• Welcome to AppraisersForum.com, the premier online  community for the discussion of real estate appraisal. Register a free account to be able to post and unlock additional forums and features.

Treasury Department Recommendations

Status
Not open for further replies.
AI’s letter also makes an important point that appraisal alternatives or “waivers” are nothing new. Leading up to the real estate crash of 2007- 2008, Fannie and Freddie were issuing appraisal waivers en masse. After the GSEs were taken into conservatorship back in 2008, it was discovered that as many as 30 percent of mortgage loans held by Fannie and Freddie had received such waivers, according to AI. Even after the crash, a separate report from the Government Accountability Office reports that Fannie and Freddie only required appraisals for 85 percent of the mortgages they purchased in 2010 and 94 percent in 2009. In other words, the GSEs have long used AVMs or waivers as alternatives to appraisals and the practice dates back to the early 2000s.

However, AI warns that Freddie’s latest move to use these tools for first purchase transactions is especially foolish. “Freddie Mac’s decision to veer away from fundamental risk management practices appears to harken back to the loan-production driven days in the years leading up to the 2007-2008 financial crisis…which turned out to be disastrous for the entire economy,” the AI warns.


http://www.workingre.com/avms-to-finally-replace-appraisers-3/


better watch out mike... you said something nice/good about AI and that will make you lots of enemies 'round these here parts...
 
I guess the adage if it ain't broke don't fix it does not apply....despite the housing market debacle, which was a hopefully once in a century event, appraisals have served the mortgage market well with very low defaults and vetted collateral for the loans allowing low to moderate interest rates for borrowers. Time to muck it all up and go hi tech and big data....big whoop will save some borrowers an appraisal fee they still will be paying exorbitant loan fees, points RE commissions etc.
 
I guess the adage if it ain't broke don't fix it does not apply....despite the housing market debacle, which was a hopefully once in a century event, appraisals have served the mortgage market well with very low defaults and vetted collateral for the loans allowing low to moderate interest rates for borrowers. Time to muck it all up and go hi tech and big data....big whoop will save some borrowers an appraisal fee they still will be paying exorbitant loan fees, points RE commissions etc.

hi tech and big data....big whoop will save some borrowers an appraisal fee

doubtful - bankers will be bankers (gimme da green), "valuation fee" = "appraisal fee
 
better watch out mike... you said something nice/good about AI and that will make you lots of enemies 'round these here parts...

Kidding? Not with Mike. Others connected? Different story. Lol

You can’t paint with a broad brush. It’s foolish.
 
What's telling is all the fuss made of consumers saving money by waiving appraisals or downsizing them to hybrids...but where are consumers saving money by digitizalixzing mortgages? I don't see anything about bankers cutting THEIR loan origination fees to save borrowers $- they'll still charge thousands in junk BS fees lol.

Looking at the final HUD statement/settlement statement on any of my transactions is always amusing. Doc fees, "underwriting" fees, title insurance for the borrower, title insurance for the lender, processing fees, fax fees, demand fees, wire transfer fees, HOA transfer fees, capital preservation fees, 6% commission total on average, etc...If borrowers understood what any of that meant they would revolt. The appraisal fee seems like a bargain..and most appraisals are completed within a week once actually ordered unless access is sketchy. In a 30 day close world, thats not a delay.
 
independent appraisers report being paid relatively
less than they earned prior to the introduction of the appraisal independence standard that
gave rise to increased use of AMCs. Appraisers in some areas may be reticent to accept appraisal
requests due to the compensation passed through to them. Delays in completing an origination or
upcharges for rush appraisals to meet closing timelines may result and are ultimately borne by the
borrower through higher origination costs.

My takeway from that is the simple notion that appraisers eschew working for AMCs, because they are paid less but the end result is the BORROWER OFTEN PAYS MORE TOTAL (origination costs.) So the solution is to double down and make appraisers make even less money with Hybrids?? Great notion. Treasury authors are idiots...another committee created stupidity

Secretary Mnuchin and Counselor Phillips would like to thank Treasury staff members for
their contributions to this report. The staff’s work on the report was led by Jessica Renier
and W. Moses Kim, and included contributions from Chloe Cabot, Dan Dorman, Alexandra
Friedman, Eric Froman, Dan Greenland, Gerry Hughes, Alexander Jackson, Danielle
Johnson-Kutch, Ben Lachmann, Natalia Li, Daniel McCarty, John McGrail, Amyn Moolji,
Brian Morgenstern, Daren Small-Moyers, Mark Nelson, Peter Nickoloff, Bimal Patel,
Brian Peretti, Scott Rembrandt, Ed Roback, Ranya Rotolo, Jared Sawyer, Steven Seitz,
Brian Smith, Mark Uyeda, Anne Wallwork, and Christopher Weaver.​

dwarfed by the lending pipeline
Perhaps not for much longer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Find a Real Estate Appraiser - Enter Zip Code

Copyright © 2000-, AppraisersForum.com, All Rights Reserved
AppraisersForum.com is proudly hosted by the folks at
AppraiserSites.com
Back
Top