• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Revision Request

Status
Not open for further replies.
So how do we categorize an ROV with sales that were already identified and addressed in the original report? If they were already there...why did I get asked to consider them AGAIN? Does that jive with the "appropriate" language? Shouldn't take an MAI to notice they are already there...but it might take one to determine one of those should have been given more consideration. I agree in principle with where DW and GH are coming from but something still smells funny.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DTB
What would your response be to the allegation that you mismeasured the home that the borrower thinks is 2200 sf even though your report says that's how big your measurement came out to? You'd respond that you already did that - right? Or not, because some appraisers don't think you have any obligation to defend your work on account of the fact that you have a license and are thus presumed infallible.
 
AFAICT all the mania about ilking all requests as external pressure so you can sue them is nothing more than the passive/aggressive revenge ploy against the AMCs for your fees. As with all your other complaints, if you were getting what you thought was a fair fee you would take more seriously the idea that the job isn't done until your users have concluded that the work is sufficiently credible for their usage.

Nobody - including none of you - is actually concerned that values are being *unethically* increased on a regular basis in response to correction requests or ROVs. You're just mad about your fees.
 
To be clear: Allegation that I mismeasured even tho the measurement is the same as the person's making the allegation? (not real clear but good enough)
I'd seriously question the competence of the person passing that issue along. In my experience, a simple phone call or email is never sufficient...it must be addressed in the report. Infallibility has nothing to do with it. Fee notwithstanding...it's ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
What would your response be to the allegation that you mismeasured the home that the borrower thinks is 2200 sf even though your report says that's how big your measurement came out to? You'd respond that you already did that - right? Or not, because some appraisers don't think you have any obligation to defend your work on account of the fact that you have a license and are thus presumed infallible.
I would be happy to remeasure. Send me an order for that service and I'll get right on that.
Same with an ROV. Send me an order for that service and I'll get right on that.
If they're trying to do something to me that is illegal, I'll turn them in.

Not rocket science. I don't know why that is so hard to understand :shrug:
 
AFAICT all the mania about ilking all requests as external pressure so you can sue them is nothing more than the passive/aggressive revenge ploy against the AMCs for your fees.
LOL, crash & burn.

Strike 1. I never said that all requests were external pressure
Strike 2. I never suggested suing them
Strike 3. I have never complained about my fees, which have always been high.

So from this post, AFAICT...you've been tapping into Danny's Koolaid.
Next batter up.
 
Last edited:
AFAICT all the mania about ilking all requests as external pressure so you can sue them is nothing more than the passive/aggressive revenge ploy against the AMCs for your fees. As with all your other complaints, if you were getting what you thought was a fair fee you would take more seriously the idea that the job isn't done until your users have concluded that the work is sufficiently credible for their usage.

Nobody - including none of you - is actually concerned that values are being *unethically* increased on a regular basis in response to correction requests or ROVs. You're just mad about your fees.

LOL - you got that right fo sho. Especially when the requests come in when the client is mad about a value that does not serve their goal. Especially when non-compliance usually results in a loss of business. Especially when there are supposedly laws against this stuff. So yea, the crap fee is definitely salt in the wound. I would be happy to explain things to the end of days for the right price.

We are part of a system. That system has need of balance. Our fee is part of that balance. The amount of work we provide for that fee ought to be part of the balance too, but lately falls quite short.

Home inspectors get more than us, for less work.
Surveyors get more than us, for less work.
Neither of these industries has a client base that sends blast orders to all of their competitors for each assignment.
So, when our fee is crap, and it appears our fee is being compromised by actions that could be illegal, then yea, we are going to get upset and raise a stink. None of this changes the appraisers obligation to report independently, but to say these things don't possibly and likely eventually have an adverse affect on that, would be to ignore human dynamics.

This crap is a problem and it should end.
 
So if it's the fee then complain about the fee. Don't complain that the 6 stips for stupid housekeeping stuff and the ROV with the stupid sales data is the problem when the problem is really the fee.
 
I would be happy to remeasure. Send me an order for that service and I'll get right on that.
Same with an ROV. Send me an order for that service and I'll get right on that.
If they're trying to do something to me that is illegal, I'll turn them in.

Not rocket science. I don't know why that is so hard to understand :shrug:

Actually, you did misunderstand the example I cited, so maybe it was hard for you.

The example I cited doesn't involve a discrepancy between what you measured vs what they claimed. I worded it that way to equate to the ROV that cites the same sales you used in your report - i.e. no actual disagreement with those facts.

As for you not even considering the possibility you made a mistake (which is apparently how you read the question), I take your response to mean that you would rather just leave a possible error out there unless you get paid to fix it. Again, relating the performance to the fee. I understood that part just fine.
 
LOL, crash & burn.

Strike 1. I never said that all requests were external pressure
Strike 2. I never suggested suing them
Strike 3. I have never complained about my fees, which have always been high.

So from this post, AFAICT...you've been tapping into Danny's Koolaid.
Next batter up.
First facts were fake news, now Mr. Wiley's facts are Koolaid. This world keeps getting curiouser and curiouser! Alternative facts are getting more popular! :eyecrazy::rof:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top