• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Three days in a row. Different GLA than advertised.

I never said it was foolproof.

To be fair, you never said appraisals were foolproof - you just implied it. :)

Have there not been Forum members who admitted in this forum that they alter measurements so the GLA matches the tax card?
Well, one for sure I know that admits that.
 
I never said it was foolproof.

To be fair, you never said appraisals were foolproof - you just implied it. :)

Have there not been Forum members who admitted in this forum that they alter measurements so the GLA matches the tax card?
I was just getting ready to cite Mr. Fernando's post when he described the need to revise a sketch so the living area equals Assessor info. So yep. He is the "peers" to whom I refer in all situations when a discrepancy is evident--ANY kind of discrepancy. Yep.
 
I was just getting ready to cite Mr. Fernando's post when he described the need to revise a sketch so the living area equals Assessor info. So yep. He is the "peers" to whom I refer in all situations when a discrepancy is evident--ANY kind of discrepancy. Yep.
Consistency is very important for a reliable report. All appraisers know that.
 
Accuracy and honesty are what is important for a reliable report! Consistency is what is needed from report to report. That is what professional appraisers know.
My sketch has disclaimer that it's accurate but not guaranteed. Always put a disclaimer.
Be forewarn that not all appraisers have the skills of Fernando to do what he does.
 
It's surprising that public records showed property larger than it really was; generally, it's the other way around (built without permits). I've only come across this issue a few times, so your experience is remarkable. Local building inspector not physically visiting property or plans not reviewed, or builder fraudulently misrepresenting what he was selling?? Odd.

2 instances I ran into where the actual GLA was smaller by about 12%, the builder/developer had the larger square footage in the brochure, with statement that the actual finished space may be different. The sketch on the high-rise condo revealed the size was short, and buyer renegotiated the $$$sale price.

In measuring the other new construction house in Beaumont, it felt smaller than expected, and appraisal showed GLA was short about 15%. Buyer sued seller/builder (& won $$$), insisting they were not getting the square footage they were paying for.

The 3rd case was a very old building in the Crenshaw District, where a portion of the original structure, probably a sunroom or dining area, was missing. It was clear where that indoor space had been part of the original house. That one was unforgettable, because there were very noisy wild parrots flying all over the place. Apparently some birds had escaped captivity long ago, and made that area their hangout. Soooo loud!
 
There are a lot of assumptions in that rather bold assertion. :)
One thing you can depend on - Ole DW will fight everybody on AF to defend the GSE’s honor.
I never said it was foolproof.

To be fair, you never said appraisals were foolproof - you just implied it. :)

Have there not been Forum members who admitted in this forum that they alter measurements so the GLA matches the tax card?
“Members”?? As in more than one?? I’ve not personally seen that said out here, but what kind of professional appraiser would say that?

And to be fair. A real appraisal that’s done by a real professional, is more credible than anything value related - when all is completed correctly. We are often judged broadly because of the bad apples in our midst, and that has taken a toll on us. I’ve not found the critics to be qualified to judge very often.
 
In response to the OP. There is junk data everywhere, and it hasn’t gotten better over the years.

DW has argued with me that Fan and Fred now has better sale data than anything we can see or buy. I was told they “know” the errors that exist in the information we see and use. I find that difficult to swallow, but if true, appraisers should have access to all the better data. Wouldn’t that be logical? Better data would equal more accurate appraisals for all. A “Win-Win” as Stephen Covey would say.
 
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top