• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

I'm Conflicted - Should I Do These Reports?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Has anyone ever just asked these people why they are paying someone else to take the pictures instead of the appraiser? Has anyone asked these people why they would want the report quality to be diminished by using pictures taken by Realtor's kids? We all know it is about money but they won't admit it or even discuss that.

Has anyone asked these people if they know how many times the term "credible assignment results" is mentioned in USPAP?

"We all know it is about money but they won't admit it or even discuss that."

Of course it is....
Haven't you taken the time to read the posts left by AF members for the past decade???

AF member question:
Why is the sky blue?
AF member answer:
I can't believe $275.00 for a full appraisal....

AF member question:
What is your favorite food?
AF member answer:
You can't buy food with the fees paid to the appraiser!!!!

AF member question:
Any question regarding minimum wage?
AF member answer:
Hurts the economy...and why haven't our fees increased since the 1980's???

We all agree and know that it's all about the money!!!! :)
 
These are USPAP compliant provided you do the necessary disclosures. That being said, you really have to a. Know the market AND the neighborhood like it was your back yard and b. The property has to be very typical of the neighborhood. If any of these are off, decline it.

Also, budget at least an hour each. I am in good with the one AMC I use and I have told them I don’t have time for them and to only give them to me in a pinch
 
Also, budget at least an hour each. I am in good with the one AMC I use and I have told them I don’t have time for them and to only give them to me in a pinch
Not trying to be a ****, but if you only have to "budget at least an hour" why only ask for them to only give them to you "in a pinch"? (honest question, not trying to be cynical or facetious - I haven't done one of these types so would like to hear more about it from those who have) If they're something so "easy" that can be done in an hour, why wouldn't one want to do that?

I'm still pretty skeptical of these type of assignments (personally) so haven't done any nor sought out any clients who offer them.
 
Michigan and Terrel caught on to the hypothetical assignments I posted to start this discussion.

Other responders blew right through, focusing on the wrong elements.

I wrote what I wrote on purpose to distract people, and it worked!

It's not about the money, market knowledge, software, time spent, or working in PJ's in your basement and bunny slippers.

When 'someone' you don't know writes part of "your" report, and you sign it as the licensed appraiser (with E&O), how does that square with your responsibility under USPAP to allow an unlicensed 'someone' to do Appraisal Practice - especially a person you have not supervised? (Yes, from my reading of USPAP, collecting data, taking photos, and writing comments IS Appraisal Practice when a valuation report is being done. This is not the same as a real estate agent including property data in a listing.)

Then, even though their name might be shown in the report, fail to disclose that 'someone' as providing Significant Appraisal Assistance in the web-based form report?

It is my view that appraisers are being fed a dump truck load of bovine substance with these report requests. They go by many names, because there are multiple entities promoting them............."enhanced desktop" and "Hybrid Appraisal" are just two I have heard about. But people who contact you asking if you will do them may have other names or descriptions.

The first question you need to ask is WHO collects and provides the subject property information? The usual response is "we have a field inspector do that." And they won't tell you who the 'field inspector' is.

These kinds of reports are NOT THE SAME as a traditional 'desktop' appraisal done ENTIRELY by the appraiser.

Let's be careful out there.
 
Indeed you do not know who the field inspector is, you either feel their inspection results ( an exterior photo and field notes ) are reliable enough to use, or you don't. I said in my post on this thread that these are bifurcated appraisals, since somebody else inspects.

USPAP does not require photos, nor an inspection . It also does not specify that an only appraiser can inspect or drive by a subject or comp and take photos. It is clients or users that require the appraiser inspect/drive by the comps. The appraiser must disclose assistance by others in report .

Curious you created this thread to point out these are not the same as a traditional desktop done entirely by the appraiser, which is obvious. Then you write it's not about the money, when you asked if you should do them because you need 5k to pay for braces.
 
Last edited:
Then you write it's not about the money, when you asked if you should do them because you need 5k to pay for braces.

His opening post was a "hypothetical" situation of an appraiser faced with doing these reports.
 
I tried my 1st one last week...
While I'm not conflicted...I'm not sure I'll want to do them often...
These kinds of reports are NOT THE SAME as a traditional 'desktop' appraisal done ENTIRELY by the appraiser.

Let's be careful out there.
UC did one and wasn't conflicted, so it must be okay. :rof:
 
15-july-aug-2015-days-work-fsl.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top