That happened to me in San Antonio with Flagstar. Its been 6 years ago but the subject was say about 2,800 square feet in an average 1,500 to 2,000 square foot range neighborhood. Slight over build, so there were no comps in the neighborhood in that size range so we widened our search and found three good comps within one mile and used them. A reviewer comes back cuts the report in half and uses three comps like 1,100 SF, 1, 300 SF and something like 1,500 SF? None in the subject size range. Also, no deduction for functional obsoles. due to the overbuild, etc. He also made numerous errors in his analysis. I'm a reviewer myself, so I reviewed his review and sent it back to Flagstar and also turned the reviewer into the state for standards violations in the review. In the end, I never heard from them again, game over for that company.
