• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Rural Counties

Status
Not open for further replies.

wyecoyote

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2002
Professional Status
Gvmt Agency, FNMA, HUD, VA etc.
State
Washington
After many years of working exclusively at the Assessor’s office I decided for personal reasons several months ago to get back into the fee side. Dip my toe so to speak. Couple months back I had an AMC send me a e-mail asking if I covered a certain county and what my fee would be. It was a county that I had originally started appraising in plus an area where I visit often due to family members. A Rural County, with a population of about 75K people. I quoted a high fee that I thought would just send them away. Really didn’t want to go there and visit and work at the same time. Unfortunately they accepted the fee. Wasn’t bad pre REO appraisal no real “comps” just sales and listings. Since then this company has sent me one a week in that County. I continue to quote what I perceive as high fees to go there. I got to thinking which can be dangerous was if they were willing to pay this to go there who else would pay. I contacted a client that sends me some work once in a while about including that county as a coverage area. They basically stated that I could quote whatever I wanted. They do not have someone that really covers that area. When I told them what I was charging the other company. They said that was pretty in line or less than what they were paying other appraisers for the area.

So my question is have we lost Rural appraisers in the market area or is this mostly an anomaly? Looking at it years ago when I was appraising there was about 4 appraisers. Now none are listed. Most come from a county away. Down south of that county there used to be 9 appraisers now listed 4. This is also a county listed on the VA list of an area they need appraisers.

I have considered at this point the possibility of selling and relocation to this area. My wife has been out of work for the past year which is why I have considered this change and why I have gotten back into the fee world. The timing is obviously an uncertain of what the future holds. Just really more curious has the number of rural appraisers decreased over the past couple years?
 
has the number of rural appraisers decreased over the past couple years?
decreased and deceased over past ten. And some of us simply quit accepting secondary market work especially in rural area because no one was willing to pay decent fee for the extra work and worse yet, the extra stips from jerk underwriters who didn't know a well house from a dairy barn.
 
I work two rural Counties... one of which has some really remote areas. AMCs are happy to pay $450 - $600. Banks start at $550 and go up as much as I quote. I don't take advantage of this for either AMCs or banks (or non lenders.) It's tough doing the market analysis and finding sales not to mention lots of driving time (through gorgeous areas with no traffic and no stop signs.)

It's slow right now but I've heard that from a lot of folks. Still, a couple or three or four a month and I'm happy (have a 2nd contract job that pays the basic bills.)
 

Attachments

  • boggs lake.jpg
    boggs lake.jpg
    289.1 KB · Views: 15
Things have been slow the last couple of months and one of the appraisers in my office who has appraised some large recreational ranches has been trying to get into that market. Everyone he’s talked to said rural/agricultural appraisers are booked 1-2 months out. I remember sitting next to a couple of guys at a USPAP class a few years ago. They were all agricultural appraisers in rural areas and the average age was probably over 70. One guy talked about retiring soon and he was going to be throwing out decades worth of files. I got the impression that most of them didn’t want to take on a lot of work so they might only take on a couple of jobs a month.

I got a commercial job from an AMC and right after I signed up on their website and indicated I cover the whole state I got a call about appraising a mobile home in a small town along the freeway about two hours outside of Albuquerque. I told the guy on the phone I didn't do residential and he sounded like he was pretty hard up to fill that order as there might only be one or two appraisers that cover that county, most probably located 50 miles away in the next closest "city".
 
A Rural County, with a population of about 75K people. I quoted a high fee that I thought would just send them away.


You call that rural? I just finished a small r/w project in a county with a population of 7,200, LOL. Yeah, comps sucked there too but there were no underwriters to contend with.

I think you may have hit on a niche market and could make some decent $ if you're up to the challenge. If you can satisfy the AMCs and are adept at fitting square pegs into round holes, you could become the local specialist. Before long you'd know all the sales in the area and have pretty good productivity.

As far as fees, so far this year I've quoted "I don't want to do it" fees on 2 or 3 occasions and they said yes. And when I told them I needed payment up front, they sent checks in advance. You can't get rid of some people.
 
Glad to hear of your successes. My main county is somewhat rural and at one time commanded higher fees. Then the urban county became over supplied with appraisers who would accept work here at a small increase of their local work. None were members of the local MLS and were often producing poor work by relying on just one MLS.

Sometimes our competitors ruin it for all.
 
Sounds like of course it is location dependent as how the local appraiser population is doing. The fee's I've been getting are 1.5-3 times what I would get in my local market. The one bank I talked to said they are paying minimum $1,000 or more for the county for a 1004. For 2055's there wasn't much of a price difference. This from the bank for what they are paying. I am surprised that there are not more appraisers coming from a county just to the north. Working there of course the number of counties covered would have to grow. It's not like the local market. We used to cover 5 counties when I started down there. Basically to the coast and back to the mountains. One of the counties does have a small population 4,000 people. Is that rural enough?

Fun thing is there usually are no real comps more sales and listings. Not unusual to include 6 properties in a report. It is really an area that an AVM will not work. Most likely will just continue to work at the assessor office and continue on the weekend fee appraising. See how things go and consider my options.

Thanks for the replies.
 
Just out of curiosity which county is this? I grew up in the Portland area, went to school at WSU, and have family all over the state.
 
It's a niche market, no better time to stake your claim to it. I do believe there's always a decline in rural appraisers while the market is hot (like last year), but they'll start drifting back in now that things have slowed. See the same thing with sales agents. A sure sign of a change in the market is when you see an agent signs out of their home area all of a sudden.

I cover only 1 county, however most of my work is in the quieter parts of it. Bad thing is subject and comps are pretty spread out on mostly dirt roads. Good thing is there's no traffic, good fishing, you get to know the market very well and you use the same comps over and over. Verify and take pics once and then reuse them. Not to mention fees are $50-100 more than the more populated spots to the south and west and the market really doesn't change quickly. No alarming declines or increases to complicate things (at least here).

Have one on my desk right now in a rural village that I've been the appraiser on every fair market SFR sale in town for the past 18 months. Should be quick money....other than driving out there of course.
 
Just out of curiosity which county is this? I grew up in the Portland area, went to school at WSU, and have family all over the state.

Go cougs!
I'm back in Rural WA and hoping to find a supervisor. Pouring over the forums it isn't simple to find folks who are in the northwest. I'm open to tips on how to woo a supervisor to take on a newbie. We have so very few here in my county. In fact two counting my trainee license. I'm looking at bordering counties but of course those folks don't know my reputation so I feel a bit discouraged.

If you know someone in SW WA interested in a trainee with six months or so training from a Wisconsin appraiser.... or if you know that I'm up a creek and should hang up my measuring tape... I would love advice from someone who knows rural appraisal life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top