• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Prudent?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 142783
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In the case cited in the OP, a value of $102,000, or even $103k would be very well supported. You have a sale that just closed for $100,000.
In my market that closed sale would have been under contract at least 30-45 days ago, so at about +2% a month, that would easily adjust to $102-103k.
It's right there in front of you. There is no mystery here.
 
your name is PushinValue... call it at $105 and be done with it!


-edit-

i was going to read this thread until i got to the 7th post by the (AGIAN) top poster of the month, jgrant... on page 2... and like i expected it has become a jgrant vs everyone thread about opining values vs market value vs whatever other crap gets dredged up... again...
 
Last edited:
Total BS on your part. Read the OP post one, where he talks about the way to hit the 102k is by fudging adjustments and using less similar sales ! Can you not read? Read the very first post in this thread.
What in the heck are you talking about? Per the OP, the comps are exact model matches in identical condition....there are no adjustments to fudge!

Condo complex with only one model.

12 sales a year

Three comps 1 closed on the effective date 100k 2.sold one month ago for 98k 3. Sold 3 months ago 96k 1pending at 102k

No other similar complexes

All identical condition with no concessions
 
Did you not read the post # one in this thread? The op cited sales in project of same units of 96k, 98k and only one at 100k. They alluded to reaching 102k by fudging adjustments and using less similar sales.
Because they are apparently worried about some of the nonsense that people like you shovel about not coming in above the highest closed sale. Using the last 3 comps in the project along with an appropriate date of sale/time/market (whatever you want to call it) provides more than enough support for a value of $102,000 (assuming that the facts given in the OP are correct - including the rate of appreciation). There is absolutely no need for any other comps (assuming that this is an established, not a new project).

Anyhow, I am done with you in this thread, have a nice night.
 
In the case cited in the OP, a value of $102,000, or even $103k would be very well supported. You have a sale that just closed for $100,000.
In my market that closed sale would have been under contract at least 30-45 days ago, so at about +2% a month, that would easily adjust to $102-103k.
It's right there in front of you. There is no mystery here.

Then you are adjusting today' ( as of eff date) MVO ) up to future appreciation rate would result in. .

I am happy to appraise to a higher SC price if some other closed sales similar to subject support it and/or qualities of subject itself. Due to only appreciation...very questionable but as we see from some posts here, number hitting is alive and using future appreciation as the support. Good luck with that in a forensic review down the road.
 
Then you are adjusting today' ( as of eff date) MVO ) up to future appreciation rate would result in. .

I am happy to appraise to a higher SC price if some other closed sales similar to subject support it and/or qualities of subject itself. Due to only appreciation...very questionable but as we see from some posts here, number hitting is alive and using future appreciation as the support. Good luck with that in a forensic review down the road.
I know I said I was done with you in this thread but can't resist one more post since your last post is even more clueless than your prior posts.

First of all, the adjustment today for appreciation has nothing to do with future appreciation but is made to reflect current appreciation, which is estimated based on the current pattern of appreciation going back in time over the past 12 months. You say that "you are happy to appraise to a higher SC price if some other closed sales similar to subject support it" which makes if obvious that you won't go above the sale price of the highest closed comparable sale in your appraised value opinion, no matter that the market is strongly appreciating as of the effective date of the appraisal.

Let's flip this problem on its head....what would you do if you appraising in a quickly declining market with with a 24% rate of annual depreciation (-2% month) and the last 3 sales of model matched in the subject's project were 3 months ago $100k; 2 months ago $98k; 1 month ago $96k, current pending sale at $94k? Using your logic that you applied to an appreciating market, then your appraised value could not possibly be less than $96k unless you could find a comp that sold for less than that....of course you come up with some nonsense of why it does not work that way in a down market, but it will only further expose your biases.

Check mate. Game over, thank you for your participation.

Now I am done with you in this thread
 
TMD can do as he pleases as far as response, but support for a value whether higher or lower is the same set of problems only in reverse.

Do other indicators, such as recent closed most similar sales and intrinsic qualities of subject indicate the MVO of a pending sale price? In close call situations it is not easy. ? Rate of appreciation or decline is one factor in a MV opinion but not the only factor.
 
Then you are adjusting today' ( as of eff date) MVO ) up to future appreciation rate would result in. .

I am happy to appraise to a higher SC price if some other closed sales similar to subject support it and/or qualities of subject itself. Due to only appreciation...very questionable but as we see from some posts here, number hitting is alive and using future appreciation as the support. Good luck with that in a forensic review down the road.

What the hell are you talking about "up to future appreciation rate"?

Market is appreciating at +2% month, sale that closed today for $100,000 was under contract 30-45 days ago. I adjust +2-3% from the CONTRACT date, which is in the PAST.

And I won't need your "good luck" in a review.
 
We are providing the credibly supported market value opinion to our client, we are, not telling a buyer what to pay.
Never said that. The contract came first. The market indicator is telling us.
 
However the most similar sales ALSO indicates 100k. That is why 100k is the better supported value.
Not really. The market is in a 24% increasing trend. All the sales support 102k.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top