

  • borrower name;
  • property address;
  • certification language that the alteration or repair was satisfactorily completed;
  • signatures and date of the borrower;
  • visually verifiable exhibits of the completed work; and
  • one of the following
    • signature of the qualified professional,
    • a professionally prepared report, or
    • paid invoices for the alterations or repairs.
When either of these attestation letter options is used, a link within the letter to any digital exhibits is acceptable but must be accessible by Fannie Mae for the life of the loan. These exhibits must be unaltered and able to be authenticated using metadata and the geocode for the subject property. The letter and all documentation must be retained in the loan file.

Criteria for Use of Form 1004D and Completion Alternatives

Use of Form 1004D and completion alternatives varies depending on the type of valuation method and condition (completion, alteration, inspection, or repair) that must be verified.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top