Evan,
Why on earth would you want an "appraisal camera" without at least a 28mm (equiv.) lens? Seems like a waste of money to me. You said your previous Canon (which is one of my faves, BTW) gave out on you (from minor abuse, typical to the profession?), so why would you think the cheaper model will fare any better? Just some things to think about... I'm not trying to be critical, just to ask the "devil's advocate" type things to hopefully aid in thinking things through...
Anyway, it sounds like the problem is in the lens retraction system... (?) Some of that can be avoided by using a design that does not have this (very typical) type of lens assembly. There are some recently available (and another one just announced) cameras that, while being in the $330 - $400 range, may be a better VALUE for you (?) YMMV, of course.
You might consider one of the following. Both are semi-rugged designs which means they are:
- water-proof to about 30 feet
- dust-proof
- shock-resistant (5' - 6' drops)
- 28mm - 100mm+ (equiv) zoom lenses that are the non-protruding "folded lens" type that reduces the fragile moving parts that probably failed in your other camera
Available now - the Olympus Stylus SW 1030.
Detailed description:
http://tinyurl.com/5z4teq
Pricing: ($330 - $400)
http://tinyurl.com/5eouz9
Available in August - the Pentax Optio W60
Detailed description:
http://tinyurl.com/5s4smy
Pricing: ($330)
http://tinyurl.com/5pcagk
Hope this helps!
-Randall Garrett-
..Apex Software..
/end/