• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

How would you deal with this? Conventional assignment.

Here's an AI answer.

Soot on Roof from Stove​

The presence of soot running down the roof of a wood-burning stove is a sign of a significant issue, primarily indicating excessive creosote buildup within the chimney flue. Creosote is a flammable byproduct of incomplete wood combustion that deposits on the inner walls of the chimney as the hot gases cool, especially when temperatures drop below 250 degrees Fahrenheit. When this buildup becomes substantial, it can appear as a black, tar-like substance running down the chimney cap or roof. (Based on the picture, it's not running down the chimney cap).

Several factors contribute to this problem. Burning unseasoned or wet wood is a common cause, as it produces more smoke and unburned particles, leading to rapid creosote accumulation. The design and insulation of the chimney system are also critical; if the flue liner extends too far out of the roof without proper external insulation, it cools quickly, promoting creosote formation. A poorly insulated chimney allows the flue gases to cool too rapidly, which is a primary reason for excessive soot and creosote deposits. Additionally, a chimney that is too short or not positioned high enough relative to surrounding structures can experience downdrafts, pulling smoke and soot back down the flue.

The situation is dangerous because creosote is highly flammable. A layer of creosote just 1/8 inch thick significantly increases the risk of a chimney fire, which can damage the flue, spread to the home's structure, or allow carbon monoxide to enter the living space. The presence of soot on the roof is a clear warning sign that the chimney needs immediate attention.

To address the problem, the chimney must be professionally swept to remove the accumulated creosote. It is also recommended to ensure that only dry, well-seasoned hardwood is burned and to maintain a hot, brisk fire to promote complete combustion. Inspecting the flue for proper insulation and ensuring the chimney is adequately tall and clear of obstructions are essential long-term solutions. If the issue persists, a professional chimney sweep should be consulted to assess the flue's condition and recommend necessary repairs or modifications.
 
he chimney must be professionally swept
Bull****. I clean my own chimney, and it requires a bit of work but is not something only a professional can do. that's like saying you must hire a professional lawnmowing service to mow your lawn.
 
Bull****. I clean my own chimney, and it requires a bit of work but is not something only a professional can do. that's like saying you must hire a professional lawnmowing service to mow your lawn.
That was the AI answer.....AI doesn't do manual labor :)
 
Bull****. I clean my own chimney, and it requires a bit of work but is not something only a professional can do. that's like saying you must hire a professional lawnmowing service to mow your lawn.
That's right cowboy. You make your own moonshine with the wood you just axed for your still. How was the corn crop this year that you planted for your shine.
 
The picture speaks a thousand words:........"we have a problem Houston".
 
That's right cowboy. You make your own moonshine with the wood you just axed for your still. How was the corn crop this year that you planted for your shine.
cleaning a flue is something rural folk have done for a century or more. It's not brain surgery. Country people built barns, roofed their own home and often picked out the trees from their own place for the wood cutters to saw up into lumber. My nephew is remodeling my parent's old home, and much of the lumber there was cut full 2" x 4" for wall studs and rafters, and is everything from Red Oak to Chincapin. I have helped my dad build barns and sheds, I've reroofed houses for other family members, and we built fences, hung doors, replaced window panes with putty and glass cutters.

Until 10 years ago, I cut and split my own wood without a wood splitter, and I have installed metal roofing on a number of barns on the farm. I built my own well house 30 years ago and will be tearing it down this fall but hiring that due to my knee. City people cannot change a light bulb without an electrician. Poor you.
 
I was kind of surprised by Tom's remark being a house flipper and all. He of all people should know you've got to get in there and get your hands dirty.

There's a lot of people like Terrell on the forum. It's just that we're getting old and we're are not physically able to do all the things we used to do.

Getting back to the topic at hand, even me being a city boy and not dealing with wood burning stoves, can see that there's obviously something wrong with that chimney.
 
The stove may could stay, but something is not right in that chimney. Probably not a major fix. Just put in new pipe or whatever and forget cleaning that one.

I don't know what they been burning in that stove.

The roof needs addressed for marketability.

I am not licensed to tell anybody how to fix it.
 
Last edited:
I could do an EA on roof won't impact marketability and look like an idiot. LOL
 
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top